Years ago on the way to New Zealand for my doctoral studies, I stopped in Los Angeles to visit a friend. He organized a trip to Joshua Tree, where we hiked and camped. Come nightfall, I gazed at the stars and clouds — or so I thought. My friend pointed out that the cloudcover was, in fact, the Milky Way.
I didn’t realize our galaxy was ever visible to the naked eye, and I was deeply moved. The vast stillness of the desert, the free-roaming coyotes and the thick blanket of stars reminded me that we humans are only a tiny part of it all, yet also unbreakably connected to this stretching, expansive universe. More than a decade later, the awe of that experience remains important and vivid in my life.
Now, as a psychological scientist, I study awe for a living. Last summer, my colleagues and I asked 200 people in the UK to document their encounters with awe over six weeks. Because such experiences are often linked to a sense of purpose and flourishing, we wanted to know what mattered more: their frequency or intensity.
What we found surprised us. As we’ll explain in a forthcoming John Templeton Foundation-supported paper, those who experienced moments of awe that induced strong feelings of amazement and wonder reported a greater sense of meaning and wellbeing by the study’s end. It wasn’t how often people felt awe that mattered, but whether they had an experience which strongly evoked it.
What, exactly, happens to us when we experience awe, and what makes the feeling so significant, in such a lasting way?
We researchers know that it has something to do with feeling simultaneously small and connected to something larger. During awe, analytical thinking recedes; we simply experience, transcending the cerebral way in which we ordinarily engage with the world.
After years investigating this phenomenon, I’ve come to believe that awe offers a window into an overlooked aspect of human consciousness — one of science’s most elusive mysteries. If we can isolate and study the state of awe and similar self-transcendent experiences, we might deepen our understanding of our species, and of how we experience the world.
The problem with the thinking mind
When we think of consciousness, we imagine a conscious voice that says, “This is now” — an idea that goes back at least as far as the 17th-century French philosopher René Descartes, who famously stated, “I think, therefore I am.” But what if this thinking (literally) has led us astray?
My inquiry into consciousness started in 2015, when I began researching analytical versus intuitive thinking. Having trained as a cognitive neuroscientist during my PhD at the University of Auckland in New Zealand, I’d always prioritized the rational mind, dismissing intuition as a lesser agency — one reserved for guessing games or New Age spirituality. It’s a predictable bias: Since Descartes, the Enlightenment and the Scientific Revolution, much of Western culture has privileged logic over the supposedly mercurial feelings of the body.
It wasn’t until I began working with Dr. Miguel Farias on the psychology of religion and spirituality that I questioned my assumptions about intuition. Our research challenged the idea that religious belief is necessarily rooted in intuitive rather than analytical thinking, and made me reconsider whether the preference for rational thought might be limiting how we understand the human mind. Even for an academic like me, who saw the body mostly as a way to transport my brain from place to place, experiences of awe like the one I had at Joshua Tree seemed too consequential to ignore.
Research suggests that intuition plays an important role in how we perceive the world and make decisions, even when we’re not consciously aware of the processes guiding us. In a foundational study, neuroscientists Antoine Bechara, Antonio Damasio and their colleagues asked participants to choose cards from four decks — two advantageous and two disadvantageous. They found that subjects began showing subtle physiological signs of stress when approaching the unfavorable decks, even before they could consciously identify them as risky. The researchers interpreted these findings as evidence that the body can influence decisions before we can consciously explain them.
Psychologist Jonathan Haidt has made a similar argument about moral judgment, likening the rational mind to a press secretary: Rather than making decisions, the brain may simply explain and justify conclusions we’ve already reached intuitively. In a way it makes sense: Working memory, which supports analytical thinking, has a limited capacity. Yet there is a whole world around us that we need to take in, which the body does holistically through its various senses.
For me, these findings raised a larger question: How much of our experience of the world unfolds beyond the reach of reflective thought? And if we fail to fully study this intuitive, non-reflective dimension of our minds, how complete can our understanding of consciousness really be?
The self that thinking cannot capture
This question brought me back to an idea proposed more than a century ago by William James, widely regarded as the father of modern psychology. In his 1892 text, Psychology: Briefer Course, James distinguished between two aspects of the self, which he called the “Me” and the “I”:
“Whatever I may be thinking of, I am always at the same time more or less aware of myself, of my personal existence. At the same time it is I who am aware; so that the total self of me, being as it were duplex, partly known and partly knower, partly object and partly subject, must have two aspects discriminated in it, of which for shortness we may call one the Me and the other the I.”
In line with philosophical discussions, I developed modern definitions for the two aspects of James’s “total self.” His “Me” is what I call the reflective self-state: conscious awareness, where we think about ourselves, reflect on what we are doing or have done, interpret how we are perceived, and so on. It’s the type of thinking that can be described in language, and thus be made explicit. James’s “I” is what I have come to think of as the experiential self-state: the part of us that simply is — in the here and now, as a sensing entity.
The experiential self-state is difficult to describe, because the moment we try to put it into words we shift toward the reflective self-state, making ourselves the object of our attention once again. But this doesn’t mean the experiential self is simply an absence of thought or intention. Rather, it’s a form of awareness in which bodily sensations, emotions and sensory information come together to guide our perceptions and responses, without deliberate thought. Deep meditation offers a useful example of the experiential self-state, as does awe.
What science might be missing about awe
This distinction between reflective and experiential awareness could help resolve a longstanding puzzle in the study of awe itself. To measure the awe we feel during concerts, psychedelic trips, collective rituals, mystical encounters and the like, researchers use the Awe Experience Scale (AWE-S), a survey tool developed by Johns Hopkins University psychologist David Yaden and his colleagues.
I’ve used this scale extensively in my own research, and encountered a recurring puzzle. Participants sometimes describe feeling small or insignificant during awe, as I did at Joshua Tree, only for that sensation to give way to an overwhelming sense of connection. I wonder whether retrospective surveys capture this lasting connectedness more readily than the fleeting feeling of self-diminishment.
If so, it could be problematic. For example, in one study of nearly 500 ravegoers, my colleagues and I found that connectedness predicted how transformative participants considered their experiences, while self-diminishment did not. I suspect these seemingly contradictory sensations — feeling small yet big — may occur in a specific temporal sequence, such that feelings of connectedness remain, to the time of a survey, whereas self-diminishment does not.
My dual self-states theory offers a helpful framework: As the reflective self recedes, the experiential self becomes more prominent. Rather than contradicting each other, feelings of self-diminishment and connectedness may reflect two crucial dimensions of consciousness. As we become less focused on ourselves, this allows us to become more immersed in sensory experience, after the perceived boundaries between ourselves and the world begin to dissolve.
This distinction matters, because the way we measure awe determines what we can understand about it. If we capture only the sense of connectedness that people remember afterward, we may overlook the changes in self-awareness that unfold during the experience itself. Studying how these two self-states interact in real time could reveal not only what awe feels like, but also how it shapes and enriches our experience of the world and even the universe.
New windows into what it means to be human
Awe, meditation, and other self-transcendent experiences should not elude scientific inquiry simply because they are difficult to describe. I propose developing a psychological scale to measure the experiential self-state, so we can better understand these experiences.
Doing so would help us investigate experiences often described as ineffable, or beyond words, and ask more precise questions about powerful moments of awe that seem to deepen our sense of purpose and well-being: When does self-focused thought diminish, and when does a sense of connection emerge? Do bodily boundaries become less distinct? How do bodily signals shape our judgments before we can put reasons into words? And could becoming more attuned to these signals help us use them more effectively?
Perhaps the moments when we are least focused on ourselves — whether we are lost in music or immersed in nature — offer some of our best opportunities to understand what it truly means to be conscious.
This article was developed in partnership with the John Templeton Foundation.
The most transformative discoveries often begin by questioning the boundaries of what we think we know. The John Templeton Foundation’s Future of Intelligence venture supports research and dialogue that challenge what was once taken for granted: What is intelligence, and what might our conventional definitions miss in the worlds of plants, the cosmos, and AI? Learn more, apply for a grant, and sign up for the newsletter here.
This article The surprising science of awe — and what it reveals about consciousness is featured on Big Think.
