Sir Keir Starmer has been accused of taking a softer stance on family voting to appease the Left and win over Muslim voters.
In government, the Tories changed voter fraud guidance to ensure the Electoral Commission, which oversees UK elections, made tackling family voting a priority.
Labour has abandoned those plans despite reports of “concerningly high levels” of family voting in the Gorton and Denton by-election last month.
Family voting, which is illegal, is an attempt to influence someone’s vote in the polling booth. It has become a particular concern in parts of the country with high Muslim populations because wives culturally can take their lead from their husbands.
In 2022, the Conservative government gave the Electoral Commission tougher new guidelines for “tackling fraud”.
They included “providing clear guidance to deliver robust polls that meet the UK’s highest standards of democratic integrity”, which ensured “the secrecy of the ballot inside polling stations by making it clear in both advice and guidance that any breach of the secrecy laws or attempt to influence someone’s vote while in the polling booth is an offence”.
While the practice remains illegal, the decision by Labour to remove this guidance to the Electoral Commission has led to accusations Labour ministers no longer see tackling voter fraud as a priority.
Ministers have been accused by the Tories of “grubbing around” for Muslim votes following a surge in popularity for the Green Party. The change comes after Labour lost its stronghold seat of Gorton and Denton to Hannah Spencer, the Green Party candidate, last month.
Labour initially said it would keep the Tory guidance in place, but it has since pledged to repeal it.
Labour has traditionally performed well in Muslim communities, but the party’s position on the war in Gaza has seen voters flock to Green and independent candidates.
Sir James Cleverly, the shadow communities secretary, told The Telegraph: “Off the back of a by-election marked by allegations of breaches of electoral law, this Labour Government is now going soft on electoral fraud as part of a wider lurch to the sectarian Left.
“Labour have U-turned again, scrapping the commitment in their own election strategy to focus on the security of the ballot box – a focus brought in by the Conservatives.”
In 2022, the Tory government said its new strategy for the Electoral Commission would address “cross-party concerns about the practice of so-called family voting or ‘community voting’ in some areas of the country”.
It pointed to research suggesting that 5 per cent of voters observed in Tower Hamlets earlier that year were either causing or affected by family voting. It found that more than 85 per cent of those affected were women, predominantly from Asian backgrounds.
The Prime Minister has abandoned plans to cancel local elections for 4.6 million people – House of Commons
In 2018, it was estimated that 19 per cent of voters in Tower Hamlets were in some way linked to the practice.
Sir James added: “Ministers are removing safeguards introduced because of the endemic fraud in Tower Hamlets, deleting guidance for local councils about how to stop family voting, and introducing secretive election pilots to gerrymander the democratic process to their own partisan advantage.
“After their botched attempts to cancel local elections, Labour cannot be trusted to uphold our democracy.”
The Green Party won 40.7 per cent of the vote in Gorton and Denton, with Reform UK second and Labour in third place in its former stronghold.
The Greens were accused of manipulating Gorton’s Muslim vote after publishing leaflets in Urdu urging residents to “punish Labour for Gaza”.
Accredited poll observers said they had witnessed “concerningly high levels” of family voting on the day, with 32 separate incidents recorded in 15 of the 22 polling stations.
The alleged spike in cases in Gorton and Denton, which has a large British-Pakistani population, prompted Reform UK to accuse the Green Party of “cheating”.
Nigel Farage, the Reform leader, reported the findings to the police, who are assessing the claims.
Lord Jackson, a Tory peer who raised the issue in the Lords earlier this month, said Labour was “de-prioritising family voting because they are grubbing around for votes from the South Asian community”.
The peer called for “tougher powers” for police to tackle the issue, warning it is “almost impossible to challenge someone at the polling station”.
“When you know everyone should be equal before the law, you either believe in the sanctity and the integrity of the ballot and everyone’s vote is equal and should be protected, or you don’t, and I think people generally don’t trust this Labour Government to do the right thing,” he said.
A spokesman for the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government said: “We completely reject this. Family voting is illegal and is a matter for the returning officer and the police.
“We’re reinforcing the commission’s independence, further strengthening its ability to oversee future elections.
“This will not impact the tackling of family voting – as enforcement is for the police not the Electoral Commission.”