Secular & Atheism

Trump and Odysseus: Mirrors for Our Time

Trump and Odysseus: Mirrors for Our Time


Sometimes the hardest lessons to heed are the ones that fall closest to home. Take The Odyssey, for example. While the blind prophet Tiresias makes note of the monsters sure to cross Odysseus’s path on his journey home, his most fervent warning is to remind Odysseus to keep both himself and his crew in check. If Odysseus hopes to survive, he must learn to curb not only the reckless desires of his companions but his own. And if you’ve seen Christopher Nolan’s epic  movie, you’ll likely agree that stabbing a cyclops on your way out the door isn’t the best move for an otherwise pretty-smart guy. That said, I’ll admit to yanking my sister’s hair on more than one occasion. If we are honest with ourselves, I think most of us will acknowledge that the temptation for revenge supersedes our equanimity from time to time.

In a more contemporary prophecy, back in 2015, a friend of mine declared, “If Trump wins, he will serve as our cultural enema.” While I was startled by the crudeness of the image, I also immediately recognized the insightful nature of the comment.

A few years later, I heard a spiritual teacher describe Trump as a “fallen angel.” The image she offered was that of a fat, insecure child eagerly waving his hand in naïve yet wildly enthusiastic volunteerism when God asked, “Who among you has the courage to rudely shake the world awake?” 

More recently, during dinner with friends, someone suggested that Trump was little more than a puppet—a figure animated by forces much larger than himself. This commentary, more than any other, inspired debate with some friends suggesting an energetic goonie or some sort of spirit animal dictating his every move and others descending into conspiracy theories about hidden cabals and, yes, the Knights of Templar. 

Splintering metaphors reveal the human mind’s deep desire to find invisible agency motivating visible events. Perhaps it is easier to imagine demons, angels, puppeteers, and hidden forces than to confront the more unsettling possibility of collective participation, just as the ancient Greeks attributed upheavals to multiple gods. We sense that something larger is at work, but we struggle to name it without first personalizing it.

Regardless of the point of view, metaphors function to explain the unexplainable. And here we have three disparate metaphors, all competing for the narrative win: cultural enema, fallen angel, or puppet of a shadowy conspiracy. Whether any of these descriptive metaphors are “true” of Trump is, in some sense, less interesting than why people reach for mythic language at all.  

And during the summer of the rebirth of Odysseus, it seems we’ve all become curious about distinguishing the myth from the man. Comparing Trump to Odysseus may seem like folly, but I cannot help but chuckle at the spectacle of Trump concealing himself in a catering cart to escape death threats. The scene absurdly echoes Odysseus hiding in a wooden horse to enter Troy as a conqueror. The two scenarios could not be more different—one entering to conquer, the other escaping—yet both remind us that what matters most may be hiding in plain sight. 

It can be tricky to see the truth while we are living it; myth gives us the distance to recognize ourselves in the story, making truths that might otherwise be hard to swallow easier on the palate. Emily Wilson opens her contemporary translation of The Odyssey with a great undressing of the man himself: “Tell me about a complicated man.” With this slight shift in syntax, she demystifies the man, while ironically elevating the individual. Rather than seeing Odysseus as a larger-than-life mythic figure, the reader is encouraged to relate to his fears, flaws, desires, and dilemmas. This is the brilliance of the poem, what makes it epic—a tale that has endured across time because it invites us to imagine ourselves in those same well-worn shoes.

As the story unfolds, it becomes apparent that the man mirrors the complexity and shifting nature of the society he moves through, in which individual actions often have different repercussions than intended—but also in which the individual’s actions are constantly thwarted or thrown off course by forces much larger than himself: storms sent by gods, magic perpetrated by powerful witches, and the fallout from wars that decimate cities. In spite of his intelligence and skill, Odysseus can no more control these larger forces than one individual today—even a powerful one—can singlehandedly control the stock market or the weather. 

We tend to imagine history as something enacted by extraordinary individuals. But sociology and mythology suggest almost the opposite. Sociology has long taught us that individuals do not exist apart from the cultures that produce them. They are expressions of a larger ecology, mirrors reflecting patterns that extend far beyond themselves. Mythology, in turn, uses individuals within stories as representatives of collective experience to express lessons learned from the past and warnings to guide the future. Individuals become historically or mythologically significant when they crystallize dynamics already moving through a culture. They become mirrors for the whole rather than themselves, just as Odysseus is a mirror for the culture of Ancient Greece and the myths that both resulted from and shaped it. 

How many times must we mistake the person as the cause rather than the symbol of the truth? Whatever had been quietly fermenting beneath the surface of American life didn’t suddenly appear in the form of one individual; it became visible. Our Trump-sized cultural enema required both a symbol and an imagination. To me, this moment is less about why this person than about the relational conditions that produced the purge. 

We become so captivated by the personalities moving across the stage of history that we forget to ask what larger story is being told through them. Perhaps this is why we instinctively reach for metaphor when ordinary political language no longer seems sufficient. We sense that we are witnessing more than an election cycle or a political movement. We are watching a culture come face to face with itself.

No leader exists independently of the consciousness that produces and sustains them. Identity is relational; our sense of self emerges through countless interactions that affirm who we hope to be and distinguish us from who we fear we are not. We are, in many ways, like goldfish swimming in water, unable to fully distinguish ourselves from the environment that makes our existence possible. Life is at once collective and individually focused, literal, and symbolic—one in the many, many in the one. Perhaps this is why certain historical figures become such powerful mirrors. They reveal not only themselves, but the waters in which we are all swimming.

And today, the cultural and political waters we are swimming in feel as deep and as potentially destructive as the seas Odysseus navigates as he tries to get home. I can’t help but think of Steve Bannon’s metaphor about “flooding the zone” and how apt it is. Sometimes the bombardment of conflicting news reports, court orders, and inevitable redirects feels like a coming tsunami.

My daughter works in public health as a grants manager for a large hospital system. In early 2025, one of the largest grants she managed—a grant supporting a neurology research project with patients already enrolled—was abruptly defunded. While Madeline had long been aware of the inefficiencies, redundancies, and administrative barriers embedded within the system, she was still stunned by what felt like a bull-in-a-china-shop approach to reform. Her experience is only one small anecdote, but it reflects a pattern being repeated across institutions.

And yet, in the midst of her frustration and outrage, Madeline also acknowledged something else: Perhaps the scale of the disruption created an opportunity to rethink and rebuild systems more radically, in ways that better serve the people they were designed to help. The challenge, of course, is whether rebalancing can begin before the damage becomes irreversible. When does disruption become transformation, and when does it simply become destruction?      

Systems do not change by ignoring disruptions. They shift by integrating new awareness of the conditions that caused the disruptions in the first place. The question is not whether disruption occurs; the question is how we rise together to greet it. We heal both by integrating our new awareness of the conditions that brought us to this moment and reimagining our way toward a more healthful solution. 

We keep asking what history means. Perhaps history is about continually asking ourselves what we are willing to see, to acknowledge. Prophetic warnings aside, it is tough to take responsibility for our own actions. As the Greek myths also remind us, we don’t know what we don’t know.

My own interest for many years now has been how awakening—whether personal or cultural—often begins not with beauty, but with the unbearable experience of seeing clearly. Anyone who has ever sat quietly long enough knows that silence doesn’t immediately produce peace. Often, it first produces noise—the uncomfortable recognition of just how much activity exists beneath the surface of our awareness. Meditation reveals the mind that was already busy, just as certain historical moments function like long moments of collective awareness, as well as prolonged reckonings. That which has always been present suddenly becomes impossible to ignore.

A culture, like an individual, cannot transform what it refuses to see. As the individual sits in silence and discovers the mind, the culture encounters disruption and discovers itself. Both processes require awareness before transformation—otherwise, the disruption becomes yet one more dazzling narrative to explore or exploit. Awareness, like flour for a cake, is always the foundational ingredient for transformation. 

When we move beneath the constant activity of the thinking mind, we discover a deeper silence—a quality of awareness that many traditions describe as transcendence. Transcendence is not an escape from the reality of the material world; it is a broader perspective from which to encounter it. This quiet space does not remove us from life; it allows us to see it more clearly.

From this perspective, we begin to recognize that human beings are meaning-making creatures. We encounter the world, interpret it, and release those interpretations back into the world through our actions, relationships, and creations. Perhaps this is why even our enemies can become teachers—not because their actions are admirable, but because they reveal something we would rather not see. Vulnerable as it may make us feel, we need to see ourselves squarely in the face of our enemies. They are showing us what is possible if we give in to our crudest impulses. While it is wise to move away from ignorance, it is reasonable to learn who you are by recognizing what you are not.

This does not absolve anyone of responsibility. It enlarges responsibility.

We, like the Greeks before us, live out our own myths, searching for meaning and awakening through both our stories and our understanding of the world around us. As individuals become more aware, they contribute to the possibility of a more aware culture. We individual people act as both witnesses and actors on the grand stage of life—relationally connected as both receivers and transmitters. The individual is waking up and the culture is stretching her long arms toward the heavens signaling the seeds for an unveiling. 

Culture does not change apart from us. It changes through us. Each time we loosen the grip of fear, question our conspiracies, and cultivate greater awareness, we subtly and distinctly contribute to a healthier collective life. Our personal awakening becomes part of our shared awakening. Cultural renewal begins as an accumulation of personal acts of awakening.

In the end, it was the enduring love Odysseus carried in his heart for both Penelope and Telemachus, this longing to be reunited, that became the invisible compass that carried him home. Like Odysseus, we need to be humbled into acquiescence—called back into community through acts of our own hubris and reminded of our connection through the remembrance of love.



Source link