Mohammadul Hassan was 19 years old when Myanmar Army soldiers dragged him and his two brothers from their home, forced them to kneel in the dirt, and shot them in the back of the head.
Somehow, Mohammadul survived.
A soldier then shot him again, this time in the chest.
Left for dead, Mohammadul survived that, too, and crawled back to his family. For 14 days, bleeding from multiple gunshot wounds, his family carried him through the jungle to Bangladesh, where I met him near the Myanmar border.
He was one of more than 700,000 Rohingya Muslims who fled Myanmar’s campaign of mass murder, rape, and destruction in 2017.
Nine years later, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in The Hague, the world’s highest court, is preparing to deliver a judgment in The Gambia v. Myanmar, a case that will decide whether Myanmar is responsible for genocide.
The generals in Myanmar had been planning the attacks for months and used the occasion of a militant attack on local police to launch them. My colleagues and I documented in detail, and The Gambia showed in court, that for several weeks ahead of the attacks, the military expelled aid workers to remove eyes and ears, cut all lifesaving aid to weaken the population, confiscated sharp objects from Rohingya homes to prevent self-defense, and trained local Buddhist civilians to join the attacks.
Commencing those attacks, the military laid waste to Rohingya life, razing more than 300 villages in the span of weeks and forcing throngs of women, children, and men into neighboring Bangladesh.
For years, the warning signs in Rakhine State were unmistakable. Myanmar began stripping Rohingya of citizenship and its attendant rights in 1982, and it had long imposed draconian restrictions on freedom of movement and other basic freedoms, confining Rohingya to villages of isolated poverty. You want to leave your village to go see your cousin one town over? You need express approval from the state. You want to get married? Only with state approval. You want a mobile phone? You’re going to prison, or worse.
For 15 years, I have investigated atrocities against the Rohingya in Myanmar and beyond, interviewing survivors as well as perpetrators, investigating massacres, uncovering mass graves, and working alongside communities seeking justice.
The Rohingya have taught me many things. One is that genocide does not begin with mass killing. It begins with decisions by people in power. In plain sight, leaders often pass laws that exclude, enact policies to dehumanize, and commit resources to persecute. They organize themselves. Genocide also feeds on inaction and diplomatic cover.
For years, several of my colleagues and I warned embassies, governments, and senior U.N. officials of what was happening in western Myanmar. Many ignored the signs, or at least failed to act.
The Gambia was different. In 2019, Abubacarr Tambadou, then The Gambia’s justice minister, met Rohingya survivors in refugee camps in Bangladesh. Having previously prosecuted the Rwandan genocide, Tambadou recognized disturbing parallels in Rohingya accounts.
Months later, The Gambia filed the case against Myanmar at the ICJ.
In January this year, as part of The Gambia’s official delegation in The Hague, I sat in the Court and watched the legal team present years of evidence, including material my colleagues and I had gathered, including Mohammadul’s sworn testimony. The Gambia also submitted Jason Motlagh’s 2018 investigation for Rolling Stone, which reconstructed a notorious massacre in the Rohingya village of Tula Toli. It later filed the video and transcript of Motlagh’s interview with Nazmul Islam, who witnessed the attack.
Myanmar, of course, denied any wrongdoing. Its lawyers claimed the military carried out a legitimate counter-terrorism operation against Rohingya militants, even going so far as to claim mass graves are common in hot climates. Never mind the untold women and children in those graves.
In 2022, U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken made a formal determination that the Myanmar military was responsible for genocide against Rohingya. It was only the eighth time in history that the U.S. had done that. Now, in an about-face, the Trump administration has opened direct talks with Myanmar’s rulers, and its own State Department strategy links U.S. diplomacy to securing access to the country’s rare-earth minerals, a fraught industry in the country that is fueling conflict and poisoning the environment.
Trump has also imposed sanctions targeting the International Criminal Court (ICC), which is just down the road from the ICJ in The Hague and is carrying out a criminal investigation of the Rohingya atrocities. The ICC is the world’s only independent court created to prosecute genocide, war crimes, and other atrocities. It was created by an international treaty and has 125 member states — it does not include the U.S.
Nevertheless, Trump and Secretary of State Rubio are intent on destroying the ICC. On November 13, Rubio publicly threatened the Court with a quote attributed to the Roman general Pompey: “Stop quoting laws to men with swords.” Trump’s order against the ICC forced me to stop sharing evidence with ICC prosecutors, so I sued in U.S. federal court. A judge granted preliminary relief on our First Amendment claim, and that case is ongoing.
The blue wave in the U.S. midterms was inspiring and might signal a new direction for the U.S. regarding international justice. It, at least, gives Congress a chance to push back against Trump’s attacks on the ICC. But over the years, Democrats have been equally abysmal with regard to international justice. President Joe Biden called the ICC prosecutor’s 2024 request for arrest warrants for Israeli leaders “outrageous.”
Survivors of mass atrocities cannot count on a change of party in Washington to access justice. The future of international justice is in the hands of small and medium-sized states like The Gambia. Of the world’s 193 nations, 162 have fewer than 50 million people. It took one of them, The Gambia, to bring Myanmar before the world’s highest court. Other such states should join forces to support cases wherever jurisdiction allows, defending courts against political pressure, and pressing governments to comply with judgments.
If the ICJ finds that Myanmar committed genocide, it will be the first time the court has found a state responsible for committing genocide. Its judgment cannot return the dead, rebuild the villages reduced to ashes, or give people like Mohammadul back the years they have spent in exile. But it can change the legal and political landscape. It can strengthen the law of genocide and its jurisprudence. It can bolster the struggle for accountability and give survivors a firmer foundation on which to demand justice. And it can pave the way for actual reparations — but especially for that, U.N. member states must stand behind it.
The Gambia made sure victims and survivors were heard in court. It will take other governments standing with the Rohingya to make sure Myanmar complies with the judgment, and to ensure survivors in other countries can also access justice.
Matthew Smith is the Chief Executive Officer and founder of Fortify Rights, a human rights organization working in Myanmar and other countries.
