In general, people hold strongly to their beliefs about the big three hot-button ideas: politics, DEI, and religion. As a professor of psychology and neuroscience, I’ve studied how our brains settle on one viewpoint; even with additional knowledge or experience, we remain resistant to other viewpoints. We are reluctant to adjust viewpoints, which may be due to nature, nurture, or a combination of both.
Studies have confirmed that a specific set of religious and political beliefs, including liberalism, anti-racism, free speech, and tolerance of others, is influenced by our intelligence (Edwards and colleagues, 2024). Intelligence, as represented by various indicators, is influenced by educational duration. Education also reduces the probability of poverty. Which is more relevant, education or poverty? Recent studies, discussed below, consistently report robust relationships between educational levels, cognitive ability, low religiosity, financial stability, and liberal views (Onraet and colleagues, 2015; Rachmatullah and colleagues, 2019; Jedinger and Burger, 2022).
Education and Politics
A study using a within-family design (to circumvent environmental confounds) examined the relationship between intelligence and political beliefs using polygenic scores (Edwards and colleagues, 2024). A polygenic score is a DNA-based predictor of a person’s trait, calculated as a linear combination of estimated allele effects. Researchers took this approach because other studies show that polygenic scores can predict political beliefs such as social liberalism.
The most definitive outcome was that years of education significantly affect political beliefs. The authors concluded that intelligence causally affects political beliefs, suggesting the relationship between intelligence and political belief is not due to environmental confounding such as socioeconomic factors.
Education and Religiosity
Higher levels of education also significantly correlate with lower levels of religious beliefs and attitudes. The higher one’s educational level, the less likely one is to believe in God and to think of God as a person, the less favorable one is toward the church, and the less importance one attaches to religious values (Rachmatullah and colleagues, 2019). For example, a recent poll found that 93 percent of the current members of the National Academy of Sciences (190 of whom have won Nobel Prizes) do not believe in God. The trend in today’s culture is unusual. Religious beliefs have been a durable feature of the world’s cultures. For example, up until the nineteenth century, it is unlikely that you would meet someone who does not believe in God. Anthropologists estimate that at least 18,000 different gods, goddesses, and various animals (bulls and bears were very popular) or objects (such as quartz stones during the Neolithic) have been worshipped in some form by humans since our species first appeared. Evolution shaped the human brain to accept supernatural beliefs because those ideas helped early people survive and reproduce. Spirituality must have once offered something tangible that enhanced survival. Something has clearly changed in the past 200 years that underlies the increase in religious non-believers. There are two possibilities: greater access to education and scientific knowledge, and differences in brain structure and function between conservatives and religious groups versus liberal non-believers. I’ve discussed the first option; let’s consider the second.
Religion in the Brain
A recent fMRI study found that not believing in a God is due to activation of distinct higher-order brain networks (Nash and colleagues, 2022). The results showed that religious believers are more likely to use intuitive and heuristic reasoning, and that religious non-believers are more likely to use more deliberative and analytic reasoning. For example, non-believers are more likely to process sensory information, such as something they see, in a more deliberative manner that involves higher cortical areas, called top-down processing, involved in reasoning. In contrast, religious believers are more likely to interpret visual information emotionally or intuitively, called bottom-up processing; this involves more ancient brain systems. Religious believers share this bottom-up processing bias with people who believe in the supernatural or paranormal activity, such as telekinesis or clairvoyance. We may inherit both our brain structure and our religious and political beliefs from our parents. Therefore, nature wins over nurture. Also, separated twin studies have found only a small effect of parental beliefs on their adopted children. Future studies will need to focus on the role of specific brain structures in religious and political beliefs.
DEI
A January 2024 survey of American adults conducted by the University of Massachusetts Amherst sought to identify racism’s influence on how someone feels about diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs. This is difficult research to conduct; quantifying personal racial attitudes is not easy. Fortunately, psychologists are adept at asking revealing questions regarding hidden feelings and motivations. There were some interesting findings. First, most respondents supported DEI training in general, especially for medical professionals, teachers, police officers, and soldiers. The overwhelming majority of people with negative racial attitudes (defined by psychologists as holding prejudicial, stereotypical, or racist views) did not support DEI programs. The study reported that just under half (46 percent) of respondents who consider racial problems to be rare support DEI training. Some 62 percent of those participants who do not believe that white people have advantages because of their skin color also do not support DEI training programs. Overall, how someone views the importance of racism appears to influence how they view DEI programs.
The apparent universality of racism—generally defined as antagonism directed against a person based on their membership in a racial or ethnic group that is different from your own—around the world suggests that it may be an emergent property of brains that has survived throughout our evolution. Given that brains evolved to promote two primary tasks—survival and procreation—then racism may have been conserved as a behavior that supports one of these two goals. The most obvious choice is survival. We fear the unknown, the unfamiliar, or the unexpected. We also may fear people who do not share our appearance, genes, or behaviors. Almost without fail—and regardless of the nature of the information gathered by your vigilant brain—the brain often comes to the same conclusion: Be afraid. From an evolutionary perspective, at least, if everyone is considered dangerous until proven otherwise, you are much more likely to survive the experience and pass on your be-fearful-first genes to the next generation. Again, nature wins over nurture.
