In a memorable scene in the film “Aliens,” Ripley (Sigourney Weaver’s character) exasperatedly asks a room full of managers, “Did IQs just drop sharply while I’ve been away?” Perhaps in context the question is superfluous, but, in the real world, it is an important one, to which the answer seems to be a qualified “yes,” with a fairly strong association with social media use. What remains to be known is whether the effect is direct, and social media is sucking the intelligence out of its users; or indirect, in that something that social media encourages people to do also reduces IQ. The evidence tends to support the second, although the first cannot be discounted.
The “Flynn Effect” refers to the fairly consistent rise in intelligence test scores throughout much of the twentieth century; a rise that averaged around three IQ points per decade, at least across many industrialised nations1,2. However, since the 1990s, there have been reports of a slowing, or even reversal, of this trend in several of those developed countries, including Norway, Denmark, Finland, the United Kingdom, and the United States3-5. This phenomenon has become known as the “Reverse Flynn Effect.” Data from more than 700,000 Norwegian military conscripts have shown that IQ scores increased among those cohorts born up to approximately 1975, but subsequently declined among later cohorts4. In the USA, this decline appears to have accelerated from the turn of the century5. Reductions in IQ scores are observable within families, with younger brothers often scoring lower than older brothers4. This finding suggests that something in the environment, rather than genetic factors, is responsible for the reversal – now, what has become a major aspect of the environment since the millennium?
The emergence of social media has coincided with this reversal of IQ scores. Digital platforms, such as Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Snapchat, and X, have come to play an increasing role in people’s communication and social lives, and this has led some to examine the relationship between its usage and the Reverse Flynn Effect6-8. It is a well-rehearsed argument that correlation does not demonstrate causation, but there are strong theoretical reasons to suggest that social media is more than just a trivial correlate in the weakening of the collective intelligence of the planet. In particular, there are several social media impacts on basic cognitive processes that could well reduce IQ scores.
One pathway that could link social media use to the Reverse Flynn Effect concerns ‘attention fragmentation’. Social media platforms are designed to promote rapid, brief exchanges. Users frequently switch between tasks, notifications, videos, messages, and hyperlinks during a session. Such digital environments may weaken people’s ability to sustain attention and concentrate7. In fact, evidence indicates that excessive social media use is associated with poorer attentional control and weaker executive functioning, particularly among adolescents and young adults6,7. As many intelligence tests, particularly those assessing fluid reasoning and problem solving, require prolonged cognitive engagement, reductions in sustained attention could negatively affect test performance.
Another potential mechanism involves changes to reading habits associated with social media usage. Throughout much of the twentieth century, intellectual development relied heavily on reading books, newspapers, and other complex texts. In contrast, social media tends to encourage shorter forms of communication, rapid scanning of information, and fragmented information processing9. It is possible that reduced engagement with deep reading may limit the development of vocabulary, comprehension, and abstract reasoning9. This argument is particularly relevant because evidence from the USA indicates declines in verbal reasoning and vocabulary-related cognitive domains, while some spatial abilities have remained stable or even improved5.
“Cognitive offloading” refers to the tendency to rely on external devices or online systems to perform mental tasks that previously depended on memory or reasoning10. Digital technologies allow immediate access to information, reducing the need to retain facts or to engage in extended retrieval from memory. While such technologies could theoretically speed things up (although people’s experiences with the social systems now relying on such technology may, anecdotally, be at odds with this suggestion), extensive reliance on external information sources may reduce the exercise of working memory and problem-solving abilities. Analysis of the large American Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development dataset has shown relationships between social media use patterns and reduced cognitive performance; higher levels of social media engagement being associated with poorer outcomes in some areas of memory and cognitive functioning11.
It is worth noting that the relationship between social media use and cognitive performance appears to depend on the type and quality of social media engagement5,6. Educational or intellectually stimulating online activities may support language development and learning. In contrast, excessive passive consumption, compulsive scrolling, and social media addiction are associated with poorer attention, working memory, and executive functioning6,7. Such evidence suggests that the way in which social media is used, rather than the social media itself, is the key thing impacting IQ declines7.
A counterargument to the hypothesis that social media is making people less intelligent is that it is not intelligence, per se, that is affected. Rather, the cognitive skills on which IQ tests rest may be used less frequently and, therefore, become less developed. The problem with this view is that it assumes that IQ is different from this set of skills, whereas IQ may well be exactly this set of skills – in other words, there are not the skills and the IQ, the two are the same thing.
Thus, current evidence suggests a plausible and complex relationship between social media use and the Reverse Flynn Effect. Certainly, the reversal of IQ gains appears to be driven by environmental influences, and the rapid growth of social media represents an important environmental transformation over this period. Mechanisms involving attentional fragmentation, reduced deep reading, cognitive offloading, and altered learning practices provide theoretically compelling explanations for an association. While the empirical evidence remains incomplete, and social media may not be the sole cause of declining IQ scores in some nations, it certainly doesn’t look like it has helped much!
