Lifestyle

Do Youth Suicide Prevention Programs Work?

Do Youth Suicide Prevention Programs Work?

Suicide in all age groups has increased dramatically in the last decade. This increase has been especially pronounced among children and adolescents. Suicide is now the second leading cause of death among youth aged 10 to 14 years and the third leading cause of death among adolescents aged 15 to 19 years (Flores et al., 2024). Studies indicate that although male adolescents (and adults) have significantly higher rates of suicide, females have shown the greatest rate of increase in the last decade. This increase in suicide and self-harm has been attributed to a number of factors, including use of social media, cyberbullying, sexploitation, and AI chatbots, which will be the topics of a future blog.

Adolescent Early Warning Signs

In adolescents, suicide is often preceded by episodes of intentional self-harm. A single episode of self-harm by an adolescent increases that young person’s risk for death from any cause 4-fold, and death from suicide 10-fold (Wright-Hughes et al., 2025). At least one study has found that even an unintentional injury, especially one related to intoxication or aggression, significantly increases subsequent risk for self-harm and suicide (Frajerman et al., 2024). Since serious episodes of self-harm often lead to a mental health evaluation, a majority of adolescents who die by suicide have previously presented to a mental health professional, often with suicidal and/or self-harm ideation (Mojtabai et al., 2025).

At several points in my career, I (Frank W. Putnam) was repeatedly confronted with evaluating the risk for self-harm and suicide in adolescents and young adults. It was always a difficult and anxiety-provoking responsibility, especially when assessing the more “adolescent” (in terms of impulse control) individuals. One is often left anxiously second-guessing. Fortunately, we never had a successful suicide.

Until recently, I would have attributed that success to good luck and to the fact that we would put in place a safety plan and a prevention program. While semi-personalized, the safety plans and prevention programs shared common features, including: education on warning signs and triggers, bolstering internal and external coping strategies, setting up emergency contacts, making connections to community and school-based mental health services, and reducing access to lethal means (Mojtabai et al., 2025). One stimulation-based study found, for example, that as many as a third of teenage firearm deaths could be prevented by secure storage of guns (Monuteaux et al., 2025).

Do Youth Suicide Prevention Programs Work?

A recent meta-analysis of 39 randomized controlled studies, however, found that there was no clear-cut evidence that formal youth suicide safety and prevention programs actually work. Indeed, after the first episode of self-harm, there was no evidence that specialized programs produced a significant decrease in subsequent episodes of self-harm or suicide for the following 6 to 12 months compared with a randomized control condition—usually treatment as usual (TAU) or an enhanced TAU (e-TAU) (Wright-Hughes et al., 2025).

It was noted, however, that there were small positive effects for adolescents with multiple self-harm episodes. (Cognitive Behavioral Therapy models such as the Military Suicide Prevention Intervention (MSPIRE) model have been shown in randomized clinical trials to reduce suicide in adults [Bryan et al., 2025]).

In fact, the current child and adolescent self-harm and suicide prevention programs are most likely much better than doing nothing. For ethical reasons, all of the studies in the metanalysis randomized control subjects into an active intervention of some type. But these programs are not doing enough to stop the rapidly mounting crisis of youth suicide and self-injury. Despite our growing awareness of the unmet need for better youth suicide and self-harm prevention programs, we lack a national commitment and the necessary funding and resources to develop, validate, and disseminate programs to guide clinicians treating youth at elevated risk for self-harm and suicide.

School Shootings: A Growing Form of Youth Suicide

An historically new form of adolescent suicide is also spreading through our society: school mass shootings, which typically end with the suicide of the shooter or “suicide via the police.” These incredibly tragic episodes are increasing in frequency and lethality as suicidal male adolescents often seem intent on achieving “fame” by running up the body count. This horrible form of youth suicide puts all of our children at risk, every single school day.

While these events are statistically still relatively rare, the pervasive threat of a school shooting profoundly impacts all children’s sense of safety while at school, which should be a refuge. In some instances, kids tag deviant or angry classmates as “most likely to become a school shooter,” and this may become a tragic self-fulfilling prophecy. The suicide of any child or adolescent is a tragedy for family and friends, but the enormous, society-wide impacts of recent school shootings (almost exclusively by young males), compound those individual costs by orders of magnitude.

What Can We Do About the Growing Tragedy of Youth Suicide?

First, we should continue providing the safety planning, family-based crisis support, and brief continuity of care programs currently in place. It is likely that these programs do far more good than harm, even though it is difficult to prove this for ethical and methodological reasons. Second, we must improve and better integrate these current services through systematic research conducted at the levels of the individual patient, public health, and community institutions serving children and families (e.g., child welfare, school, pediatrics, mental health, and juvenile justice).

As we become more confident in the efficacy of our intervention models, we need to invest in the infrastructure required to address the magnitude of this enormous and increasing problem on a national scale. Remember, suicide is currently the second or third leading cause of child and adolescent death, and growing. Also, the death of any family member by suicide increases the risk of other household members dying from any cause about 4-fold. So, effective youth suicide prevention programs can save the lives of many people, in addition to the suicidal child or adolescent.

If we can do this, I believe that we will also discover that the best way to prevent school and other mass shootings by suicidal adolescents is by preventing youth suicide in general.

If you or someone you love is contemplating suicide, seek help immediately. For help 24/7 contact the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline by calling 988, or the Crisis Text Line by texting HOME to 741741.

To find a therapist near you, see the Psychology Today Therapy Directory.



Source link