Just one beat.
My father would drum his hands on the dinner table. Someone answered with a fork or spoon. Soon, everyone had found a rhythm, and dinner had become a family percussion circle.
Ask my sisters and me about those moments now, and we may each remember something slightly different. One may remember how playful it felt. Another may remember it as simply part of dinner with Dad. I remember the possibility of it all, the way one small beat could suddenly become music.
We were sitting at the same table, but we did not necessarily hear the same thing. Maybe that was part of the gift.
Father’s Day invites us to remember, but families rarely carry one perfectly agreed-upon version of the past. We take away different details and feelings, even from moments we shared.
There always seemed to be music somewhere in our house: the Beatles, the Beach Boys, a Broadway cast album. On long drives, we argued over who got which part in Les Misérables. Kazoos appeared at birthdays, retirement parties, and other occasions that probably did not require kazoos.
Dad taught us to jitterbug, too.
One sister remembers standing on his feet as a child, then learning to let him lead as he whirled her around the dance floor. He hummed while they moved and sometimes tapped the rhythm into her hand so she could feel the beat.
Another sister found rhythm through athletics. There is a dance to the discus throw: the windup, the turn, the gathering of momentum, and then the release. Dad was there for that rhythm too, cheering from the side.
For me, music meant piano lessons, competitions, camps, and college auditions. Music meant Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony blasting on the way to sleepaway piano camp while Dad and I replaced the German words with animal sounds.
Each daughter had her own rhythm with him. What connected those experiences was that our father met us where we were.
Why Music Brings So Much Back
Memory is not a recording. Each time we remember something, we rebuild it through our emotions, later experiences, and who we are now. That helps explain why siblings can share an event and carry away different pieces of it.
No one memory has to cancel another. Together, those pieces may tell a fuller story.
Music is a particularly powerful cue for autobiographical memory. A familiar song can reactivate not only an event, but also the emotions, people, and setting attached to it.
We do not simply remember what was playing. We remember who was there.
When people sing, dance, clap, or make music together, they coordinate their attention and movement in time. That synchrony can support closeness, but it does not require everyone to experience the moment in the same way. We can move to the same beat without singing the same part.
The message beneath the music in our family was something like: I see what matters to you. I am here.
To this day, I’m still not sure if my sisters like classical music. But they know it matters to my father and me, so they show up too. We know how fortunate we are to have received that kind of love.
As a family, we know how fortunate we are to have received that message.
Father’s Day can be joyful, painful, complicated, or all three. Not everyone experiences a father’s presence this way, and many people receive that love and guidance from someone else who steps into the role.
For us, love often arrived through music, movement, and the steady rhythm of showing up.
The Always-Evolving Soundtrack
This week, my parents also celebrate their 55th wedding anniversary. Dad may have started many of the beats, but our family soundtrack grew inside the life they created together.
My mother has often been the quiet conductor, keeping the peace, bringing the snacks, getting everyone where they needed to go, and making sure each child had room to develop a different rhythm.
She also taught us to dance around the kitchen with wooden spoons as microphones, usually to “Dancing Queen.” Matching pitch was never the point. Dancing and laughing together were.
“You Are My Sunshine” carries another layer of family history. My father and I danced to it at my Bat Mitzvah and again at my wedding. Now I sing it to my children, just as my mother and grandmother sang it to me.
The melody stays. The people around it keep changing.
When we experience a song during an emotionally meaningful moment, the brain connects it to the people, place, and feelings surrounding it. Later, the music can reopen that network almost before we consciously choose to remember.
The memory is not frozen. Each return can add another layer. “You Are My Sunshine” now holds my grandmother, my mother, my father, my sisters, and my children. “Dancing Queen” still brings back wooden spoons and a kitchen filled with people who may each remember the dancing a little differently.
Once a song becomes part of our autobiographical memory, it can be difficult to hear it as only a song again.
Today, among the greatest gifts of my adult life are writing Resonant Minds: The Transformative Power of Music and contributing to this Psychology Today blog with my father. Our soundtrack now includes research conversations, edited drafts, disagreements, laughter, and plenty of opportunities for me to tell him he is wrong.
This Father’s Day, I find myself thinking less about one particular song and more about what lived beneath all of them: a father willing to enter the worlds that mattered to each of his daughters.
We still do not always hear things in exactly the same way. Perhaps we were never supposed to.
My sisters and I carried away different sounds, movements, and memories. Together, they tell a fuller story of a father who listened, a mother who quietly conducted and held those worlds together, and a family fortunate enough to keep finding connection through music.
Different rhythms.
A shared beat.
