Debate

Brain damage linked to “pseudopsychopathy” may not reduce the will to empathize

Brain damage linked to “pseudopsychopathy” may not reduce the will to empathize

People with localized damage to the ventromedial prefrontal cortex, a lower-front brain area linked to social behavior and emotion, opted into empathy-inducing tasks in a laboratory setting just as often as healthy adults and patients with injuries elsewhere in the brain. Published in Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience, the study suggests that injury to this region does not necessarily diminish a person’s willingness to step into another’s shoes. Instead, everyday empathy struggles after such injuries may stem from trouble reading emotions rather than avoiding empathy.

The ventromedial prefrontal cortex is a region of brain tissue at the bottom middle of the frontal lobes, sitting behind the forehead and above the eye sockets. Injury here from trauma, stroke, or tumor removal can trigger dramatic shifts in personality and social judgment while sparing intelligence, memory, and speech. Since the nineteenth-century case of railroad worker Phineas Gage, who survived an iron rod passing through his skull, clinicians have observed that damage here often leaves people indifferent to social norms and others’ feelings.

Modern cases, such as a man known in medical literature by the initials EVR whose personality shifted dramatically after surgery to remove a frontal brain tumor, showed similar social detachment that clinicians have compared to psychopathic traits.

Empathy involves identifying, sharing, and understanding another person’s emotional experiences. Patients with localized areas of tissue damage, known as lesions, in the ventromedial prefrontal cortex often struggle to recognize fear or disgust on faces, hear emotion in a speaker’s voice, or mount normal bodily stress responses to someone’s pain. In a 2018 experiment co-authored by Professor Daniel Tranel, senior author and researcher on the new study, comparison participants shared more money in an economic game after overhearing a partner describe a personal tragedy, whereas patients with ventromedial prefrontal damage did not.

Free daily newsletter

Don’t miss the next big psychology finding

Every morning, PsyPost sends a short briefing on the most interesting new peer-reviewed research in psychology and neuroscience.

Psychologists distinguish between empathy ability, the capacity to read emotions accurately and feel concern, and empathy motivation, the willingness to enter situations or mindsets that invite sharing someone’s feelings. A 2013 brain-imaging study of incarcerated offenders with psychopathy showed how these can split apart: participants had muted activity in pain-sharing brain regions while passively watching people get hurt, yet responded far more normally when asked to feel with the person on screen, pointing to low spontaneous motivation.

“We wanted to better understand the brain regions that contribute to whether people were more or less empathic toward others, specifically focusing on the contribution of the ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC),” lead author Julian A. Scheffer, an assistant professor of psychology and member of the Centre for Brain and Mind at the University of Western Ontario, where his lab is based, told PsyPost.

“Case studies like Phineas Gage and patient EVR highlighted that after damage to the vmPFC, these individuals experienced profound personality and socioemotional changes that made them appear to lack empathy by no longer being concerned for the feelings of others (i.e., ‘pseudopsychopathy’). However, we wanted to isolate whether these deficits of empathy were due to issues of motivation (i.e., ‘won’t empathize’) or ability (i.e., ‘can’t empathize’).”

Other functions of the ventromedial prefrontal cortex gave scientists reason to suspect it might govern empathy motivation too, since the region helps weigh rewards against mental effort during decision-making. In a 2019 multi-study paper co-authored by Scheffer and Pennsylvania State University associate professor C. Daryl Cameron, another researcher on the new team, healthy adults given free choices repeatedly steered away from empathy-inducing tasks because they found them mentally demanding and unpleasant.

Scheffer, who was also affiliated with the University of Iowa during the research, worked with Tranel and colleagues at Iowa to compare patients who had localized lesions in this region against two control groups. They predicted that patients with ventromedial prefrontal damage would choose empathy less often and judge it to be more mentally taxing.

The team recruited 13 patients with ventromedial prefrontal damage on one or both sides of the brain, all tested in the stable recovery phase at least three months after injury. They compared them against 13 brain-damaged patients whose injuries spared the ventromedial prefrontal cortex and other emotion-linked regions, plus 16 healthy adults without brain injury.

Both comparison groups were matched to the ventromedial prefrontal patients on age, sex, and education, though the brain-damaged comparison patients’ injuries were more recent on average, at about 11 years prior versus 24 years. Including a second brain-injured group helped isolate effects specific to the ventromedial prefrontal cortex, and a neurologist unaware of the hypotheses verified all lesion boundaries on brain scans.

The researchers preregistered their hypotheses and analysis plan during data collection and posted their data and code publicly online. Their broader preregistered project also recruited patients with damage to the amygdala, an almond-shaped brain structure involved in emotion, whose results, reported separately by the same team in the journal Brain, similarly showed intact empathy motivation.

Participants completed two 40-trial computerized tasks capturing affective empathy, or emotionally sharing someone’s feelings, and cognitive empathy, or imagining someone’s emotional perspective. In the affective task, participants chose on each round between a blue “FEEL” card deck and a red “DESCRIBE” deck before viewing a photo of a child refugee. Picking “FEEL” required writing briefly about the child’s internal emotions, whereas “DESCRIBE” required writing objectively about physical appearance, with a mandatory 10-second wait before submitting on every round (four brain-injured patients with typing difficulties dictated their responses verbatim to an experimenter).

In the cognitive task, participants were paired with a fictional partner identified by name and birthday and chose between a “FEEL-OTHER” deck and a “FEEL-SELF” deck. After viewing a moderately emotional photo and waiting 10 seconds, they indicated whether it made either their partner or themselves feel positive or negative. Missing choice responses led the team to exclude one brain-damaged comparison patient from the affective task and one patient from each brain-injured group in the cognitive task, leaving 41 and 40 participants, respectively.

After each task, participants rated both card decks on a mental workload questionnaire. The items measured perceived effort (how hard and mentally demanding the deck felt), aversiveness (how irritated, stressed, or discouraged it made them feel), and efficacy (how successful they felt at following its instructions).

Across all participants combined, people tended to avoid the empathy decks, picking the affective empathy option on 42 percent of trials and the cognitive perspective-taking option on 32 percent of trials. Participants who chose to empathize more often in one task also tended to do so in the other, indicating a moderate link between the two measures.

Contrary to the researchers’ primary hypothesis, group differences in how often participants selected the empathy decks were not statistically significant in either task. In the affective task, patients with ventromedial prefrontal damage chose the empathy deck on 47 percent of trials. Brain-damaged comparison patients and healthy adults landed in a similar range, averaging 44 percent and 37 percent, respectively.

Choices were even closer in the cognitive task, where both brain-injured groups picked the perspective-taking deck on 33 percent of trials and healthy adults picked it on 31 percent. To look closer at those null results, the team ran Bayesian statistical analyses, which test whether the data actively favor practical equivalence between groups rather than merely failing to detect a difference. Those tests backed up the lack of group differences in both tasks, though the authors noted that the cognitive task’s Bayesian result should be read conservatively because scores departed from a normal bell-curve distribution.

Participants overall rated the empathy decks as more effortful than the non-empathy alternatives in both tasks, and in the cognitive task they also rated perspective-taking as more unpleasant and felt less successful at it. Yet patients with ventromedial prefrontal damage did not find empathizing more costly than comparison groups did. In the affective task, both comparison groups rated sharing the child refugees’ feelings as harder work than describing physical appearances, whereas that effort difference was not statistically significant among ventromedial prefrontal patients. Follow-up Bayesian comparisons indicated that the ventromedial prefrontal group rated the affective empathy deck as moderately less effortful than healthy adults did.

In the cognitive task, standard tests comparing the three groups on those deck differences in effort, unpleasantness, and efficacy were not statistically significant, though secondary Bayesian analyses pointed to a small-to-moderate tendency for ventromedial prefrontal patients to rate the perspective-taking deck itself as more unpleasant than comparison groups did. Across the sample, correlations between perceived mental costs and choosing empathy were not statistically significant in either task, though with roughly 40 participants, the study fell short of the 120 needed to reliably detect moderate individual-level relationships.

Separate checks also found no consistent group differences in how mental workload ratings related to card choices, despite a 2017 study co-authored by Justin Reber, a researcher on the new team, showing that damage here leaves patients struggling to factor fullness into decisions about eating.

“We were surprised that we did not observe a decrease in empathy motivation in people with vmPFC lesions compared to brain-damaged and healthy comparison participants,” Scheffer said. “But, this may have further highlighted that prior issues of empathy were on how people with damage to this region successfully deploy empathy.”

“Damage to this region has also previously been shown to impact how people encode the subjective value of different choices in front of them into their future decision-making (e.g., being unable to encode satiation into decisions to consume food). However, we additionally did not find any differences in how they encoded the cognitive costs of empathy into their decision-making, relative to their comparison groups.”

To explain why affective empathy felt less effortful after ventromedial prefrontal injury, the authors suggest that damage to this region may blunt emotion-recognition processes that ordinarily make sharing someone’s distress feel demanding. The researchers also propose two ways to reconcile normal empathy motivation in the lab with the everyday social struggles documented in these patients.

In the authors’ reading, patients with ventromedial prefrontal damage may retain the willingness to empathize, unlike people with psychopathy who often lack spontaneous motivation, yet falter when someone is hurting because they misread emotions or fail to generate the bodily arousal that fuels concern and helping. Alternatively, the authors note that patients with damage to this frontal region often perform well on structured, rule-bound laboratory tasks while struggling to make appropriate social choices in open-ended everyday settings.

“The performance and function of empathy can be separated into ability and motivation issues, and these have different implications for social interactions and relationships,” Scheffer explained. “People with vmPFC damage here did not exhibit remarkable deficits on motivation to empathize. Therefore, they seem to not suffer a deficit on wanting to empathize but rather may not be able to successfully deploy empathy when trying to do so. This distinction can be important for clinical profiles and caregivers, given this presents different reasons and reactions for why someone may not empathize but for different reasons: someone who can’t empathize but is trying may be thought of differently from someone who can empathize but won’t.”

There are a few things to keep in mind when interpreting these results. Choosing between two labeled card decks on a laptop is far more structured than daily life, where nobody prompts a person to tune into a partner’s distress amid competing priorities. Because each round forced a binary choice between two decks, picking the empathy option could also reflect a dislike of cataloging someone’s appearance rather than a desire to empathize. The researchers also did not directly test emotion-recognition accuracy in these specific 13 patients, so the study cannot verify impaired empathy capacity alongside intact motivation within the exact same individuals.

Injuries confined to this region are rare, whether from surgery, tumor, or a stroke that cuts off blood flow, a process called ischemia. Because of that scarcity, the 13-patient sample only had enough statistical power to detect fairly sizable group differences, leaving subtler motivational shifts possible.

“Lesion comparison studies are valuable in that they allow researchers to study whether a social or cognitive process is present or absent when a given brain region is removed by surgery, ischemia, or other surgical procedure,” Scheffer noted. “These types of studies are also quite rare, have clinical utility, and there is a scarcity of patients with lesions to these regions (i.e., the vmPFC). We do note that the size of the sample is smaller when conducting group-based comparisons; however, we do note that brain lesion studies may have larger effect sizes when examining social or cognitive processes given the profound changes that occur with brain damage.”

Future studies could offer empathy choices on an accept-or-reject basis rather than a forced pair and observe patients during unstructured interactions outside the lab. Measuring willingness to empathize alongside actual emotion-reading accuracy in the same participants could also clarify how those two pieces interact.

“In my lab at the University of Western Ontario, we are continuing to study and consider the brain regions that impact empathy motivation and/or ability, and are aiming to better compare these in the same study given we missed that opportunity here,” Scheffer added. “We are also studying caregivers of people living with dementia to examine how frequent interactions with someone who may experience ability or motivation issues with empathy may impact their caregiver’s empathy or compassion fatigue.”

“We hope that this study continues to inform how people consider the function of empathy and the contributions of ability and motivation into whether it appears to be successful and high performing versus weaker and low performing,” he said. “We are continuing to explore how this impacts social behavior and relationships in future research.”

The study, “Is damage to the ventromedial prefrontal cortex associated with impaired empathy? A neuropsychological study using an empathy motivation task,” was authored by Julian A. Scheffer, Justin Reber, C. Daryl Cameron, and Daniel Tranel.



Source link

Filed under: Debate

Selected by

Avatar photo

I’m a freelance blogger, writing about health care, art and politics.