Alan Milburn’s much-anticipated report into tackling the UK’s youth-inactivity crisis arrived earlier this week. It proved a mostly feeble and half-hearted affair. The former New Labour health secretary announced, ‘We are at the fork in the road and half-measures will not do. A complete system reset is needed.’ What we got were mostly half-measures and only a partial reset.
Rejecting the ‘crude cuts’ to the benefit system proposed by the Conservatives and Reform UK (the former want to shave £36 billion from the benefits bill, the latter propose £50 billion with even tougher rules for claimants), Milburn merely set out plans to shift claimants off the two main forms of sickness and disability benefits to a new, supposedly more rigorous system.
He recommended measures to prepare children better for school and to double apprenticeships, calling for £5.8 billion a year in taxpayer subsidies. After these significant upfront costs, it is hoped that his plans will save a mere £200million per year in 2036–37. By then, another generation will have been lost and, to judge from current trends, Britain will already have gone bankrupt.
This is why ‘crude cuts’ are precisely what this country demands. This is an emergency. Urgent cuts are needed not merely to save the country but to save our neurotic, hermitic youth, whose imagined or feigned declarations of mental illness have been indulged for too long by adults peddling a therapeutic ideology – the same kind of adults who, for decades before the Covid lockdowns, told them that they were hopelessly fragile and forever on the brink of mental disintegration.
Under Milburn’s proposals, under-25s will be offered a Youth Opportunity Service, guaranteeing them an apprenticeship, training place or job, as well as ‘instant access’ to mental-health support. This is but more of the same costly, therapeutic, statist mollycoddling that landed us here in the first place. It is as infantilising and debilitating as welfare handouts themselves.
We all know why Alan Milburn didn’t propose ‘crude cuts’. They would never have been endorsed by our gaseous and supplicating prime minister, who responded this week by saying that he wanted to ensure that ‘no young person loses out from a cash point of view’. Nor would it be supported by the Labour backbenchers in parliament, many of whom rely on votes from those who live on welfare.
The Labour left may be the biggest dependency junkies of them all.
Snobs are missing out on science fiction
While browsing the shelves of Albion Books in Hastings this summer, I noticed in the science-fiction section a copy of George Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty-Four, now given a makeover. It transpires that an edition has featured in Gollancz’s ‘SF Masterworks’ series since 2022.
About time, I thought. Science fiction has always been an unfairly maligned and unfashionable genre. Its masterpieces, such as Aldous Huxley’s Brave New World and Ray Bradbury’s Fahrenheit 451, have been regarded as honourable exceptions to the field rather than exemplars. When Philip K Dick came into vogue at the turn of the millennium, efforts were even made to wrench him away from the field, with The Man in the High Castle given a Penguin Modern Classics jacket.
Nineteen Eighty-Four is a quintessential work of science fiction, in that it imagines a world disconcertingly different from ours. Orwell read HG Wells as a boy and was entranced by A Modern Utopia (1905). His last novel belongs to a literary tradition – one that goes back to Gulliver’s Travels – of depicting a reality that could happen, or that might otherwise have transpired.
That Nineteen Eighty-Four is now recognised as a ‘sci-fi classic’ represents a welcome trend. At Waterstones in London’s Piccadilly this summer, I also noticed how Huxley’s dystopian novels are now found in the science-fiction department, alongside the more speculative works of Daphne du Maurier.
Further evidence of this shift came last week with the news that this year’s Booker Prize has gone to a science-fiction novel, The End of Everything, by M John Harrison. It’s a deserving winner, being strange, spooky, gory, gooey, satirical and occasionally hilarious. Yes, it’s an opaque and elusive read, but the best rewards in life usually come from putting in the most effort.
The 81-year-old author has said he will use his newfound fame to continue his ‘drive against the whole concept of generification’ (classifying novels by genre). On this point, I disagree. Sure, The End of Everything could as easily be filed under ‘horror’, ‘fantasy’ or simply ‘fiction’, and pigeonholing can be restrictive. But human beings are creatures who will classify things, and if some narrow-minded snobs still quail at the genre ‘science fiction’, then that’s their loss.
Never forget – and never despair
Going to Flanders to pay one’s respects to the fallen on 11 November is always a sombre affair, but this year’s visit assumed a particular poignancy. It took place on the same day that I read about further attempts to dilute the definition of ‘Englishness’, in the same week that it was reported that Britain’s migrant population has risen faster than that of any other G7 country over the past decade, and against the backdrop – as I mentioned last month – of a growing melancholic feeling that our country is disappearing.
One sentiment expressed by a talking head in a 2003 First World War documentary, which we watched as our coach wound its way through the misty fields of Flanders, resonated even more loudly today: ‘Was their sacrifice worth it?’ Many feel that it wasn’t, and will recall the rueful words of a Second World War veteran who said on Good Morning Britain last November: ‘The sacrifice wasn’t worth the result that it is now.’
Reading the traditional English names of the fallen at Tyne Cot cemetery near Passchendaele, I couldn’t help feeling how alien they now seem, in light of last month’s report about the dramatic change in popular surnames in just the past 30 years, with Khan on course to overtake Smith among newborns. Given the demographic upheavals that have taken place all around Europe, the names at the nearby German cemetery in Langemark will likely have aroused similar sentiments among visitors there. As a Scots piper gave his climactic performance at the Menin Gate ceremony in Ypres (or Ieper, to give it its proper Dutch-language name today), I couldn’t help wondering whether I was also bidding goodbye to our fractured United Kingdom. This wasn’t just the ‘Last Post’. It felt like a last goodbye.
What gave me some hope was being reminded that Ypres, having been completely destroyed in the First World War, was subsequently rebuilt as it had been, thanks to the determination of the Belgians. Nil desperandum, as they say. The future is still in our hands.
