Secular & Atheism

Tribunal: Sarah Mullally “plainly wrong” in safeguarding decision

Tribunal: Sarah Mullally “plainly wrong” in safeguarding decision


A tribunal has rebuked the newly installed archbishop of Canterbury, Sarah Mullally (pictured, right), for her role in a safeguarding complaint against the archbishop of York, Stephen Cottrell (pictured, left).

The complaint against Cottrell was brought by a victim of sexual abuse perpetrated by David Tudor, then a vicar in Reigate. The victim was 15 when the abuse started in the early 1980s.

The victim alleged that Cottrell, as bishop of Chelmsford between 2010 and 2020, twice inappropriately reappointed Tudor as an area dean in the diocese, and wrongly praised him as a ‘Rolls Royce’ priest.

Cottrell was briefed about Tudor’s offences when he was first appointed bishop of Chelmsford. Tudor had been banned from ministry for five years in 1988 after he was convicted of sexual offences against other girls. The convictions were later quashed on technical grounds.

Former archbishop of Canterbury George Carey advocated for Tudor to be allowed to return to ministry. In 2024, Carey resigned the priesthood after Tudor was finally permanently banned from the priesthood following furthers allegations of abuse, which he did not dispute.

By 2012, Cottrell also knew that Tudor has paid £10,000 to a woman who alleged he had sexually abused her when she was eleven years old.

The tribunal agreed with the complainant that Cottrell should not have re-appointed Tudor as area dean in 2013 and 2018. The appointments were “mistaken and regrettable” and “deeply painful for victims and survivors”.

However, the tribunal concluded the appointments, and other aspects of the victim’s complaint, did not amount to misconduct by Cottrell. The victim said she was “disgusted and appalled” by the decision.

The bishop of Newcastle, Helen-Ann Hartley has previously called on Cottrell to resign over his handling of the case.

Sarah Mullally “plainly wrong” in dismissing complaint

The victim’s complaint was initially handled by the diocese of London, where Sarah Mullally was then bishop.

Mullally dismissed the complaint, only asking Cottrell for a written explanation as to why he re-appointed Tudor as area dean in 2018.

The victim subsequently appealed Mullally’s decision to the Clergy Discipline Measure tribunal. The president of the tribunal ruled Mullally’s decision was “plainly wrong”.

Earlier this month Cottrell ruled Mullally had no case to answer in response to allegations of separate safeguarding failures made against her.

Advocate for victims and survivors Andrew Graystone said the verdicts show the Church’s “internal disciplinary system is wholly compromised”.

“Last week, Sarah Mullally was effectively exonerated by Stephen Cottrell, and this week Stephen Cottrell was effectively exonerated by Sarah Mullally”, he said.

In yet another case, earlier this month two dioceses were officially warned by the Charity Commission over safeguarding failures relating to allegations of sexual abuse against then bishop of Liverpool John Perumbalath.

Cottrell knew about the allegations against Perumbalath yet still pushed for his instalment as bishop. Perumbalath was later forced to resign.

NSS: ‘CofE hierarchy rotten to the core’

National Secular Society spokesperson Alejandro Sanchez said: “When it comes to safeguarding, the Church of England’s hierarchy is rotten to the core.

“Privileging one denomination of one faith with established status is wrong in principle, but it is even more reprehensible given the Church’s dismal record on abuse.”



Source link