Employment relations in higher education institutions are shifting. The Employment Rights Act 2025 is intended to redress power imbalances between employers and their employees. But it has arrived at just the moment when AI is disrupting the wider day to day employer relations landscape.
The balance of information between institutions and their staff is changing, at pace. For a long time, university HR teams held most of the cards. They had detailed knowledge of the extensive policies and the law, and could judge the risk of a decision – what a claim might cost, how long it would take, whether it was worth contesting. Most employees didn’t have that level of knowledge.
AI has dramatically lowered the bar to mounting a grievance or lodging a claim. First, AI has made it far simpler for anyone to frame something that happened to them at work as a legal claim, whether or not that challenge is ultimately well founded. This can, in some ways, be a good thing, where AI is used to better understand one’s rights, but this is not always the case, and it has consequences for the system as a whole. Second, AI can assist with the process of submitting a grievance, reducing the workload and administrative burden of doing so.
The downsides of democratisation
Tribunal numbers were already on the increase, since the abolition of tribunal fees in 2017. We are seeing a huge increase in AI-generated grievances and tribunal claims, mirroring parallel increases in student complaints. These claims may include pages and pages of detailed citations of cases, legal arguments and references to legislation, all driven by AI. Where a tool has helped someone set out their claim clearly and identify the relevant evidence, it can genuinely help a case progress. But equally, where HR teams have to sift through thousands of words of irrelevant or ill-founded evidence to detect the genuine basis for the claim, the cost to organisations is enormous.
The less obvious but more pernicious effect is that the access to information that looks, sounds, (and may even be) legally relevant can push both sides into taking formal positions on policy and process very early on. Claimants may, for example, expect written line-by-line responses to the detail of their claim, rather than an informal discussion to see if the issue can be resolved. This raises the stakes, as well as the level of frustration, for both sides.
Moreover, while AI may accurately tell someone that, for example, a refused flexible working request might give rise to a discrimination claim, it is much less helpful on the wider context of how a claim is likely to play out, how long it will take, whether it is likely to be resolved in their favour, or how stressful the experience will be.
Enter the Employment Rights Act
The Employment Rights Act then changes the calculation significantly. From January 2027, the cap on compensation for unfair dismissal is removed. It currently stands at £123,543 or 52 weeks’ pay, whichever is lower.
The qualifying period for the right not to be unfairly dismissed falls from two years to six months. Academic probation commonly runs for longer than six months, so probation reviews become far higher stakes: a decision not to confirm someone in post can now be challenged as an unfair dismissal. Claimants will also have six months to bring a claim, rather than three.
There is also a steady drip of other changes. Employers now have a duty to take all reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment in the workplace, and failing to do so can increase compensation if a claim succeeds. Failing to follow the Acas Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures can likewise push awards up.
The tribunal system already has a backlog and is seeing a sharp rise in new claims. The latest quarterly data on tribunals shows that the current open case load for employment tribunals with single claimants currently stands at 70,000, the highest on record and an increase of 51 per cent since the same time last year.
This changes the calculation of risk in deciding how to manage a grievance that could end up in tribunal proceedings. Consider a borderline dismissal of an administrator earning £25,000. Two years ago, an institution might have gone ahead despite some procedural flaws, knowing the risk was bounded: compensation would be capped, and a hearing would take place perhaps eighteen months down the line.
From January, that claimant has six months to bring a claim. You will be lucky if the first preliminary hearing takes place within a year, and the final hearing could be three years away – during which you may be liable for lost earnings for the whole period, including the value of their pension, for someone who may struggle to find another role. An approach which treats the prospect of tribunal proceedings as an acceptable or readily quantifiable risk becomes a very different calculation.
Claims can also run while the claimant is still employed – we have seen cases take three years, with everyone still working together awaiting a hearing. Protracted proceedings can also have a significant human impact on everyone involved.
Culture, not just process
Many institutions in the higher education sector have reduced staff numbers as a result of financial pressures. Staff unions have a legitimate concern about how these processes are handled and the degree of transparency adopted. Higher education staff are already culturally well-informed and likely to be in a position to seek advice and, in the current climate, less likely to be able to shrug and move on to another role. Because the primary measure of tribunal compensation for unfair dismissal is lost earnings, someone who hasn’t found a new role has much more reason to litigate, and to hold out for a larger settlement.
None of this means universities should avoid tribunals at all costs. Sometimes litigation is the right answer, and there will be claims which cannot or should not be settled. But many of the disputes we see highlight the importance of early resolution and clear communication, particularly in maintaining trust when difficult decisions are being made.
As AI makes grievances longer and more complex, there is a risk that everyone becomes absorbed in the detail. The challenge is to cut through that complexity, identify the real issues and keep sight of the employment relationship. Now, more than ever, institutions need to be as clear, transparent and open with staff as they possibly can. Any gap an employee perceives in an explanation is likely to be filled with an assumption of bad intent. That means proper consultation, genuine attempts at informal resolution – which is also the government’s steer – and in-person meetings rather than emails.
The quality of line management and the confidence of line managers to address issues proactively is a critical factor. A university’s policies may be pristine, but managers may not always be well trained in applying them, especially if their role is interim or they are stepping up as a result of a restructure. HR can set expectations but managers need to be equipped and empowered to weigh up decisions and think through risks, and be prepared to sit down with staff and work things out, or at least offer a clear explanation of why something has been done a certain way. Fear drives people towards process; conversation and open discussion make people feel respected.
HR teams are, typically, swamped and may not always have the organisational reach or capacity within their institutions to influence practice. Many are so occupied with concerns that have already reached the grievance stage that they have reduced capacity to help resolve those that haven’t.
Nevertheless, the core task is culture change. Managers need the support and headroom to own difficult conversations, not just follow policies – and the financial penalties of failing to offer that support is now very clear. The cost of disputes justifies prioritising culture and early resolution at the highest level.
This article is published as part of a partnership with Mills & Reeve. Sign up here to receive our regular HE Counsel briefing on law and regulation in higher education.