All posts tagged: uncertainty

The Wisdom of Uncertainty

The Wisdom of Uncertainty

This is an edition of The Wonder Reader, a newsletter in which our editors recommend a set of stories to spark your curiosity and fill you with delight. Sign up here to get it every Saturday morning. How comfortable are you with saying, “I don’t know”? Most of us spend our lives trying to know more. We look things up, seek expert advice, and gather information before making decisions. In many cases when we disagree with someone, we assume that if we could just establish the facts, one of us would turn out to be right. We accumulate knowledge until, we hope, the uncertainty disappears. But what if uncertainty never fully goes away? In a recent Atlantic essay, the physicist Carlo Rovelli argues that modern science complicates the idea that we can ever arrive at a completely objective description of reality. Even physics suggests that what we see can depend on the relationship between the observer and what they’re looking at. We are not standing outside the world looking in, Rovelli writes. We are part …

Responding Skillfully to Uncertainty

Responding Skillfully to Uncertainty

By Lizabeth Roemer, Ph.D., and Josh Bartok, M.S. In times such as these, life may seem more uncertain than ever—but meeting uncertainty has always been part of our lives. Whenever we try new things, we are putting ourselves into uncertain contexts that could contain social threats, disappointments, or hurt. When our routines change (due to a new school year, transition at work, move, birth, death, or break-up), we face uncertainty about how we will adapt and what the near or far future might look like. And of course, right now, our sociopolitical context is filled with sources of uncertainty—the impact of climate change, high-stakes political upheavals, economic challenges, and other injustices and sources of real and potential harm. Psychological research indicates that uncertainty is related to mental health challenges, including anxiety and depression. It is human to experience fear and distress, and it is human to have a desire to constrict or avoid when faced with uncertain threats or challenges. Often uncertain contexts lead to habits of worry—trying to plan, predict, or avoid threat by …

What Will You Do to Escape Uncertainty?

What Will You Do to Escape Uncertainty?

What is your relationship to uncertainty? For most of us, ambiguity serves as the basis of anxiety, which is a categorically uncomfortable feeling. How far will you go to escape the anxiety associated with not knowing? Some of us can remain in limbo indefinitely. In contrast, others will act to exit the state of not knowing, often making bad or impulsive decisions to regain clarity and escape ambiguity. Let’s look at two different examples of managing uncertainty I have seen in my work. Chloe is a lawyer in her early thirties and was six months into dating someone she thought would become her long-term partner when she noticed a subtle shift: he changed the cadence of his text responses and seemed distracted on dates. She began seeking reassurance from him that the relationship was “ok.” Despite his affirmations of love and support, she had difficulty with not knowing where she stood. To escape her intense anxiety, she ended the relationship, which was very painful, but offered immediate relief from the uncertainty. Now let’s look at …

The Philosopher’s Guide to Uncertainty

The Philosopher’s Guide to Uncertainty

There is a paradox at the heart of being human. On the one hand, we have to make plans for the future. We go to jobs, book vacations, and save for our retirement. But on the other, life is never straightforward, and the best laid plans often go wrong. The old Yiddish proverb, “Man plans, and God laughs,” captures the limits of our ability to control the future. So how are we to resolve the paradox? How can we feel confident planning for a future that we can’t predict? How can we make rational, thoughtful decisions when we have no idea what lurks around the corner? In this Big Think Live event for members only, Dan Hayes talks with Jonny Thomson about the philosophy of decision-making. Together, they draw on Stoicism, Buddhism, and modern psychology to explore how we can walk the narrow path between control and surrender. The event will feature an extensive Q&A session with an invitation for members to offer their own stories of decision-making and to give their own commentary on …

How to Thrive Amid Uncertainty in an Endlessly Changing World

How to Thrive Amid Uncertainty in an Endlessly Changing World

1. Walker, E. Y. et al. Studying the neural representations of uncertainty. Nat. Neurosci. 26, 1857–1867 (2023). 2. Harp, N. R., Nielsen, A. N., Schultz, D. H. & Neta, M. In the face of ambiguity: intrinsic brain organization in development predicts one’s bias toward positivity or negativity. Cereb. Cortex N. Y. NY 34, bhae102 (2024). 3. Fernandes, T. P., Santos, N. A. & Dahlgren, L. N. Signal-to-Noise Efficiency Explains Inter-Observer Variability in Orientation Discrimination. Vision 10, 4 (2026). 4. Sarinopoulos, I. et al. Uncertainty during anticipation modulates neural responses to aversion in human insula and amygdala. Cereb. Cortex 20, 929–940 (2010). 5. Qiao, Z., Geng, H., Wang, Y. & Li, X. Anticipation of Uncertain Threat Modulates Subsequent Affective Responses and Covariation Bias. Front. Psychol. 9, 2547 (2018). 6. Redshaw, J. & Ganea, P. A. Thinking about possibilities: mechanisms, ontogeny, functions and phylogeny. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B. Biol. Sci. 377, 20210333 (2022). 7. Aytur, S. A. et al. Neural Mechanisms of Acceptance and Commitment Therapy for Chronic Pain: A Network-Based fMRI Approach. Front. Hum. …

AI and the Wisdom of Uncertainty

AI and the Wisdom of Uncertainty

New research shows that people with access to AI-generated answers are less willing to admit “I don’t know,” even when those answers are wrong. In the study, researchers asked participants very specific, obscure questions about films. Participants could always decline to answer and admit they did not know, suspending judgment instead of guessing. The stakes were raised with a monetary penalty for mistakes. But across every version of the experiment, having access to AI advice nearly eliminated participants’ willingness to say they did not know, even though AI advice was usually wrong on these questions. In another study, researchers found that intellectual humility, the metacognitive awareness of one’s own limited knowledge, acted as a protective cognitive filter against AI-generated health misinformation. Participants with higher intellectual humility rated pseudoscientific content as less credible. The Known Problem of Automation Bias Longstanding evidence on automation bias illustrates the human tendency to over-rely on and defer to automated outputs. This has been a concern in medical decision-making and other fields like aviation. In the case of AI chatbots, some …

Rowing through the fog: how to increase your tolerance for uncertainty

Rowing through the fog: how to increase your tolerance for uncertainty

Simone Stolzoff describes himself as “naturally an uncertain person” inclined to rumination and self-doubt. This tendency benefits him in his work as a journalist, but can otherwise be a double-edged sword. While working for a magazine in New York, Stolzoff was approached about a job at a design firm in San Francisco. Now, he laughs at how tortured he felt “having to decide between two attractive career paths”. But, at the time, “it really sent me for an existential loop,” he says. “I could see these two diverging paths – Simone the journalist, Simone the designer – and, for the life of me, I could not make up my mind.” Stolzoff talked his options through – with everybody. “My yoga teacher, my Uber driver, all my friends and family …” He grimaces. “I was insufferable.” He wound up choosing the San Francisco job: a new home, an unfamiliar industry. The experience informed his new book, How to Not Know: The Value of Uncertainty in a World That Demands Answers. Looking back, Stolzoff says over video-call …

Reclaiming Hope in a Time of Uncertainty

Reclaiming Hope in a Time of Uncertainty

What have you been doing with your hope lately? Do you notice yourself tucking it away or holding it quietly? Do you allow yourself to share it and speak it out loud? Is it bringing you to action? Recent findings from the Gallup National Health and Well-Being Index provide a snapshot of how U.S. adults are viewing their future. Among more than 22,000 respondents, just 59.2% rate their life in five years as a 7 or higher out of 10, marking a record low. When fewer U.S. adults rate their future positively compared to prior years, it tells us something important about the emotional climate people are living in. Over the past several years, individuals have navigated prolonged uncertainty, economic pressure, political division, social unrest, and collective fatigue. When people feel worn down by uncertainty, it changes how the brain scans for the future, and as stress becomes sustained, our nervous systems begin to prioritize protection over possibility. This doesn’t mean people have lost hope entirely, but it does suggest that hope is under strain. …

Relatives with lower paternity uncertainty are perceived as kinder

Relatives with lower paternity uncertainty are perceived as kinder

According to a large study published in Evolutionary Psychology, people consistently perceive family members as kinder when there is greater certainty of biological relatedness. Humans often assume that kindness within families is driven mainly by love, shared history, or cultural expectations. Yet evolutionary theories suggest that altruism within families may also be shaped by genetic relatedness. According to kin selection theory, people are predisposed to invest more care and support in relatives who are more likely to share their genes, because such investment indirectly promotes their own genetic success. One important factor complicating this picture is paternity uncertainty, the fact that, unlike maternity, biological fatherhood is never absolutely certain. Radim Kuba and Jaroslav Flegr examined whether this uncertainty influences how people perceive kindness among different family members. Drawing on evolutionary psychology and prior findings on parental and grandparental investment, they asked whether relatives associated with higher paternity certainty (such as mothers or maternal grandmothers) are consistently seen as kinder than those associated with lower certainty (such as paternal grandfathers). The researchers analyzed data from a …

Leading Through Uncertainty at Work

Leading Through Uncertainty at Work

Uncertainty has become the defining feature of today’s workplace—whether driven by economic shifts, organizational restructuring, rapid advances in artificial intelligence (AI), changing client expectations, or the constant re-prioritization that keeps teams on edge. This ambiguity doesn’t just create operational challenges; it erodes focus, fuels burnout, and chips away at trust. Leaders who understand the psychological impact of uncertainty can take intentional steps to create clarity, stability, and connection to reduce its toll. A recent study helps explain exactly why uncertainty is so psychologically taxing. A new meta-analysis synthesizing 76 fMRI studies shows that nine separate areas of the brain get activated in uncertain environments. Those nine brain areas make up both emotional pathways and cognitive pathways, and when all those areas fire, the brain has much less capacity for things like focus and sound decision-making. In fact, it leaves parts of your brain offline or unavailable, which may help explain why you might feel more brain fog, feel an inability to remember details or retain information, experience hesitancy when making decisions, or keep re-reading details …