Lifestyle

3 Reasons Not To Use AI for Relationship Advice

3 Reasons Not To Use AI for Relationship Advice

We all value feeling reassured when we feel hurt. Maybe your partner seems distant, or your adult child just sent you an angry text. Or a friend of yours cancels your plans, once again at short notice. Your brain jumps to what their behavior surely means, and AI can offer a welcome dose of validation in moments like these.

As a psychologist, I am struck by how many of my clients tell me they turn to AI after painful interactions like those above. And I really do get it, because when you are upset, it can feel like a big-time relief to put your thoughts into an AI query and get an immediate response. But a quick, smoothly written, AI response often misses what’s going on between two people below the surface, especially when it’s based on only one person’s perspective. Let’s now dig even deeper and look at three further reasons to be cautious when turning to AI for relationship advice.

1. AI Only Knows the Story You Tell

The reality is that you are loading the dice when you roll it skewed with AI as your confidant, and that is a big deal. Suppose you ask, “Why was my partner so hostile when I got home?” This question already implies some interpretation. Maybe your partner had a valid reason to feel angry with you, or perhaps they were worn out from caring for your sick child. In other words, AI can’t read your mind (or your partner’s) or know what you haven’t told it, and you may not even know all the details yourself yet.

Recently I wrote about jumping to conclusions and separating what happens from what we think it means. For instance, “My partner spoke sharply is your observation based on their voice and body language. But “They don’t care about me” is an interpretation. The point is that even though your hurt merits attention and you may be tempted to get that met with AI, the interpretation you get back may not be valid.

2. AI Can Flood You With More Possibilities That Drive Your Overthinking

In my book, You Ruined My Life—Now You Owe Me, I discuss painful conflicts between parents and their adult children. After receiving an angry message, a parent may reread it repeatedly, searching for a clue about what will happen next. I have written a lot about overthinking, and I often see how seeking reassurance can backfire. In this case, let’s say you go to AI for another explanation, hoping it will finally put your mind at ease.

But guess what: now you feel flooded as AI doles out freshly minted interpretations as quickly as you can ask for them. Each answer likely gives you only brief, temporary relief (because you are stuck in a maddening overthinking loop) before you feel compelled to ask again; then you are just feeding that worry loop instead of stopping it.

3. AI Cannot Have A Genuine Conversation With You

Whoa, hold on, you may be saying to yourself, “Dr. Jeff, how out of touch are you? AI sure feels like it can have a conversation with me!” Well, I’ll give it to you that AI can suggest what someone’s words could mean. Still, it cannot tell you what the person actually intended, listen to their response, or repair a misunderstanding between you (especially given that your relationship’s history and context are packed into your brain, not that chatbot’s).

Don’t get sucked into the illusion that an AI-polished answer feels like progress while the actual conversation you need to have (which may likely be messier) remains undone. How about instead saying something (live, in real life, to the actual other person) like “Our recent exchange hurt me, and I’d like to talk and better understand what happened. I’m committed to a calm, constructive conversation so we can both better understand each other.” And then there’s the magic part that moves mountains and heals relationships: Listen, really listen without you filling in the blanks or letting your AI “friend” fill them in for you.

Final Thoughts

The urge to get an immediate answer from AI can seem to make sense, especially when we are hurting. Instead of turning to AI, though, slow down and ask yourself: What do I really know, what am I assuming, and what human-to-human conversations or decisions would actually help?



Source link