Debate

The authoritarian legacy of the Southport riots

The authoritarian legacy of the Southport riots


In our legal system, the process can often be the punishment. Being on bail for a serious crime puts your life on hold. You could be facing a trial and a prison sentence. Clients often describe how, by the time they get to trial, years after any alleged crime has been committed, they feel as though they have already served their sentence. They may have restrictive bail conditions, affecting where they can and cannot go, or who they can and cannot meet up with. They possess physical liberty, but the possibility of a potential prison sentence makes planning a life all but impossible.

When I met James and saw the footage, I could not believe he had been charged. He used some heated language with the officers, but riot police are normally assumed to be able to deal with harsh words from the public. It is not illegal, in this country, to insult a police officer.

Before he instructed us, James had been represented by a previous legal team who had applied to have the case dismissed. But the judge had allowed the case to continue to the jury. He must have thought that a jury could conclude that James’s actions contributed to an ‘aura of menace’ against the officers and the men inside the hotel. So, we had to prepare James for a criminal trial.

He took me through his movements at the demonstration in detail. His case was, as stated above, that the serious disorder was happening elsewhere. He pointed out that the officers who were marching forward – towards him and the others on Fletcher Street – pushed them towards Grimshaw Lane, where bottles and other missiles were being thrown at police. James had driven to the demonstration and parked his car a few roads away. He insisted he just wanted to get back to his car when he saw that the demonstration had become violent, but was stopped from doing so by the riot officers. James was angry that the police officer had pushed both him and the woman he was with. He did not say anything that would have made the officers fear for their safety – far from creating an ‘aura of menace’, he was walking away throughout most of the footage shown to the jury.

Often, in these cases, it is not possible to discern the full picture. The evidence produced by both the defence and the prosecution might be incomplete. Here, James had decided to attend a protest outside a hotel where asylum seekers were housed. Whatever the law says, most people would think this method of ‘protest’ is wrong. The UK’s dysfunctional asylum system is not the fault of those who are caught up in it. It’s not right to protest government policy by targeting individuals.

Yet the idea that people should face lengthy prison sentences merely for showing up at a demonstration and shouting at the police has been alien to the law in the UK for a long time. The law generally allows the freedom to protest, including shouting at the police. We don’t live in a country where the state punishes people for being in the wrong place at the wrong time. Whatever you think of James being at such a demonstration in the first place, the law does not tend to punish people who behaved like he did.

He could very easily have been one of the defendants who pleaded guilty at the magistrates’ court. He might have been told by his lawyer that he had no chance of being cleared, given his presence at the scene of the disorder. He might have been advised that, by pleading guilty, he would receive credit from the court and a reduced sentence. Yet had he pleaded guilty, he would have been held in custody. It is a good bet that he would have been given a lengthy prison sentence. Instead, he took his chance with a jury trial.

He won very quickly. He gave evidence in his defence and was acquitted unanimously. By this point, he had been on bail for close to two years.

The personal costs of this legal process have been enormous. While on bail, James had to find a new job. He was prevented from attending his place of work, which was opposite the Holiday Inn on Fletcher Street. He had to attend a new site, on the opposite side of town, which added two hours to his working day. The possibility that he would serve a sentence of up to five years beyond the date of his trial overshadowed his life. In today’s desperately overstretched court system, defendants on bail can expect very long waits for their trials. While most of us can plan for what we would like to be doing in three years’ time, when you are awaiting a trial for an imprisonable offence, such planning becomes impossible.

Anyone who saw footage of the riots in 2024 would have recognised the need for a tough law-and-order response. Fuelled, in part, by racism and misinformation, the levels of violence were often serious and the potential for harm was immense. That goes some way to explain why the police and the justice system felt they had to use the law to ‘send a message’.

Yet it is hard to resist the conclusion that James and people like him were punished not just for their actions on the street – but for being on the street in the first place. It is hard to know how many of those involved in the 2024 disorder pleaded guilty to riot-related offences because they felt they had to, rather than because they genuinely believed they had broken the law.

The use of the law to ‘send a message’ may seem necessary when faced with a national crisis, yet such crackdowns create ripple effects that aren’t always immediately visible. Individual justice is suspended. The normal rules cease to apply. We may welcome this when coping with an immediate emergency, but James Cooper’s case suggests the harm to individual defendants can be immense. We must remain vigilant to ensure that states of emergency do not create lasting precedents that further limit our everyday freedom.



Source link