To kick off the process, we enlist the GQ Recommends braintrust to vote on our contenders. Some of the folks involved have worked in retail, slinging clothes to the masses; others have toiled for small-batch menswear labels; all spend way too much time thinking about what hangs in their closets.

We lean on that collective experience to guide our search, culling a mix of household names, indie favorites, and the artisanal imprints on the bleeding-edge of the genre. Then we narrow down the assortment to the picks that scored the highest across quality, fit, and price.

Across the majority of our buying guides, our team boasts firsthand experience with the bulk of our selects, but a handful are totally new to us. So after several months of intense debate, we tally the votes, collate the anecdotal evidence, and emerge with a list of what we believe to be the absolute best of the category right now, from the tried-and-true stalwarts to the modern disruptors, the affordable beaters to the wildly expensive (but wildly worth-it) designer riffs.

Whatever your preferences, whatever your style, there’s bound to be a superlative version on this list for you.

What Are Athletic-Fit Jeans, Anyway?

Even with the skinny jeans era thankfully behind us, it can be difficult for bigger fellas to find denim that fits flatteringly and comfortably. Or it was, anyway, before a handful of denim brands started tailoring their dungarees specifically to the needs of swoler physiques. Enter the athletic fit, a roomier and more forgiving silhouette that accentuates your legs rather than hiding them under a baggy, JNCO-esque curtain of fabric. If you’re a committed leg day practitioner or just the proud owner of a dad bod, these are the best athletic fit jeans for every budget that’ll look and feel incredible straight off the rack.

What to Look for in a Great Pair of Athletic-Fit Jeans

Given that expert wisdom, the most important factor for a good pair of men’s athletic fit jeans has to do with the top block of the jeans—the thighs and the seat. The top block should have extra room all-around to accommodate larger frames. And while not totally necessary, it helps if they’ve got a medium rise or a high rise that actually tapers closer to the body so you don’t have that dreaded crack-baring waist gap. That said, athletic cuts with lower rises can work too if you’re after that kind of Y2K-reminiscent style.

Big Tips from Big-Thigh’d Guys

We consider ourselves pretty big denimheads, but big thigh’d guys, we are not. So we tapped some real heads with real big thighs for tips on how to find the perfect pair of jeans.

“There are so many different bodies and all of them can achieve similar looks,” says Albert Muzquiz, a fashion influencer, actor, and denim expert whose resume includes stints at Self Edge and Heddels. “But they have to look at different cuts that have different names.” There’s endless talk about the Levi’s 501 as the ultimate jean. Aside from literally birthing a new type of garment, the 501’s iconic fit is basically a yard stick for every other straight-leg silhouette out there. But it ain’t gonna fit the same way for a rail-thin body as it will for someone with thunder thighs.

You might be after a straight-leg fit, but you’ll probably have to do some transposing to figure out which models actually offer your personal perfect fit. What’s marketed as a slim jean only fits comfortably on a handful of frames. For people who have bigger legs, they can achieve a slimmer, tailored look, but they have to look at different models.

“I look for a high rise,” Musquiz says. “I tend to find that any jean that’s cut with a high rise almost always has a more accommodating thigh.” Muzquiz also notes that folks who work out a lot tend to have a smaller waist relative to their frame. Because of that, higher rise jeans tend to accommodate that differential better. Higher rise jeans sit higher up on the body (duh) which naturally gives you more room in the top block. Not only does it give the wearer more room, it also gives them the option to wear the jeans higher or lower, depending on their preference.

The perfect pair of jeans is like Atlantis—it probably doesn’t exist. Or at least, for most people, it doesn’t exist straight off the rack. That’s why both Muzquiz and Brandon Mahler, a visuals manager in New York, advocate for taking your jeans to the tailor. The jeans journey is enough of a hassle, so why in Ralph Lauren’s name would you want to add another step to it? Well, you might actually waste more time searching for those Atlantis jeans. Instead, what you want to do is get a pair of jeans that fits close enough and take them to the tailor. It’s important to make sure they fit well in the top block—that is, the area around the hips, seat, and crotch—since that area won’t stretch very much and it’s harder for a tailor to adjust.