Self-Silencing, Gaslighting, and Poor Mental Health
In the 1990s, psychologist Dana Jack noticed a pattern among some of her female patients. Some of her patients were choosing to stay silent about important issues in their relationships, stifling their own self-expression to maintain a sense of intimacy and stability. Forgoing self-expression out of concern for the relationship is known as self-silencing, and it is associated with poor mental health and depression. Self-silencing theory attributes this tendency among women to socialization into traditional gender roles. Recently, Ercan Aras and Meva Demir-Kaya at Igdir University and Ataturk University in Türkiye noticed that self-silencing has some conceptual similarities to gaslighting. Just as self-silencers are placing their partner’s needs above their own, targets of gaslighting are placing their gaslighter’s viewpoint above their own. In both gaslighting and self-silencing, this prioritization of the other’s needs and views over one’s own is theorized to be for the sake of maintaining an intimate connection. Both gaslighting and self-silencing can lead to adverse mental health outcomes, such as depression. Finally, while anyone can be a target of gaslighting or self-silencing, …

