Philosophy

8 size and distance comparisons: from subatomic to cosmic

8 size and distance comparisons: from subatomic to cosmic


Here in this Universe, there are multiple different ways to look at all that exists in terms of size. You can look at the physical size, or volumes, that the objects occupy, and you can do that in a variety of ways. For humans, we can measure our dimensions — things like our height, width, and depth — or the amount of volume we displace when placed in a bath of water. Whichever method we choose, we get a proxy for our size. For planets, we can look at the edges of their solid surfaces or atmospheres; for stars, we can look at the boundary of their photospheres; for atoms, we probe them through techniques like force microscopy or scattering experiments.

But in addition to these physical sizes, we can also examine such objects relative to other objects of the same type as found in nature. We can look at the distance from one human to another, for example, under a variety of common conditions. We can examine the distances between atoms, or stars, or planets, or galaxies, or anything else that we choose. And if we like, one interesting comparison that we can make, on any scale we choose, is the ratio between the physical size of the object itself to the distance from it to the next similar object.

If we were to do this, which scale would be the most extreme, and how does that relate to human scales that we’re familiar with? Let’s examine eight different scales, from the quantum to the cosmic, to find out.

Although, by volume, an atom is mostly empty space, dominated by the electron cloud, the dense atomic nucleus, responsible for only 1 part in 10^15 of an atom’s volume, contains ~99.95% of an atom’s mass. Reactions between internal components of a nucleus can be more precise and occur on shorter timescales, as well as at different energies, than transitions restricted to an atom’s electrons.
Credit: Yzmo and Mpfiz/Wikimedia Commons

1.) Subatomic scales

On scales smaller than an atom, we run into things like atomic nuclei, electrons, individual protons or neutrons within the nucleus, and quarks and gluons. Of these particles, it’s not necessarily fair to talk about “size” for most of them: quarks, gluons, and electrons are consistent with being what we call point particles, or particles consistent with having an actual size of 0. From scattering experiments, we’ve determined that if they do have a size, that size is no larger than about 10-19 meters, or a tenth of an attometer. Protons, neutrons, and atomic nuclei, however, do have an actual size: about that of a femtometer, or 10-15 meters.

Within this context, you might consider looking at the distance from one subatomic particle — like a proton or the nucleus — to an electron as a measure of distance on subatomic scales. (If you went to look between two protons in the same nucleus, you’d find that they were practically adjacent: a distance-to-size ratio of around 1-to-1.) Since electrons are typically around a tenth of a nanometer, or 10-10 meters, away from the nucleus, that results in a ratio of around 100,000-to-1. If the atomic nucleus were the size of a basketball located at Pepperdine University in Malibu, the electron would be roughly 24 kilometers (15 miles) away on the Santa Monica Pier.

The K-4 crystal consists exclusively of carbon atoms arranged in a lattice, but with an unconventional bond angle compared to either graphite, diamond, or graphene. These inter-atomic properties can lead to drastically different physical, chemical, and material properties even with identical chemical formulas for a variety of structures. The average separation between two atoms in a lattice-like structure is only marginally larger than the size of one atom itself.

Credit: Workbit/Wikimedia Commons

2.) Atomic scales

Atoms are the building block of nearly everything we find on Earth, with enormous numbers of these very, very small entities combining together to compose the entire world and so much more. Atoms make up the atmosphere, the seas, the rocks and soil, every living creature on our planet, and the entire world itself, as well as pretty much every other known world in the Universe and much more. Atoms are generally the same physical size everywhere in the Universe — with the smallest atom, helium, having a diameter of 0.06 nanometers and the largest well-measured one, cesium, having a diameter of between 0.520 and 0.596 nanometers — with a typical atom’s size being around 10-10 meters.

But atoms can come in a huge variety of configurations, with some configurations placing atoms almost perfectly adjacent to one another and others creating great separations between them. Some examples include:

  • in a water molecule, hydrogen and oxygen atoms are separated by 0.1 nanometers,
  • in a diamond, two carbon atoms are separated by 0.15 nanometers,
  • in the Earth’s crust, silicon and oxygen atoms are separated by 0.16 nanometers,
  • and in a helium balloon, gaseous, monatomic helium atoms are typically separated by 3.4 nanometers.

In solids and liquids, or wherever atoms are bound together into molecules, the next atom over is approximately only one or two atomic diameters away, while in a gas composed of atoms, the next atomic particle (at Earth’s standard pressure and temperature) is only a few dozen atom diameters away. If an atom again were a basketball on a basketball court, the next atom over for solids and liquids would be at the distance of a very tight defender, while for gases, the next atom over would be standing over by the 3-point line.

A diagram illustrating the physics behind ice skating.

Whereas ice requires water molecules to take on a relatively inefficient bond angle structure, even warm water achieves greater densities than ice does. At lower temperatures and higher pressures, liquid water is the densest form of water of all. The separation between water molecules in ocean water is approximately the same scale as the diameter of a water molecule itself.

Credit: World Ocean Review

3.) Molecular scales

This is an interesting one, because the separation distance between molecules depends tremendously on which type of molecules we’re talking about and the environment that they’re found in. Sure, when we think of molecules we typically think of something like water, which is a small molecule just 0.28 nanometers across: barely larger than an atom. But human DNA is also a molecule, albeit one that’s about three billion base pairs in length, spanning over a micron in length when coiled up (over 1000 nanometers) or extending for more than two meters if stretched out end-to-end. The protein Titin, found in striated muscle, is similarly large when coiled.

But what about the distances between molecules? Again, the distance depends on the environment, and it varies tremendously.

  • In red blood cells, the distance between hemoglobin molecules is about 7 nanometers, compared with the size of hemoglobin at about 5 nanometers.
  • In the ocean, water molecules are separated by about 0.31 nanometers, compared to a size of 0.28 nanometers.
  • Nitrogen molecules in Earth’s atmosphere at sea level are separated by 3.4 nanometers, while a nitrogen molecule is just 0.3 nanometers in size.
  • In Mars’s carbon dioxide-rich but thin atmosphere, however, the average separation distance is more like 17 nanometers, compared to a molecular size of 0.3 nanometers.

Although gases can be very sparse indeed, for most applications, if a molecule was the size of a basketball, the next molecule over would still be on the same basketball court, and in many cases, just around one basketball-diameter away.

A performer with a suitcase stands before a large, seated crowd in an outdoor amphitheater on a sunny day. An umbrella and a bicycle are visible in the foreground, sparking curiosity about why machines learn from such everyday scenes.

This crowd in Mauerpark, Berlin, is an excellent example of large numbers of people gathered together in one place: where the average separation distances between humans is small even compared to the scale of a single human. However, humans are spread out across a large area of the planet, heavily clustered together in urban areas. As such, the minimum separation distance between two humans varies tremendously dependent on location.

Credit: Loozrboy/flickr

4.) Human scales

At last, something we’re familiar with: the scales at which we live. A human being ranges in size from about 45 centimeters (18 inches) at birth to 2 meters (6’7″) for a very tall human. (There are greater extremes, but most of us fall somewhere in the middle.) For a full-grown adult human, most of us are somewhere between 150 cm and 190 cm: a narrower range that encompasses nearly 90% of the population over 18 years old. However, how well-separated we are varies tremendously depending on where we live.

  • If all 8.3 billion humans were evenly distributed across the Earth, we’d be spaced approximately 270 meters apart. (Including uninhabitable places like oceans or ice sheets.)
  • In the densest Tokyo wards (like Toshima), the average distance between the two closest people is just 3.25 meters apart.
  • In a Tokyo subway car during rush hour, the average spacing between humans is just 40 cm.
  • But in a rural area like northern Siberia, Russia, the average distance between any two people can rise to several kilometers.
  • And outside of the capital city of Nuuk, there are 17 towns and 56 small settlements along Greenland’s coastline; the average spacing between two nearest-neighbors outside of this rises to between 3 and 7 kilometers: the largest human-spacing on Earth.

Even in the sparsest, least population-dense places on Earth, humans are more closely packed together than subatomic particles are within an atom: with a maximum ratio of just a few thousand-to-1 in terms of distance-to-size. If a human were a basketball, those of us in cities would make a court that looked like the fans had just rushed it, but those of us in the most rural areas would still have other humans in the arena, but not necessarily on the court.

The TRAPPIST-1 system contains the most terrestrial-like planets of any stellar system presently known, and is shown scaled to temperature equivalents to our own Solar System. These seven known worlds, however, exist around a low-mass, consistently flaring red dwarf star. It’s plausible that exactly none of them have atmospheres any longer, although JWST will have more to say about that in future years.
Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech

5.) Planetary scales

But as we turn to planetary scales, things suddenly get very, very large in terms of both sizes and distances, with distances far exceeding the size scales. A planet like the Earth is large: about 12,700 km in diameter. Rocky planets can be significantly smaller, of course: Mercury is the smallest major planet in our Solar System with a diameter of 4880 km, but planets could, in theory, be just a few hundred kilometers in diameter and still meet all of the necessary criteria for being classified as a planet. On the largest end, Jupiter is 143,000 km in diameter, and several super-Jupiter exoplanets up to double Jupiter’s size are known.

Nonetheless, as impressive as those numbers are, they’re absolutely paltry compared to the distances between planets.

  • Relative to Earth, our nearest-neighbor planet at closest approach is Venus: 38 million km away, or about a factor of 3000 greater than Earth’s diameter.
  • For an outer planet like Uranus, its diameter of 51,000 km is peanuts compared to its separation from Saturn or Neptune: 1.43-1.45 billion km away, or a factor of 28,000.
  • Even in a close-packed planetary system like the TRAPPIST-1 system, the average spacing between planets is 1.26 million km, or more than a factor of 100 larger than the average TRAPPIST-1 planet diameter, at 12,100 km.

If a typical planet were a basketball, the most closely-spaced planetary systems would put the next-nearest planet somewhere still in the arena. If Earth were a basketball, the nearest planets would still be in the same town, while the outer distant planets would be quite a way down the highway. Still, the distance ratios are less extreme than inside an atom, but that all changes when we go to the next scale up.

stars in the nearby solar neighborhood

In the early 21st-century, we’ve successfully mapped out practically all the stars in our neighborhood in three-dimensional space. The closest stars to us don’t always align with the stars we can see, as what’s visible is determined by a combination of distance and intrinsic brightness, but all stars beyond the Sun are at a much, much greater distance than anything within our Solar System. The Alpha/Proxima Centauri system is a trinary, and has the three closest stars to our Sun at present; Barnard’s star is the fourth closest, and is the nearest singlet star system to our own. Stars themselves are millions of times smaller than the distances separating different star systems.

Credit: Andrew Z. Colvin

6.) Stellar scales

Even compared to the sizes of and distances between planets, the scales of stars are far more impressive. Our own Sun is a whopping 1.4 million km in diameter. Even the smallest red dwarf stars are significantly bigger than Jupiter, with Proxima Centauri coming in at 200,000 km across. On the other end of the spectrum, a blue giant like the brightest star in the Beta Centauri system is over 13 million km across. An evolved red giant like Arcturus is closer to 35 million km in diameter, while a massive, evolved red supergiant like Betelgeuse is closer to a whopping 900 million km across. Some stars even cross the billion kilometers mark in terms of physical size!

But the distances between stars are in a whole other league. From the Sun to Proxima Centauri, our closest star, it’s 4.24 light-years, or 40 trillion km: a distance-to-size ratio of 28 million-to-1 for the Sun. Stars in globular clusters can be closer together: separated by as little as 0.15 light-years in the cluster core, but that still yields a distance-to-size ratio of a million-to-1 for most stars. And in the sparser places — like the ultra-diffuse galaxies of the Universe — average stellar separations can rise to 20 light-years, while the average star is even smaller than the Sun: exceeding a 100,000,000-to-1 distance-to-size ratio.

The distances between stars, even relative to the massive size of a star itself, provide the most extreme distance-to-size ratios of any object on any scale in the Universe. If our Sun were a basketball, the next-nearest star would be located on the opposite side of the Earth from our gym!

largest galaxy

Composite of galaxies from the smallest to the largest, shown (approximately) actual size. The giant elliptical galaxy at the heart of cluster Abell 2029, IC 1101, is the largest known galaxy in the Universe, at least in terms of stellar extent. It is much, much larger than the Milky Way or Andromeda (or any spiral galaxy), but also towers over even other typical giant ellipticals.
Credit: E. Siegel

7.) Galactic scales

Stars aren’t completely isolated, however. They’re bound together in extremely large-magnitude collections of their own: galaxies. The distances between galaxies absolutely outscales the distances between stars in impressive fashion. Therefore, you might wonder about the scale of a galaxy compared to the distances between galaxies; perhaps it’s even more impressive.

Our own Milky Way contains approximately 400 billion stars, largely confined to a disk 100,000 light-years across. Smaller galaxies, like a variety of dwarf galaxies, are often only a few thousand light-years in diameter. Meanwhile, the largest known single galaxy of all, IC 1101, has a diffuse halo of starlight that extends for over 4 million light-years (and maybe up to 6 million light-years) across. Galaxies can be tiny or enormous, with Milky Way-like galaxies sitting squarely between them.

The nearest Milky Way-like galaxy to our own is Andromeda, which is the only other galaxy in the Local Group with as much mass as our Milky Way possesses. It’s quite distant, too: 2.5 million light-years away. However, that means we have a distance-to-size ratio of just 25-to-1! If the Milky Way were a basketball located at the basket itself, Andromeda would be roughly at the free-throw line. Galaxies are often grouped together, and even isolated galaxies — or field galaxies — are usually between 10-15 million light-years from another major galaxy. Because galaxies themselves are so big, the distance-to-size ratios for these objects aren’t nearly as impressive as we find on even planetary scales.

coma cluster zwicky dark matter

The Coma Cluster of galaxies, as seen with a composite of modern space and ground-based telescopes. The infrared data comes from the Spitzer Space Telescope, while ground-based data comes from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey. The Coma Cluster is dominated by two giant elliptical galaxies, with over 1000 other spirals and ellipticals inside. Gas-free, red-and-dead elliptical galaxies are very common, especially toward the cluster center, in large galaxy clusters such as this one. The cluster spans over 20 million light-years across, but is separated by nearby clusters by around 100 million light-years.

Credit: NASA / JPL-Caltech / L. Jenkins (GSFC)

8.) Super-galactic (galaxy group/cluster) scales

You might think, then, to look to the largest scales of all: the scales at which galaxies collect together into groups and clusters. We’re a part of the Local Group: a collection of galaxies that includes Andromeda, our Milky Way, and a few hundred smaller galaxies all bound together. We’re not all that big of a group, as many galaxy clusters contain thousands of large galaxies all bound together, but we still extend for between 3-5 million light-years in total span. The largest galaxy clusters, like the Coma Cluster, can span more than 20 million light-years from end-to-end.

Sure, space is vast and mostly empty, but the separations between galaxy groups and clusters is even less severe than it is for galaxies when compared to their sizes. We have other galaxy groups relatively close to our own: the M81 group, for example, is less than 12 million light-years away, for a 4-to-1 distance-to-size ratio at most. For bigger structures, like galaxy clusters, the separation distances are greater, but the sizes are also greater. The Virgo cluster and the Fornax cluster are two of the nearest galaxy clusters to Earth, separated by around 100 million light-years in space from each other. But with a diameter of 15 million light-years, the Virgo cluster has only about a 7-to-1 distance-to-size ratio.

If galaxy groups and clusters were basketballs, their neighboring groups and clusters would be able to make up a “starting 5” as well as an opposing team, and fit them all on the same half of the basketball court. It’s a fairly crowded place when you consider such large structures, after all.

Loneliest galaxy MCG+01–02–015 Hubble

The isolated galaxy MCG+01-02-015, all by its lonesome for over 100,000,000 light-years in all directions, is presently thought to be the loneliest galaxy in the Universe. The features seen in this galaxy are consistent with it being a massive spiral that formed from a long series of minor mergers, but that has never experienced a major merger, and where star-forming activity has been relatively quiet for the past several billion years. It’s the size of a galaxy, but as isolated as a typical galaxy cluster.

Credit: ESA/Hubble & NASA and N. Grogin (STScI); Acknowledgement: Judy Schmidt

This means, in terms of a distance-to-size ratio, it’s the stellar scales that are the most impressive. Compared to even the size of the largest stars, the cosmic distances separating them are absolutely tremendous, typically reaching ratios of several million-to-1. As big as a star is, the distance separating the stars gives us the most extreme ratios.

In second place is the separation between subatomic particles within an atom: electrons within an atom or the separation between the atomic nuclei and an electron. That ratio of 100,000-to-1 outclasses all scales except the stellar, putting it in a strong second place on this list.

In third place are planetary scales, which are less extreme than subatomic particles, but which have more extreme separations than humans do on planet Earth, which (perhaps surprisingly) comes in fourth on this list. Galactic scales typically follow next in fifth, with atomic separations (at least, in gases) coming in sixth.

It’s fairly remarkable that the two most extreme examples of a distance-to-size ratio occur on such different scales than one another: one of them on interstellar scales and one on tiny, subatomic scales. The reason for it is the same in both cases: the objects are simply physically much, much smaller than the distances separating them from the next-nearest such object. From the quantum to the cosmic, the Universe is full of delights and surprises.

This article 8 size and distance comparisons: from subatomic to cosmic is featured on Big Think.



Source link

Filed under: Philosophy

Selected by

Avatar photo

Im a doctor in training and I believe in a secular world