Lifestyle

At What Age Should Your Neurodivergent Child Get a Cell Phone?

At What Age Should Your Neurodivergent Child Get a Cell Phone?

In the United States, 90 percent of kids have a smartphone by the age of 13. Perhaps even more remarkable, 42 percent of them have one by the age of 10. If you don’t like the idea of your 10-year-old having a smartphone that can access anything in the world, you’re not alone. And I’m willing to bet (something that your 10-year-old can do on their phone) that if your 10-year-old doesn’t have a cell phone, they’ve asked you for it repeatedly.

I’ll start with the cell phone because it’s the gateway to most of the other things on the internet. That little magical computer places more computing power in a kid’s hand than the astronauts had when they first went to the moon in 1969, and it has only grown more powerful with the arrival of AI chatbots. A decade ago, only about 20 percent of 10-year-olds had smartphones, so their access to other technologies and apps was far less than it is today.

Kids are growing up in a digital world, and virtually nothing that we do can prevent them from interacting with technology. My two grandsons, not even 18 months old and growing up in homes where their parents have essentially restricted them from watching television, come to visit me with an innate radar for tech. Typically, within two or three minutes, they have found the remote controls for our two televisions and turned them on. They somehow know that this electronic device gets turned on with a push, and they like doing it. These screens beckon to children, even the very young ones, and most kids are fantastic at finding their way to them.

This push, often from the children themselves, for earlier and earlier access to these technologies is a concern. It is particularly problematic for the neurodivergent kids I work with in my clinical practice. It’s difficult enough for parents, educators, and providers to manage and harness these digital technologies for typically developing children. But children with ADHD, autism, learning disabilities, and other psychiatric and learning difficulties present a different level of challenge.

What I have come to realize is that simply giving parents an age for when they should allow their neurodivergent children access is probably a poor answer to the wrong question. An age range is useful, and I will give some recommendations at the end of this post. But more importantly, we need to consider the diversity of children and their readiness to use the technology appropriately, or, at the bare minimum, to learn from the times when they don’t.

My instinct to tell parents that their neurodivergent kids should just wait longer for access to technology is understandable, but it’s also too simple and sometimes flat-out wrong. For example, there is a fair amount of evidence that some children on the autism spectrum communicate better through the slower, asynchronous back-and-forth of online platforms than they do face-to-face. For these kids, waiting longer would limit their ability to communicate. For kids with ADHD who hyperfocus on Minecraft or Roblox, it may be one of the few places they connect with classmates after school, and they may then be more accepted by them during the school day.

The simplest answer is to restrict them, to keep them away from tech. Unfortunately, that is very hard to do, and it prevents the child from developing the skills they need to interact with others online. Neurodivergent kids need a lot more supervision, an expectation that they will not automatically understand how to interact, and direct training in it. Ultimately, they will live in a world where technology plays an important role, and learning to navigate it has become a new task for good parenting.

Here are some guidelines for determining when your neurodivergent child is ready for a first cell phone and the many other internet-based technologies that come with it.

Cell phones

Minimalist phone: 10 to 12. Smartphone: 12 to 15.
A minimalist or “dumb” phone between 10 and 12 lets a child stay in touch without the dangers of the open internet. A smartphone fits better between 12 and 15, depending on the child’s developmental fit.

Fortnite

13 and up.
Fortnite is rated T for Teen, and 13 and up is our core recommendation. Often, it is the banter around the game, more than the game itself, that is hard for neurodivergent kids. If your 12-year-old’s friends are all playing, you might allow it with your supervision. Before that, Lego Fortnite, rated E10+, is a good substitute.

Parenting Essential Reads

Roblox

7 or 8 and up, with vigilant supervision of game selection.
Roblox is not a single game but millions of user-generated worlds, some perfectly fine for children and others highly inappropriate. More than anything else here, it demands parental awareness and supervision. With that in place, it can work from as early as age 7 or 8. Unsupervised use is much trickier, and limiting neurodivergent kids until age 12 or 13 may be warranted.

Social media: Instagram, TikTok, Snapchat

15 and up.
These platforms legally require users to be at least 13. Given how sensitive neurodivergent kids can be to them, we recommend 15 and up, which is increasingly the norm in countries outside the United States.

YouTube and YouTube Shorts

8 and up, with controls in place.
Shorts cannot be viewed on YouTube Kids, so they need to be supervised through Google Family Link. When parents use controls that limit the kinds of Shorts, set age ranges, manage time, and turn off the endless-scrolling feed, they can be appropriate for about age 8. Without those controls, Shorts are a real problem for focus and attention in many neurodivergent children.

Ultimately, parents need to use their judgment and understanding of their kids’ development. A great rule of thumb is to introduce technologies gradually, making it easier to increase access, but also to take them away if necessary.



Source link