Education

a valuable idea, but young people need more than a legal boundary

a valuable idea, but young people need more than a legal boundary


Would changing the age of consent better protect teenagers from sexual exploitation? Campaigners proposing a “staggered” age of consent argue that 16- and 17-year-olds should remain free to have sex with people close to their age, while substantially older adults should be prohibited from having sex with them.

In theory, I am in favour of a staggered age of consent, but one measure alone – changing the law – can not be the only approach to the problem of harmful relationships between teenagers and much older adults. There’s the risk that creating a new law is seen as the solution to this problem when wider support and education is also needed.

High-profile cases can expose harms that demand action, but the understandable pressure to respond should not replace careful scrutiny of what extending criminal law would achieve, its possible unintended consequences and the support needed to make it effective.

In England and Wales, the age of consent is 16. However, the law already recognises that 16- and 17-year-olds need additional protection in certain relationships. Defined positions of trust, including particular teaching, caring, sporting and religious roles, restrict sexual activity with under-18s. It is also against the law to engage in sexual activity with an under-18 in certain family relationships, or to pay for a 16- or 17-year-old’s sexual services, even if they agree.

The Close the Consent Gap campaign proposes that sexual activity between someone aged 20 or over and a 16- or 17-year-old should be an offence, unless their age difference is no more than three years.

The close-in-age distinction is important. This is not simply a proposal to prohibit all sex below 18. It seeks to distinguish teenagers’ relationships with peers and young adults from those involving substantially older adults.

And an age-based offence could provide an additional route to accountability. At the moment, prosecutors must establish that the under-18 did not consent, and this change would remove that requirement. That potential value deserves serious consideration.

However, my research with young people on sexual consent examines how interpersonal pressures and wider sexual expectations affect consent. Knowing what consent means does not necessarily make it straightforward to express a preference or challenge a partner.

Differences in money, status, experience, social support and authority may affect someone’s ability to negotiate what happens in a sexual relationship. Someone may use their resources or influence to impose expectations, discourage disagreement or make leaving difficult. Age can play a role in this, but it cannot stand in for all of them. An age difference between partners does not automatically establish coercion.

This matters within similar-age relationships too. Protecting teenagers from substantially older adults should not imply that relationships between peers are necessarily safe. Nor does turning 18 suddenly remove vulnerability to exploitation.

These are reasons to be clear about the purpose of a legal boundary. It can establish circumstances in which sexual activity is prohibited. It cannot certify every relationship outside that prohibition as equal or healthy.

Creating an offence is one policy decision. Making it effective requires decisions about reporting, investigation, evidence, professional practice and support. Reform should explain how each would work.

The offences for which Russell Brand was convicted were already illegal. In his sentencing remarks, the judge described how Brand’s status had protected him until journalists exposed the allegations. A new age-based offence could extend protection, but its effectiveness would still depend on whether people can report harm safely, institutions act on concerns and offences are investigated.

Young people should participate in that process. How would they understand the new boundary? Would they know that responsibility lay with the older adult? What would happen if they wanted support but did not want to describe their relationship as abusive or engage with a prosecution?

Education and support are part of protection

Education should help young people explore how relationships work, including what makes sexual agency possible and whose wishes take priority.

That means opportunities to discuss concrete situations: feeling indebted to a partner, being praised for being unusually mature, worrying about losing affection or finding that gifts come with expectations. These examples should open discussion about context, rather than become a checklist through which every relationship is judged.

Providing that support requires skilled professionals, time and accessible services. It also requires educational continuity. In England, statutory relationships, sex and health education requirements do not apply to sixth-form colleges, 16–19 academies or further education colleges, although provision is encouraged. This means that young people may miss out on education at precisely the age the proposal for a staggered age of consent concerns.

None of this transfers responsibility for preventing exploitation onto teenagers. Adults remain responsible for their conduct, and institutions need clear expectations and routes for challenging it.

Social scientist Jonny Hunt and I sometimes describe conduct as “lawful but awful”. Criminal thresholds cannot settle everything we should expect of intimate relationships or of adults who hold social power.

A staggered age of consent may strengthen protection. Its contribution should be assessed carefully, alongside investment in education, safeguarding and accountability. Young people deserve a legal framework that protects them and support systems that take their experiences seriously.



Source link