Culture & Entertainment

You Can See Everything review: Nathan Fielder and Elizabeth Holmes meet their match in a gripping documentary that could make history

You Can See Everything review: Nathan Fielder and Elizabeth Holmes meet their match in a gripping documentary that could make history


Documentary cinema is having a moment. In the 84 years since the genre’s first nod of recognition at the Oscars, it has patronisingly only ever been honoured in its specialist category, with no truly non-fiction film ever making it onto a Best Picture shortlist. As the Hollywood awards season takes shape this year, though, the talk of the town is how You Can See Everything, a sublime and singular new film from co-directors Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, might be about to change that — and it’s tempting to make the case that it should win, too.

With intelligence, wit and a gripping strangeness, it depicts cult comedian and documentarian Nathan Fielder meeting his match in Elizabeth Holmes, the Silicon Valley CEO convicted of fraud, as she spends her last 34 days of freedom with her husband and young children. Released in the US a month ago, it arrives in UK cinemas with an unusual and seductive air of mystery: after the film was made in secret for three years, a surprise premiere at a small US film festival preceded massive acclaim and word-of-mouth popularity, with almost unprecedented spoiler paranoia to boot. It’s called You Can See Everything, but you can’t say anything.

Elizabeth Holmes working on a laptop in a still from You Can See Everything.

Elizabeth Holmes working on a laptop in a still from You Can See Everything. A24

This is entirely justified, as it is no ordinary work of factual film-making with talking heads or archival footage, so preserving the shock of its astonishing diversions is worthwhile. But that’s not to say you shouldn’t know some context on entry.

The film’s subject, Elizabeth Holmes, is one of America’s most compelling recent enigmas. She was once the US’ youngest self-made female billionaire as the founder of Theranos, the Silicon Valley firm that purported to sell the “iPod of healthcare”: a miniature blood analyser that could detect a huge range of issues from just a fingerprick sample. When this was not true in practice, she was found guilty of four counts of defrauding investors and sentenced to over 11 years in prison, marking a spectacular fall from the heights of Forbes magazine covers to being skewered by an Emmy-winning portrayal from Amanda Seyfried in TV miniseries The Dropout. Throughout all of this, Holmes continues to protest her innocence.

You Can See Everything has Holmes talking to the media for the first time in seven years in an attempt to rehabilitate her reputation, the thinking being from her (and particularly her husband Billy Evans, the heir to a luxury chain of hotels) that “radical transparency” and the cultural capital of indie film studio A24 will make the world see the real her. It is no spoiler to say that inviting Nathan Fielder into their home to do this was not a good call.

He’s the Canadian giant of alternative comedy behind genre-bending series like The Rehearsal and The Curse — the man heralded as one of culture’s great absurdists, satirists or illusionists. With a hint of Louis Theroux, he revels in awkward silences with eccentric interviewees, who soon wilt as if they’re being polygraphed.

In a staring contest with Holmes, though, Fielder is in a deadpan Battle Royale of wits and wills, as if two world-class con artists are playing cards. “It’s funny that I did a show about business scams and now I’m here with you,” Fielder says before trying to reach her with references to David Blaine or even a classic comedy sketch by Bud Abbott and Lou Costello. She is by far his most famous subject — and his toughest nut to crack.

An image of Elizabeth Holmes's wide eyes and smile in a screenshot from Elizabeth Holmes in You Can See Everything.

Elizabeth Holmes in You Can See Everything. A24/ IGN / YouTube

In her husband Billy, the film finds a thorny and shifty antagonist who surprisingly offers many of the most pupil-dilating moments, which are best left alone here. Co-director Lance Oppenheim, the 30-year-old Hollywood wunderkind who recently directed Robert Pattinson’s subversive drama Primetime, also proves a perfect foil to Fielder. Mostly shot in a beachside cabin, You Can See Everything is somehow both intimate and vast, as Oppenheim repeatedly sets you on edge by foregrounding dead space and showing you their camera crew, before crashing in so close to Fielder and Holmes that you’ll notice their pores as much as their character flaws.

Longtime Fielder fans will be relieved to know that alongside some withering quips and trademark drollness, proceedings take a string of characteristically left-field turns, to the point where there are shades of documentary classics like Orson Welles’s F for Fake and Errol Morris’s The Thin Blue Line, or even Hitchcock’s Vertigo.

But if that sounds esoteric, don’t worry. This is above all a relentlessly absorbing film that plays like a procedural or thriller. It’s about presentation — of the self, of truth and of performance — but also the tension between artist and subject or documentary and fiction.

If the Stateside reaction is anything to go by, You Can See Everything is set to gross over $100 million and define 2026 both critically and culturally. As you peel back the many layers of that title during an unusually justified three hours, you can see why.



Source link

Filed under: Culture & Entertainment

Selected by

Avatar photo

I studied medicine at Trinity College, Oxford, and qualified as a doctor. There are already many excellent blogs exploring faith, humanism, atheism, politics, rationalism, philosophical doubt and everything in between. But I don't intend to limit myself to any particular subject. This is simply a space where I'll share whatever comes to mind, whether it's something I've been thinking about for years or just a passing thought from the day.