Alan Milburn and Peter Fonagy have, between them, expertly diagnosed the UK’s illness. Their reviews show we don’t just have a Neet crisis. Or a school absence crisis. Or a Send crisis. We have a neglected childhood crisis that will wreck the country’s long-term prosperity if we just keep patching over these symptoms.
The solution to any problem starts with understanding its causes, and Milburn and Fonagy provide a thoughtful analysis. I have worked closely with both of them, being a topic group member for Fonagy’s independent review into mental health conditions, ADHD and autism, and supporting Milburn with data analytics. Their reviews have followed the evidence, all of which shows a system neglecting children at scale. We have decreased benefits and slashed the support provided to children: today 4.5 million children are living in poverty. When these children grow up and are diagnosed with anxiety and depression, impeding their ability to work, they are often castigated as feckless snowflakes. It is easier to do this than admit that we have failed a generation, and that this is the predictable consequence of political decisions.
Born in Bradford, our longitudinal birth cohort programme launched in 2007 to follow the development of 13,500 children and their families, has been tracking these changes in real time, and our Child of the North consortium has synthesised the national evidence. Our findings show how childhood disadvantage accumulates into young adulthood. The science is extensive and methodologically complex, but the findings can be readily grasped through the life of an archetypal child who we will call Tracey.
Tracey is a young person desperate for education, employment or training. Like many others, she has special educational needs, anxiety and depression. We might think Tracey is Neet because she lives in a rundown area without transport links to education, employment, or training. But most young people in Bradford lack good transport, so this is only part of the story.
This is where our connected datasets are so powerful, as they allow us to travel back in time and piece together Tracey’s life from birth. Tracey’s mum was anxious and depressed and living in poverty when she was pregnant. These risk factors are known to hinder children’s development, but the signal was ignored. In fact, Tracey’s mum got less support than her middle-class peers because she couldn’t get to an antenatal group, while health visitor support was being slashed for expectant mums.
Tracey was born prematurely with health complications. Fortunately, our brilliant NHS ensured that her medical needs were met. Unfortunately, information about Tracey wasn’t shared with the other public services that would deal with the consequences of her early health problems downstream. The NHS also couldn’t address the impoverished environment in which Tracey spent her early years.
It turns out that brain science can be surprisingly easy to understand. Children need healthy environments for healthy brain growth. If children grow up in impoverished environments, they won’t develop the core skills needed to achieve and thrive in education. This means they will, by definition, have educational needs that go beyond the pedagogical support required by children whose families can access developmentally supportive environments.
The impoverished preschool environment means that Tracey starts school without the core skills needed to thrive. This is not a surprise to our Bradford researchers, who can see her history of risk factors. But it is a surprise for her teachers, who did not receive any of this information from Tracey’s mum or other public services.
Tracey struggles in primary school and her needs are not well supported: her mum cannot navigate the complex processes needed to secure the clinical diagnosis that would trigger support for her neurodevelopmental and educational needs.
It should be no surprise that Tracey struggles when she arrives at secondary school. But it is a surprise to the secondary school, because it wasn’t provided with the recorded information that screams Tracey needs love, understanding and help.
Tracey doesn’t feel included at secondary school or that she belongs there. Once more, brain science can be surprisingly easy to understand. The brain generates feelings of anxiety when faced with environments that feel hostile, and feelings of depression when hope is eroded.
Tracey attends a school with an outstanding Ofsted rating, but her own results are not helping its league table position. The school gently encourages her away from class and Tracey starts to miss school on an increasingly frequent basis. Before Tracey can sit her GCSEs, the school suggests that perhaps she should find another school or be educated at home. This is an unscrupulous yet perfectly rational response within an education system that rewards attainment over inclusion. Unfortunately, the science shows an unequivocal relationship between school absence and becoming Neet, so there is no surprise when Tracey ends up not in education, employment or training.
This all appears inevitable when viewed in hindsight. But it isn’t. Patterns in data are not fixed outcomes. We know that schemes like Sure Start in England, mercilessly cut by the coalition government, can transform children’s lives and help them enjoy healthy, productive futures. Our Bradford research shows an earlier diagnosis of neurodevelopmental issues is associated with lower risk of teenage mental health problems, and that “inclusive” schools show lower Neet rates. Early risk factors are signals for intervention, not fatalistic trapdoors. Young people don’t become Neet overnight, and every day offers an opportunity to either reduce childhood risks or let them accumulate.
after newsletter promotion
Why Tracey? Our hypothetical child is homage to Tracey Emin. Her work Why I Never Became a Dancer uses art to capture these scientific truths and shows how one child overcame childhood trauma to become a world-leading artist.
Compassion shines from the Milburn and Fonagy reviews. We must share their compassion. Our children need love, understanding and a national commitment to overcome the UK’s neglected childhood crisis.
Tracey’s story is not only about poverty or adversity but also about system failure. The social safety net is cut without consideration of the long-term consequences. Health services treat medical problems, but cannot see or address living conditions. Information isn’t shared between services. Schools are rewarded for exam results, rather than helping children. Support, rationed by thresholds, only arrives at crisis points.
The answer cannot be another sticking plaster for young people transitioning into adulthood. We need to reimagine how we support children from birth so our young people and economy can thrive. This means reshaping the public sector around improving children’s lives, while tackling the deprivation that creates adversity in the first place.
Andy Burnham is right when he says that this demands a generational response. We must all get behind a national commitment to transform childhood, recognising that the anxiety, depression and lost opportunities experienced by too many young people are not inevitable. They are the consequences of choices we have made as a society, and choices we have the power to change.
