Secular & Atheism

Should Democrats work with Robert F. Kennedy Jr.?

Should Democrats work with Robert F. Kennedy Jr.?


It’s been just shy of two weeks since the Democrats won a decisive victory in the 2026 Midterm Elections. As of this writing, they have won 256 seats in the US House of Representatives (compared to the Republicans’ 169) and 55 seats in the US Senate (53 Democrats and two independents who caucus with them), with one remaining race outstanding in Alaska that looks likely to go Democrat as well. This was such a huge victory that it’s been dubbed in some quarters the “blue tsunami,” with states that haven’t gone Democratic in decades, such as Texas, Mississippi, and Kansas, electing Democrats to the Senate. Every statewide election in Texas—yes, Texas!—was one by Democrats, and in January the state will have its first Democratic governor since the 1990s. It really is one of the most dramatic electoral upsets that I’ve ever seen, and I’ve paid attention to politics since I was in high school in the late 1970s and early 1980s. Here in my own home state of Michigan, we elected Abdul El-Sayed, a man born of Egyptian immigrants and the first Muslim ever elected to the Senate who ran on a promise, among other things, to promote Medicare for all and rebuild public health. Whether or not you agree with Medicare-for-all is less important to me than that an MD-PhD physician who at a very young age ran public health departments in Detroit and Wayne County is going to the Senate. This is a public health physician, and he is not alone. Another Senator-Elect, Dr. Annie Andrews, is a pediatrician.

I realize that Science-Based Medicine is supposed to be all about the science behind medicine and is dedicated to arguing for the viewpoint that the best medicine is medicine that is based in science as much as possible. However, we are not so naive as to believe that politics doesn’t matter. Indeed, if there’s anything the last nearly seven years since the pandemic have taught us, it’s that you can’t separate politics from medicine—or science in general. Indeed, I’ve long documented how antivaxxers slowly co-opted the Republican Party since 2009 or so in the name of “freedom” and “parental rights” until the GOP became, in essence, the antivax party, a status that became entrenched during the pandemic. This evolution resulted in the movement of the political center of gravity of the antivax movement from vaguely on the left to being very clearly on the far right, with the antivax movement becoming ever more radical. Then came Trump 2.0. In return for his bending the knee and abandoning his independent Presidential campaign to endorse him, Donald Trump appointed longtime antivax activist Robert F. Kennedy, Mr. to be Secretary of Health and Human Services, in a move that I characterized as an extinction-level threat to public health. (Go back and read what I wrote; if anything, I wasn’t pessimistic enough.) Sadly, it wasn’t just a threat to public health, but to medicine, biomedical science, and science in general as well, as the last 20 months or so have shown.

The election of Democrats to power with such large margins gave those of us who advocate for science-based vaccine, public heath, medical, and biomedical research policies hope that, at long last, there might be some accountability. Indeed, I keep hoping that my new Senator ends up on the Senate Health, Education, Labor & Pensions (HELP) Committee, where he will be able to roast RFK Jr. during committee hearings. There was even talk during the campaign of potentially impeaching RFK Jr. So it depressed me to see this article in the New York Times on Friday by Sheryl Gay Stolberg entitled, Kennedy’s Future: Will Democrats Try to Impeach Him, or Actually Work With Him? The blurb? Most Democrats abhor the health secretary’s stance on vaccines, but some see an opportunity to win voters from his MAHA movement by joining with him on food and environmental issues. Elsewhere, the AP published an article entitled Democrats are weighing impeachment of RFK Jr. while courting his supporters.

My first reaction upon reading the article was, as you might have predicted:

I realize that Democrats are politicians. I realize that a not insignificant number of them don’t have the greatest record when it comes to supporting public health and science-based medical policy. Even so, right here, right now, in 2026, as a whole Democrats are far more aligned with science-based medicine than Republicans. My facepalm, therefore, comes from the idea that people who should have learned better seem to think that they can separate RFK Jr.’s antivax views, belief in quackery and pseudoscience, and general grifting and corruption from the “popular” parts of his agenda and win over disaffected MAHA acolytes in numbers large enough to matter, or to outweigh the anger that supporters who want RFK Jr. held accountable for the devastation he has inflicted on public health, biomedical research, and drug regulation. Reading these articles, I was immediately drawn to think about other efforts to “work with” MAHA by well-meaning but naive science-based public health doctors and how doomed to failure I viewed them. As our very own Dr. Jonathan Howard pointed out, some of these MAHA acolytes advocated the execution of public health doctors and officials for supposed “crimes” against humanity.

Before I tackle the question of whether Democrats and science-based medicine advocates should even consider working with RFK Jr. on anything, though, let’s take a look at another development from last week:

The US has lost its measles elimination status, and RFK Jr. bears a large share of the blame

Towards the end of last week, a number of depressing headlines darkened my doomscrolling feed. Here are a few representative examples:

I could list more, but you get the idea.

So, what does it mean that we as a nation have lost our measles elimination status? What is measles elimination status anyway? According to this KFF article:

According to the guidelines developed by the U.S. and other PAHO member states, measles elimination has been defined at a basic level as: “Interruption of endemic measles virus transmission for a period greater than or equal to 12 months, in the presence of high-quality surveillance.” By contrast, measles is considered endemic in a given area if there is continuous transmission over a 12-month period.

PAHO stands for the Pan American Health Organization. According to its LinkedIn, PAHO is:

The Pan American Health Organization (PAHO), founded in 1902, is the world’s oldest international public health agency. It provides technical cooperation and mobilizes partnerships to improve health and quality of life in the countries of the Americas. PAHO is the specialized health agency of the Inter-American System and serves as the Regional Office for the Americas of the World Health Organization (WHO). Together with WHO, PAHO is a member of the United Nations system.

So this upcoming declaration by PAHO is a big deal, the more so because, prior to this determination, the US had maintained its measles elimination status since 2000:

Despite setting multiple goals since 1966, the U.S. did not officially achieve measles elimination status until 2000. Verification of elimination was carried out first through internal CDC and external expert review of U.S. strategy and programs to address measles, and epidemiological data on cases and vaccinations, which were compared against predetermined benchmarks for success. In March 2000, the National Immunization Program at CDC convened an external panel of experts to review the available data, and the panel concluded that criteria for elimination had been met, and officially stated that measles had eliminated from the U.S. Subsequently, a process was undertaken to re-verify U.S. elimination status in 2011, when the CDC’s National Center for Immunization and Respiratory Diseases assembled panel of external experts to review available evidence on U.S. measles programs and epidemiology since 2000. The panel agreed that measles elimination had been maintained, issuing a final report in March 2012. The U.S. has continued to review measles elimination status over time, including through an external expert committee known as the U.S. National Sustainability Committee for the Elimination of Measles, Rubella, and Congenital Rubella Syndrome.

For example, during the 2011 re-evaluation, measles elimination status was deemed to have been maintained because:

  • There were fewer than one reported measles case per 10 million population;
  • The great majority of measles cases were imported from areas outside the U.S. and most imported cases did not lead to further spread inside the U.S. – over the study period, 40% of cases were found to be imported;
  • The number and size of measles outbreaks over that period were small: a total of 64 outbreaks (median 4 outbreaks/year), with a median outbreak size of 6 cases. Only 16 outbreaks included 10 or more cases;
  • Measles vaccination rates among children had been sustained at high levels (>95%) over the study period, with no significant differences in coverage by race/ethnicity;
  • Data from national surveys indicated that population immunity to measles was above the “herd immunity” threshold; almost all age groups had seropositivity rates for measles antibodies over >95%, and;
  • Programmatic data on laboratory testing and case investigation performance indicated that U.S. surveillance adequately and quickly identified measles cases and transmission chains.

To boil the definition down to its essence, hopefully without oversimplifying, measles elimination status means that herd immunity has been maintained at a level that measles could not continuously spread endemically at a sustained level for 12 months. That did not mean that there weren’t outbreaks, sometimes fairly large, such as the Disneyland measles outbreak in 2014-2015 and the measles outbreaks in 2018-2019, both of which lasted several months before petering out, but it did mean that, thanks to vaccination programs, public health surveillance programs, and “natural” post-infection immunity in older adults, such outbreaks tended to be self-limited in under 12 months.

Going into the PAHO meeting last week, there were a number of indicators that suggested that the US had lost its measles elimination status, including:

In 2025, the U.S. had more reported measles cases, outbreaks, affected states, and deaths than in any year since 1992, and measles outbreaks have continued to occur in 2026. The pace of reported measles cases has fluctuated from early 2025 until November 2026, but there have been continual outbreaks and more states affected over that time period. A higher percentage of cases since 2025 have been due to local transmission vs. importation compared to prior years indicating local transmission has been the primary source of reported cases. Further, U.S. MMR vaccination rates have continued their steady decline and in many locations across the country levels of vaccination are below that needed for herd immunity… 

Compared to the elimination period of 2001 to 2011 discussed above, these metrics are notably worse. There were 64 measles outbreaks in total over ten years (2001 -2011) but in 2025 there were 48 outbreaks, and there have been 43 new outbreaks in 2026 through November 13. While 40% of measles cases were likely imported in the 2001-2011 period, in 2025 just 10% of cases were likely imported and just 4% in 2026 (meaning more local transmission chains). There was one measles death over ten years during the elimination period, while there three in 2025 and eight reported by states in 2026 to date (CDC data only lists 6, after changing the way it counts death reports from states). Many of these 2025 and 2026 data points are also worse than those from 2019, when U.S. measles elimination status was last threatened. For example, from January to October 1, 2019 (by which time the large outbreaks centered in New York had been contained), there had been 1,249 total measles cases, and 22 total outbreaks across 17 states; 2025 and 2026 have far surpassed those numbers.

In fairness, it must be noted that the earliest measles outbreaks in this chain that has apparently led to our loss of measles elimination status occurred in west Texas before Donald Trump once again assumed office and before RFK Jr. became HHS Secretary, as I described when they were happening. Contrary to efforts of RFK Jr. and the administration to wipe its hands of responsibility for our loss of measles elimination status, however, just because the problem started before you assumed office does not mean that you have no responsibility for it when it gets out of control. Once you assume office, pre-existing problems become your problems, and if those problems start out relatively small and potentially manageable but grow to be out of control to the point where the whole country loses its measles elimination status, you can’t escape a large part of the blame. This is even more so looking at history and how RFK Jr. has been a rabid antivax activist since at least 2005 and during the pandemic became a key force falsely demonizing the COVID-19 vaccines, which in turn led to more parents distrusting vaccines in general, including routine childhood vaccines, like the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine.

Let’s look at what a competent—and, of course, not-antivaccine—HHS Secretary and federal administration would have done to contain the west Texas measles outbreaks and then compare it to what RFK Jr.’s CDC and HHS actually did. While it is true that most public health programs are the responsibility of states and local governments, the federal government is indispensable in providing guidance, funding, and support to deal with such outbreaks.

A competent pro-public health HHS Secretary would have mobilized every agency under his command to do at least these things:

  • Promote clear, relentless, and consistent messaging urging people to be vaccinated and to vaccinate their children, given that effective “herd immunity” requires approximately 95% vaccine coverage.
  • Promote clear, relentless, and consistent messaging about the risks of measles, including pneumonia, neurologic complications, and even death
  • Send vaccines and public health workers to areas with the lowest vaccine coverage.
  • Fund and protect the public health workforce.
  • Improve surveillance to identify cases early and carry out post-exposure prophylaxis and exclude cases from school and daycare.
  • Provide science-based medical care for those with measles and avoid unproven treatments

Let’s just say that, although RFK Jr. (sort of) did some of these things initially, you could hardly call his pro-MMR messaging and advice that parents vaccinate their children strong or clear. As I described, although he would grudgingly recommend the MMR vaccine as the “best” way to prevent measles, his message was never clear and unambiguous. He always qualified it. For example, as both Dr. Howard and I pointed out, in early March 2025, then newly minted HHS Secretary RFK Jr. published an op-ed Measles outbreak is call to action for all of us. On the surface, it appeared to be pro-MMR, but it was full of antivax tropes. As I put it, RFK Jr. had not betrayed antivaxxers or gone pro-vax. For example, after recommending vaccination in a manner that reminded me of a child being forced to apologize for something he did wrong and does not regret, RFK Jr. couldn’t resist qualifications to his recommendation for vaccination, emphasizing that the decision to vaccinate is a “personal one,” while downplaying the importance of the MMR in favor of, well:

Tens of thousands died with, or of, measles annually in 19th Century America. By 1960 — before the vaccine’s introduction — improvements in sanitation and nutrition had eliminated 98% of measles deaths. Good nutrition remains a best defense against most chronic and infectious illnesses. Vitamins A, C, and D, and foods rich in vitamins B12, C, and E should be part of a balanced diet.

As I also noted at the time, it was important to note what RFK Jr. didn’t do. Specifically, he didn’t do what past HHS Secretaries and CDC Directors did in the face of measles outbreaks or outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases. He didn’t urge families to vaccinate their children. He didn’t mobilize mass vaccination efforts and public messaging campaigns about the vaccine. He just said that the MMR is the “most effective” way to prevent measles spread without actively encouraging vaccination. (Hell, he barely passively recommended vaccination.) It was because he couldn’t promote vaccination. Even if he could have brought himself to say explicitly that the MMR vaccine is safe and effective and doesn’t cause autism (or all the other things he’s claimed that it causes), MAHA had long framed vaccination solely as an individual choice without regard to society at large.

As KFF put it:

HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. has downplayed the risks of measles and has provided mixed messages about the importance of vaccination compared to alternative treatments for measles. In January 2026, then Deputy Director of CDC Ralph Abraham stated that the measles outbreaks experienced by the U.S. were “just the cost of doing business…we have these communities that choose to be unvaccinated. That’s their personal freedom.”

In addition, as regular readers know, the claim that improvements in sanitation and nutrition had reduced the death rate from measles by 98% before the vaccine is a longstanding classic antivax narrative designed to imply that the vaccine isn’t necessary. Also, holy hell! “Died with, but not of, measles?” That’s pure antivax dogwhistling, in which he’s clearly implying that most people with measles didn’t actually die because of the measles but of something else. (In other words, the implication is that the disease isn’t as deadly as normally thought.) We saw a very similar narrative about COVID-19 about dying “with” COVID-19 and not “of” COVID-19; it was nonsense too. The same is true of the implication that nutrition can protect you from measles.

Then, of course, RFK Jr. violated the bullet point about providing science-based care to those suffering from measles, offering in his official response a recommendation that vitamin A can treat measles. He even flew to west Texas after the death of a girl from measles and touted inhaled steroids to treat measles, which it does not.

I could go on and on about RFK Jr.’s response to that initial outbreak, but there’s so much more that he’s done since then that has directly degraded the federal government’s programs in public health, vaccination, biomedical research, and science in general. I’ve written about the carnage so often that I don’t feel the need to repeat it here, other than to note that RFK Jr. is antivax to the core and, consistent with that, dedicated to getting rid of pesky regulations that interfere with the promotion and the sale of unproven and disproven treatments by unscrupulous quacks. That’s what MAHA is all about; well, that and soft eugenics that seeks to limit healthcare costs by emphasizing your “patriotic duty” to stay healthy.

But Democrats want to work with RFK Jr. on MAHA priorities

Let’s circle back to the original topic; Should Democrats, flush with victory, forego holding RFK Jr. accountable in favor of courting MAHA by working with him on select policies? As I like to say whenever topics like this come up, I’m not a politician, nor do I have much training in political science. I have, however, been paying attention to such issues, but the science and the politics, going back over 20 years. Let’s take a look at the (seeming) dilemma.

First off, RFK Jr. was apparently not chastened, or, if he was, is hiding it well in order to project an attitude of bravado:

It is not exaggerating to say that Stephen Miller is a white supremacist, and his appointment signals that this administration is doubling down…likely on everything, including MAHA. That being said, let’s look at the NYT’s introduction to the situation:

The question now is whether Democrats will use their new majorities in Congress to try to push him out.

Many want to investigate him, saying his vaccine agenda and handling of measles outbreaks have put American lives at risk. Some, including Senator-elect Annie Andrews of South Carolina, want to impeach him. Senator Angela Alsobrooks, Democrat of Maryland, wants Mr. Kennedy removed, but has not said how.

“The time is now,” Ms. Alsobrooks wrote on X the day after the election. “RFK Jr. must resign or be fired. End of discussion.”

But others want to work with Mr. Kennedy in areas where they can agree. They believe his food and environmental policies, which have run into roadblocks with the Trump White House, have a natural home with Democrats, and they see a chance to win over some of the health-focused coalition that helped propel President Trump to a second term.

Personally, as you might imagine, my views lean towards those of Sen. Alsobrooks, but she faced immediate pushback:

Ryan faced immediate pushback from the neurodivergent community, because of course he did. RFK Jr.’s relentless promotion of two lies, first that thimerosal-containing vaccines cause autism and second that MMR causes autism, served as the basis for all manner of “autism biomed” quackery that have harmed autistic and neurodivergent people. This messaging has also contributed to the idea that autism somehow means that an autistic child is not the parents’ “real child” and is therefore somehow less than a human being.

While it seems true that certain proclaimed values of MAHA, such as improving access to nutrition and exercise and acting to decrease health threats in the environment, such as pesticides and other pollution, in reality, however, there is an irreconcilable clash in the ideologies of MAHA and public health. As I’ve described many times, MAHA, in essence, rejects the very idea that there is a “public” component to health. MAHA is, at its core, very individualistic, putting nearly sole responsibility for one’s health on the individual and downplaying the role of society and collective action in contributing to health. For example, public health advocates for social reforms that address social determinants of health that MAHA all but ignores, at best paying mild lip service to them. For example, MAHA has done nothing to address food deserts or to ensure that everyone has adequate health insurance and access to care. It has basically ignored one of its supporters’ biggest concerns, with RFK Jr. basically shrugging his shoulders when President Trump issued an executive order entitled Promoting the National Defense by Ensuring an Adequate Supply of Elemental Phosphorus and Glyphosate-Based Herbicides.

Yet, apparently certain Democrats think that co-opting fear mongering about glyphosate will bring MAHA onto their side. To reinforce this view, the NYT cites two former Democrats who are now MAHA activists:

Two prominent MAHA leaders, Vani Hari, a cookbook author and healthy eating activist who calls herself “the Food Babe,” and Zen Honeycutt, an environmental activist who founded the group Moms Across America, are former Democrats who followed Mr. Kennedy into Mr. Trump’s camp. Both say they vote the person, not the party.

“I’m frankly tired of reporters asking me, you know, whether I’m loyal to the Republicans, whether I’m loyal to the Democrats,” said Ms. Hari, who was a delegate for Barack Obama at the 2012 Democratic National Convention. “I’m loyal to my children.”

On the day after the election, Ms. Honeycutt joined a webinar for leaders of MAHA Action, a nonprofit advocacy group that supports Mr. Kennedy. She implored Democrats to join forces with the secretary.

“I just urge every Democrat that is considering working against him to sit down and talk with him,” she said. “I think you’re going to love him. I think you’re going to enjoy working with him.”

I’m not at very familiar with Zen Honeycutt, other than her penchant for referring to Girl Scout cookies as “full of toxins,” but I am familiar with Vani Hari, a.k.a. The Food Babe. We at SBM were writing about her long before she was MAHA. Indeed, I was referring to her as the “Jenny McCarthy of food” in 2014! Hilariously, back then, she was known for fear mongering about a benign ingredient, azodicarbonamide, that Subway used in its bread. She characterized this chemical as the “yoga mat chemical,” the implication being that, by eating sandwiches made with the bread containing azodicarbonamide, you’re somehow eating plastic, with the no doubt intentionally-planted mental image of sweaty bodies leaving their residue all over it. Back in the day, Steven Novella discussed the utter ridiculousness of this claim not once but twice, not to mention myself and a couple of times. If they were Democrats back in the day but switched to the Republican Party, thanks to MAHA, I say: Good riddance!

Particularly annoying is how the NYT doesn’t mention any of this history behind these women. Instead, they are simply portrayed as MAHA activists who were once Democrats and might once more be enticed back to the fold, if only Democrats refrained from holding RFK Jr. accountable.

Coming back to my Senator-Elect, I must admit that El-Sayed probably has one of the more pragmatic and reasonable takes on whether or not to work with RFK Jr.:

New Democratic additions to Congress are also cautiously open to working with Kennedy and his followers. Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed, a former public health official, has called Kennedy a grifter and told the AP he wants to understand how his department made decisions over the past two years on issues like vaccine recommendations. But he said he could still collaborate with Kennedy on policies to make America healthier, on one condition.

“If he wants to be evidence driven, I’ll work with him,” El-Sayed said.

Word to Senator-Elect El-Sayed, from a constituent and admirer: I guarantee you that RFK Jr. will never be evidence-driven. Ever. Trust me. I’ve been following RFK Jr.’s antivax and pro-quackery activities since 2005, when he first came out as an antivaxxer. Let’s just say, at the risk of my pulling the “old fart lecturing da youth” gambit, you were an undergraduate at my double alma mater (undergrad and medical), the University of Michigan. RFK Jr. only invokes evidence when he thinks he can twist it to support what he wanted to do anyway. If you are truly dedicated to science- and evidence-based public health policy, then you will never find anything to work with RFK Jr. on.

Once again, I cannot emphasize this enough. You can’t separate the antivax from MAHA. It’s baked in. Nor can you separate MAHA from the man who co-opted the phrase to represent his antivax, science-abusing beliefs. His activities have contributed to the degradation of public health, our federal vaccination policy, biomedical research, drug approval and regulation, and, basically, any federal regulatory policy that should be based in science. Just as bad, even leaving science and medicine aside, RFK Jr. supports the worst policies of this administration:

How do you “work with” a man who says he wants to remove Black kids from their families & “reparent” them on farms? How do you “work with” a man who supports ICE’s tactics? How do you “work with” a man who froze US funding for global vaccines—which will lead to an estimated 500,000 child deaths?

— Prof Gavin Yamey MD MPH (@gavinyamey.bsky.social) 2026-11-14T18:25:32.840Z

I might put it differently, as a warning to Dr. El-Sayed and the Democrats: “Meet me in the middle” with a person instituting harmful antiscience policies leaves you colluding in instituting harmful antiscience policies. I say: Investigate, investigate, investigate everything RFK Jr. has done since taking charge of HHS, while doing your best to prevent him from doing more damage than he’s already done, and let the chips fall where they may.

Sadly, it is far easier to destroy than it is to build, and the last two years have demonstrated that emphatically. In well under two years, President Trump through his HHS Secretary Kennedy, NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya, and Office of Management and Budget Director Russell Vought has inflicted generational damage on US public health infrastructure and biomedical research. As I approach Medicare age far faster than I’d like to admit, I have come to the sad realization that I will not live long enough to see the damage repaired; that is, if it is repaired at all. Of course, the first requirement to repair the damage is to investigate what happened and hold those who inflicted the damage accountable. Only then can we begin to rebuild, and I hope to live long enough at least to see that process well underway. It is my hope that Democrats who claim to be for “science- and evidence-based” policy won’t screw it up.



Source link