Secular & Atheism

Muslim organizer sues Gov. Greg Abbott over canceled Eid event at Texas waterpark

Muslim organizer sues Gov. Greg Abbott over canceled Eid event at Texas waterpark


This newsletter is free and goes out to over 26,000 subscribers, but it’s only able to sustain itself due to the support I receive from a small percentage of regular readers. Would you please consider becoming one of those supporters? You can subscribe via Patreon or the Subscribe button below! You can also make one-time donations through Venmo, CashApp, or PayPal.

A Muslim woman is suing Texas Gov. Greg Abbott for threatening to withhold $530,000 in public safety funding from the city of Grand Prairie if her organization was allowed to host an event at a city-owned facility, forcing the city to cancel it.

All of this happened back in May. Dr. Aminah Knight planned to celebrate Eid al-Adha with “Epic Eid,” taking place at Epic Waters Indoor Waterpark in the Dallas-Fort Worth area. While the city-owned park is open to the public most days, groups willing to pay can rent the whole damn place for private events at a cost of at least $5,000/hour. That’s what local Muslims had done the previous two years when they bought out the place for an Eid celebration. Interested families could buy tickets through the group, knowing that halal food would be served, everyone would be in “modest” swimwear, and there would be space set aside for evening prayers.

To be clear: There was nothing unusual about this arrangement. Private groups can rent out public facilities and set their own rules for admission. (And it’s perfectly sensible to allow in only members of your group.) The flyer for last year’s event called it a “Muslim-only event” and said the park was “reserved exclusively for the Muslim community.”

There were no complaints about it in the past because why the hell would there be?

That’s why the organizers didn’t think there would be any issue with this year’s identical event:

Unfortunately, they made the mistake of being Muslims in Texas. And when right-wing activists saw this flyer, they knew they could get a rise out of their bigot base by pretending this was an example of Islam taking over their state. The New York Post and conservative commentators pointed to the “Muslims only” description as a blatant case of discrimination and ran with it.

The organizers attempted to fix the issue by revising the flyer to say that anyone was welcome as long as they wore modest clothing and wanted to celebrate Eid. (That was always the case, but it was easier to advertise to the broader Muslim community by saying this was an event exclusively for Muslims.)

Knight explained:

“At its core, this event is about creating a space where individuals and families, particularly those who value modest dress and a modest environment, can come together and enjoy a recreational setting comfortably,” Knight wrote, adding that anyone who is “a different faith who wants to celebrate the Eid holiday with us and adhere to the modest dress code” is welcome to attend the event.

I need to repeat that this is a normal thing groups do! Hell, here’s another event at a waterpark in Texas that’s sponsored by Christians and includes a baptism. (It’s not a perfect comparison—that location isn’t city-owned, for one thing—but it’s the same principle.) Ministries often rent out publicly funded baseball stadiums for massive events, too! Globe Life Field, a publicly funded stadium where the Texas Rangers play baseball, is hosting a Christian event later this year and tickets are limited to people ages 18-25; that’s not age discrimination! It’s also worth pointing out that Christian events don’t normally have to say they’re “Christian only” because the purpose of those events is to baptize or proselytize. This Muslim event wasn’t about converting anybody.

It didn’t matter.

Gov. Abbott immediately acted like this Muslim event was a threat to everyone. He sent a letter to city officials saying he would pull their public safety grants if they didn’t put a stop to this, even comparing it to a “Whites only” event, which is not how analogies work.

In public fliers, organizers described the event as: “MUSLIM ONLY EVENT”; “FOR MUSLIMS ONLY”; and “CLOSED TO THE PUBLIC — MUSLIMS ONLY.” In a tacit admission, organizers have already rushed to delete that language. Now, fliers state that “ALL ARE WELCOME” and the event is restricted only by a requirement of “MODEST DRESS.” The first hint that the broader public is not really welcome, however, is language explaining that any women wishing to attend must wear “burkinis.” The organizer’s website makes matters clearer, stating that “[t]his event is closed to the general public” and “at all times” attendees must “dress in accordance with Islamic values.”’ If there were any doubt remaining, the website dispels it: “The entire waterpark has been exclusively reserved for Muslims.”’

… An event at a city-owned pool that was publicly and indiscriminately advertised as “Whites only” would surely violate the Constitution…

Abbott added on X/Twitter: “ The City must cancel the event and commit to never allowing something like it again by May 11th, or lose $530,000 in state grants. Let this be a lesson to local officials: Facilities funded by ALL taxpayers are not just for a subset of Texans.”

That’s a wild thing to say in the state currently forcing the KJV version of the Ten Commandments in every public school classroom… Then again, we’re talking about the same people trying to suppress the power of the Black vote by claiming the Voting Rights Act made them victims of anti-white discrimination.

But this facility wasn’t discriminating against anybody. They rent out their space to anyone, and those private parties have every right to set ground rules for who can attend. If I rent a public banquet hall for a religious wedding, I’m allowed to have religious rules during the event that apply to my attendees. It’s not like the waterpark was discriminating against non-Muslims. And even the organizers freely admitted they weren’t discriminating either; if you wanted to celebrate Eid with them, you were welcome to come! Just follow their rules!

Sadly, though, the threat worked.

A spokesperson for the City of Grand Prairie said Thursday the city canceled the DFW Epic Eid Celebration scheduled for June 1 at the Epic Waters Indoor Waterpark.

“After further review and in the best interest of the City of Grand Prairie, the June 1 Eid event at Epic Waters Indoor Waterpark has been canceled,” the spokesperson said.

The city didn’t admit any discrimination was taking place… because there was none. It appeared that the city’s “best interest” was simply to not fight this battle. I can’t blame them. That said, they gave a bizarre explanation to Knight as to why they were canceling: They said she hadn’t made the proper payments. Knight told FOX 4 she had been trying to make those payments for several days. If the payment excuse turned out to be true, that may have been a way to avoid any potential lawsuit.

At the time, it was unclear if Knight would sue over the matter, but she was certainly confused about why this was a problem—and for good reason:

Organizer Aminah Knight (screenshot via FOX 4)

“Last year the flyer said, come on out to celebrate the Eid. This will be a Muslim-only event. I just want to clarify that because it’s celebrating the Eid holiday — I mean who celebrates the Eid holiday? Muslims, right?” Knight said. “It was my way of letting the Muslim community know, hey, I’ve curated something just for you.”

She said in a follow-up statement:

I am deeply disappointed that DFW Epic Eid has been canceled.

What began as a private event for the Muslim community to celebrate Eid in a joyful and modest environment became something much bigger than I ever imagined. The flyer was originally shared within private community spaces, but it was later circulated more broadly by people who were not interested in attending, but rather in creating division and controversy.

While I did receive hateful messages from people who misunderstood the event, I also believe this moment sparked important conversations about Muslims in America and how our community is viewed.

My faith is not something to fear.

Not because I am personally afraid of disagreement, but because fear and misunderstanding can grow into discrimination, and that is dangerous for any society. When people begin to see their neighbors as foreign or as though they do not belong, it weakens the fabric of our nation.

I was born here. I was raised here. I was educated here. I belong here. I am proud to be both Muslim and American. I have spent nearly 20 years serving my community as an educator and attended NYU, USC, and Vanderbilt University.

And despite the negativity, I still choose conversation over division.

So this Fourth of July, I will be partnering with brothers and sisters from other faith communities to host an interfaith event called “The Great American Cookout,” where people from different backgrounds can come together, connect, and truly get to know one another as fellow Americans.

Although this experience has been painful, my faith teaches me that within every difficulty there is ease.

And I believe something beautiful can still come from this.

She was a better person than Abbott and his Christian Nationalist allies could ever hope to be.

A lot of the backlash to this controversy online came from people who clearly didn’t understand the situation. They acted like this was taxpayer-funded promotion of Islam when it was nothing like that. Abbott and his fellow Republicans were jumping on that ignorance to fuel even more anti-Muslim bigotry.

But now, six months later, Knight has filed a lawsuit against Abbott, Grand Prairie, and EPIC Waters with support from the Council on American Islamic Relations (CAIR).

In it, she explains that she made her payments to the waterpark “consistent with the arrangement from previous years.” There shouldn’t have been any drama since the waterpark also hosts similar events for Christian groups. Hell, their own website, she argued, urges religious groups to rent the facility: “Whether you’re planning a family reunion, school trip, scout outing, or church gathering, we’ve got everything you need to make it EPIC.”

She also says park representatives called her up and said none of this should be an issue “provided that President Trump did not become involved.” But later that day, they called her back to say the event was canceled. They later explained this was because of non-payment, but she says she was contractually required to make a deposit by May 11—four days after they sent her that email. Therefore there was no way she had missed a payment. The deadline hadn’t even arrived yet. (In fact, she adds, she had reached out to a park staffer two days prior to that saying she was ready to make that deposit.)

Despite all the chaos, Knight “arranged for the certified check to be hand-delivered” to the waterpark by May 11. But the event was still canceled, the park said, and they gave her back the money.

In the weeks to follow, due to Abbott’s “inflammatory public remarks,” Knight says she received “at least 61 harassing and threatening” messages from people, using racist slurs, calling her a terrorist, insulting her religious beliefs, and telling her to “go back to her country.” (She was born and raised in Brooklyn, New York.)

She also notes that her business received numerous one-star reviews online, harming her professionally.

For all these reasons, the lawsuit claims the defendants violated her First and Fourteenth Amendment rights, ignored the Texas Religious Freedom Restoration Act, and broke their contract.

She is asking the court to allow her to host a 2027 Eid event at the waterpark along with any legal fees and reimbursements. She also wants them to pay “her anticipated profit from the 2026 Eid event.”

Religion News Service points out that this is happening at a time when Texas’ political order has been upended:

The lawsuit comes just a day after Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton withdrew a lawsuit seeking to ban CAIR and its Texas chapters from operating in Texas.

Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa also said she will remove the state “foreign terrorist organization” label against CAIR.

The Muslim civil rights group cheered Hinojosa’s pledge, saying in a statement that “anti-Muslim hate is no longer an effective political weapon in Texas, and it must no longer have any place in state governance.”

This whole controversy should never have gotten this far. The only reason it did was because the people hosting the event were Muslim. That’s it. By pretending this private Eid gathering was equivalent to some kind of Jim Crow segregation, Abbott and his allies manufactured outrage, which is all they know how to do because they’re never truly victims of anything.

(Portions of this article were published earlier)

Please share this post on Reddit, Facebook, or the godawful X/Bird app.

Share



Source link