Sally walks into Tony’s clothing store and pays $30 for a shirt. Tony gets the money. Sally gets the shirt. Who wins? Assuming the purchase was voluntary, both do. Tony valued the $30 more than the shirt he sold. Sally valued the shirt more than the $30 she paid. Both walked away better off.
Yet many people believe that they can identify a loser. In a 2022 paper, Win–Win Denial: The Psychological Underpinnings of Zero-Sum Thinking, psychologists Samuel Johnson, Jiewen Zhang, and Frank Keil studied how Americans judge ordinary exchanges. In their first experiment, 94.2 percent of participants thought that at least one person was made worse off in at least one transaction. Only 55.4 percent of purchases involving money were judged beneficial to both sides.
The researchers then examined two related mistakes that people often make. The first is called win–win denial, or failing to recognize that trade can benefit both parties. The second is zero-sum thinking, or the belief that one person’s gain must come at another person’s expense. In almost 30 percent of purchases involving money, participants saw the seller as winning and the buyer as losing.
This “fixed pie” intuition may have an evolutionary explanation. For hundreds of thousands of years, Homo sapiens lived in small groups where food, territory, and status were contested. A piece of meat consumed by one person could not be eaten by another, for example.
Cognitive scientist Pascal Boyer and political scientist Michael Bang Petersen argue that our economic beliefs often draw upon mental systems that evolved under conditions of severe scarcity. Those systems help us recognize threats and cheating, but may mislead us when thinking about modern markets, where millions of strangers cooperate through trade.
Economic circumstances also influence our understanding of market exchanges. In a 2016 study, organizational behavior researchers Nina Sirola and Marko Pitesa examined nearly 60,000 people across 51 countries. They found that zero-sum beliefs were more common during economic downturns. Their experiments also showed that making people believe the economy was performing poorly increased zero-sum thinking.
In a 2026 study involving 20,400 Americans, economists Sahil Chinoy, Nathan Nunn, Sandra Sequeira, and Stefanie Stantcheva found that people who experienced stronger economic growth during their formative years tended to hold weaker zero-sum beliefs.
Johnson and his colleagues identified another important influence on people’s perception of fairness in market exchanges: money. Their experiments showed that participants consistently viewed sellers as more likely to benefit from transactions than buyers. A seller receives money, which looks like a gain. A buyer gives up money, which looks like a loss. The goods or services received by the buyer are easier to overlook. The researchers called this intuition mercantilist, after the old economic doctrine that confused the accumulation of money with the creation of wealth.
Treating all trade as a contest between winners and losers can obscure the overall gains.
Would taking money out of the equation improve people’s perception of market exchanges? Counterintuitively, no. In one experiment conducted by the Johnson’s group, Vivian exchanged her Burger King hamburger for Tommy’s McDonald’s hamburger. Since both freely agreed to trade, economists would ordinarily infer that each preferred the hamburger received to the one that was given up. Yet only 30.2 percent of barter transactions were judged beneficial to both parties.
Why was barter even more difficult to understand than purchases involving money? In 36.9 percent of barter transactions, participants believed that neither party gained. In a normal purchase, the seller receives money and is therefore often seen as winning. In barter, nobody receives money, so people frequently fail to recognize any benefit.
Johnson’s group then considered time prices, or how long a person must work to earn the money to buy something. The survey participants were presented with the same shirt purchase in two ways. One version stated that Sally paid Tony $30 for a shirt. The other stated that Sally earned $20 an hour and worked 1.5 hours to pay for it. The transaction was identical. Only its description changed.
When the purchase was expressed in working time rather than money, participants were about 18 percent less likely to see the buyer as losing. They were also less likely to see the seller as winning. But when researchers mentioned both money and working time, the effect largely disappeared. The key to changing people’s perception, it seems, was drawing attention away from money rather than simply mentioning work.
Politicians can exploit zero-sum thinking in at least two ways. The first concerns international trade. President Donald Trump has accused foreign countries of “stealing our wealth” through trade. Vice President JD Vance has criticized inexpensive foreign products entering the United States at the expense of American jobs.
But international trade allows businesses to obtain cheaper inputs, and consumers to purchase more goods at lower prices. Competition encourages innovation and productivity growth. Those gains can coexist with losses for particular workers and businesses. A factory may close because of foreign competition even as consumers and the wider economy benefit. Treating all trade as a contest between winners and losers can obscure the overall gains.
Wealth in the American economy is usually created ex nihilo, and entrepreneurs become rich by developing products that millions of people voluntarily purchase, thus benefiting everyone.
The second concerns how individuals become wealthy. If wealth is viewed as a fixed pie, someone who becomes rich must have done so at somebody else’s expense. Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont often contrasts the fortunes of billionaires with the financial struggles of ordinary Americans. Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York once declared, “No one ever makes a billion dollars. You take a billion dollars.”
It is true that some fortunes arise from inheritance, exploitation, or government-granted privilege. But wealth in the American economy is usually created ex nihilo, and entrepreneurs become rich by developing products that millions of people voluntarily purchase, thus benefiting everyone.
What required an hour of work in 1980 required only about 18 minutes in 2025
And, of course, there is the effect of the “survivorship bias,” in which we all see and recognize the winners—Steve Jobs, Bill Gates, Jeff Bezos, Elon Musk—and ignore the thousands of wannabe entrepreneurs who dropped out of college, moved back into their parents’ home, started a company with their buddies, and then went out of business. No one writes biographies or profiles of the failed entrepreneurs. We don’t even know who they were.
On the whole, we want to keep a system that allows a handful of people to succeed wildly even while the vast majority of entrepreneurs and business owners just earn a decent living, or go bankrupt.
Can we weaken the psychological appeal of zero-sum thinking even further? My hypothesis is that showing people how much less time they must work to earn money to purchase goods and services today than was the case in the past could weaken people’s intuition that wealth is fixed. Unlike the experiments by Johnson’s group, which examined individual transactions, my proposal concerns changes in affordability over decades.
In the 2026 Simon Abundance Index, economist Gale Pooley and I measured the time prices of 50 basic commodities between 1980 and 2025. Over those 45 years, the average time price of the 50 commodities fell by 70.9 percent. What required an hour of work in 1980 required only about 18 minutes in 2025. An hour of work could therefore purchase 3.44 times as much of the measured commodities, an increase of 244 percent in personal resource abundance.
My hypothesis could be tested. Researchers could randomly assign people to examine historical commodity data, including food and fuel, expressed in three ways: nominal money prices, inflation-adjusted or real prices, and time prices. The survey participants could then be asked whether one person’s gain came at another person’s loss. If those shown long-run time prices became less inclined toward zero-sum thinking, we would obtain evidence that a different way of presenting economic information can change how people understand prosperity in general and market exchanges in particular.
The deeper question, then, is whether economic understanding can be improved by changing the unit in which improvement in standard of living is measured and evaluated. Money prices draw people’s attention to what they give up. Time prices draw people’s attention to what they gain. And what they gain is the most precious commodity of all: time. If that shift in perspective makes modern abundance easier to recognize, it may also make the modern economy easier to understand and defend—not as a fixed stock of wealth to be divided, but as a process in which knowledge, innovation, and exchange can enlarge what an hour of work can command. That possibility is worth testing.
