Debate

Prolonged mask exposure changes how we process facial emotions

Prolonged mask exposure changes how we process facial emotions

Humans rely heavily on facial expressions to navigate social interactions, a process that became notably more difficult when face masks became a global norm. Recent research published in Cognition and Emotion reveals that people adapt and improve their ability to read masked emotions over a period of several months. The findings suggest that our visual processing adjusts to occluded faces, and these changes relate to both daily exposure and individual mental health symptoms.

Reading emotions from the faces of others dictates how people respond in social situations. Seeing fear might prompt someone to look for a threat, while a smiling face reinforces positive behaviors. Because human beings rely heavily on the lower half of the face to decode many of these emotional states, facial coverings create a substantial barrier to everyday communication.

Initial studies during the pandemic revealed that face masks led to lower accuracy and slower reaction times when identifying emotions. It was not well understood whether prolonged exposure to masked faces would eventually lead to improved recognition skills. Past research yielded mixed results, with some data indicating no improvement in adults over time and other data suggesting young children might adapt.

In addition to visual barriers, an individual’s mental state can alter how they perceive emotions in others. Some research indicates that people experiencing depression might be better at recognizing sadness, while those with anxiety might be highly sensitive to fearful faces. Researchers wanted to know how these mood symptoms might interact with the specific challenge of reading masked faces.

Free daily newsletter

Don’t miss the next big psychology finding

Every morning, PsyPost sends a short briefing on the most interesting new peer-reviewed research in psychology and neuroscience.

The research team was led by Marie Huc and Katie Bush, both affiliated with the University of Ottawa and Carleton University. They worked alongside senior author Natalia Jaworska of the University of Ottawa Institute of Mental Health Research. Together, they designed an experiment to track whether the ability to recognize masked emotions changes over several months, and how mental well-being factors into that process.

The investigators tracked 128 Canadian adults who participated in two testing sessions spaced three to four months apart. During each session, participants completed a series of questionnaires to assess their feelings of loneliness, perceived stress, depression, and anxiety. At the second session, they also reported how many hours a day they spent wearing a mask and how much time they spent interacting with other people wearing masks.

Following the questionnaires, participants completed a computerized emotional processing task. They were shown photographs of actors displaying five distinct facial expressions, which included happiness, sadness, fear, surprise, and a neutral state. Half of the images featured the faces fully visible, while the other half had a realistic surgical mask digitally overlaid onto the lower half of the face.

Participants were instructed to identify the emotion as quickly and accurately as possible by pressing corresponding keys on their keyboards. The research team recorded both the accuracy of the responses and the exact amount of time it took for the participants to make their choice. By comparing the results from the first session to the second session, the team could evaluate changes in recognition skills over time.

The results indicated that time and practice changed how participants processed the masked faces. Over the three to four month period, accuracy improved for identifying masked fear, happiness, and sadness. Conversely, participants became slightly less accurate at identifying masked surprise.

Reaction times also shifted depending on the emotion being displayed. Participants became faster at identifying masked fear over time, but their reaction times slowed down when attempting to identify masked surprise. Recognizing a surprised expression relies heavily on the mouth region, making it particularly difficult to decode when the lower half of the face is covered.

The researchers pointed out that becoming faster and more accurate at identifying fear could serve an adaptive purpose. Recognizing threat-related cues rapidly is highly beneficial in a stressful environment. Because the testing occurred during a global health crisis, heightened vigilance toward fearful expressions may have been a natural psychological response to prolonged uncertainty.

When looking at the unmasked faces, the researchers did not see the same broad changes in accuracy or reaction time between the two testing sessions. This lack of change in the unmasked condition suggests that the improvements seen with masked faces were not simply a result of participants practicing the computer task. Instead, it indicates a specific adaptation to processing partially covered faces.

The amount of time participants spent interacting with masked individuals in their daily lives also played a role. Greater daily exposure to masked faces was associated with slower reaction times when identifying masked happiness and sadness. The researchers suggest that people who interact more often with masked individuals might develop a habit of searching for more subtle visual cues. Looking for changes around the eyes takes slightly longer to process but helps maintain high accuracy.

Mental health symptoms were also linked to how participants performed. Individuals who reported increased symptoms of depression over the study period demonstrated greater accuracy when identifying masked happy faces. Those with increased anxiety symptoms showed better accuracy for masked happy and neutral faces.

General levels of perceived stress, depression, anxiety, and loneliness decreased across the group over the three to four months. These broad mental health improvements did not directly correlate with changes in facial recognition performance. The researchers note that their sample mostly consisted of community members without formal psychiatric diagnoses, which may explain the low overall symptom scores.

The study took place during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, a period characterized by unique global stressors that may have influenced overall mental health trends. Because mask mandates were universally in place for the sampled population during testing, the researchers could not include a control group with zero mask exposure. This limits the ability to isolate the exact impact of daily mask exposure compared to general time passing.

The experimental setup relied on static photographs of facial expressions rather than dynamic videos or real-world interactions. In natural settings, people rely on head movements, vocal tone, and body language to interpret emotions, which were not available in this computer task. Future research could incorporate video clips to better capture the realities of face-to-face communication.

Finally, because the study is correlational, it cannot prove that daily mask exposure or mental health symptoms directly cause changes in visual processing skills. The results only show that these factors change in tandem. Additional studies using different methodologies would be required to establish direct cause and effect.

The study, “Changes in facial expression recognition and well-being over time,” was authored by Marie Huc, Katie Bush, Lindsay Berrigan, Sylvia Cox, and Natalia Jaworska.



Source link

Filed under: Debate

Selected by

Avatar photo

I’m a freelance blogger, writing about health care, art and politics.