Education

Inside the overnight row over EU fees

Inside the overnight row over EU fees


For the best part of eighteen months, the question of what EU students should pay to study in the UK has hung over the latest post-Brexit “reset”.

It’s been an issue too small to bother most of the cabinet, too symbolic for Brussels to drop, and too expensive for those universities who would carry the cost to want anything to do with it.

When Keir Starmer stood at Lancaster House in May 2025, he insisted the deal “doesn’t deal with university fees”.

By the spring British officials were calling a cut a “non-starter”, by the autumn Andy Burnham’s government was costing a £450m subsidy in exchange for a place in Made in Europe, and by Thursday night negotiators in Brussels thought they had parked the whole thing for another six months.

They hadn’t. By Friday morning there were two texts in circulation – one agreed by both sides, the other by the EU alone – and two incompatible accounts of what the summit had settled.

How that happened explains who was holding the pen, and what the six months now on the clock are really for.

A long night

On Thursday evening the story was that the EU had blinked. In the Guardian’s account of the final round of talks, the UK had resisted text committing it to home fees rather than “significantly reduced” international fees, a compromise was reached before 10pm, and Brussels insiders admitted they had kicked the can down the road by leaving the fee rate out of the declaration.

But Brussels had moved on by breakfast. Before Andy Burnham arrived, Rapporteur and then Politico had seen a separate statement of the Council and the Commission, drafted after the overnight talks and put to ambassadors by written procedure that morning:

The Council agrees that adoption of the Council Decisions on signing of the ETS, SPS and YES agreements will not precede the conclusion of the negotiations on the supplementing Agreement providing for equal treatment on tuition fees.”

The sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) agreement on food and drink, the link between the UK and EU emissions trading systems (ETS) and the youth experience scheme (YES) could all be agreed, but the EU wouldn’t sign any of them until fees were settled – on the equal treatment wording the UK thought it had seen off a few hours earlier. A senior EU official insisted “we are not taking anyone hostage here”, which tends to be what people say when they are holding something hostage.

Within an hour of the prime minister’s arrival, No 10 declared that “the deal is done”, and at the press conference Burnham said it was “there in black and white in front of you”, with a bill entering Parliament next week.

Ursula von der Leyen put the fee work “on a different sheet of paper” and said she was confident of a solution. Asked directly whether the three deals depended on fees, António Costa wittered on for several minutes without saying either way.

By the weekend Ed Miliband was telling the BBC the agreements would “absolutely” become law regardless. His only evidence was von der Leyen’s bit of paper – a remark about where the fee talks happen, not about whether anything depends on them.

Two texts, one night

Basically, each side is relying on a different document, agreed within hours of the other, and the UK is party to only one of them.

Paragraph 41 of the joint statement commits both sides to work towards a supplementing agreement to the Trade and Cooperation Agreement “on tuition fees”, covering all students “irrespective of the immigration pathway” and concluded within six months – by around 20 May. It sets no fee standard and no condition.

Paragraph 50 links SPS, ETS and YES to each other through a “joint and timely entry into force”, but says nothing about fees.

The Commission’s own questions and answers on the summit are just as silent – no equal treatment, no condition – even though the Commission co-signed the Council statement that says the opposite.

The drafting trail shows how the joint text was emptied out. The first leaked draft at the start of November had the full “equal treatment with nationals” formula, and an EU text of 10 November said the same. By 18 November the draft sent to ambassadors had both options in square brackets – “significantly reduced undergraduate” fees for the UK, equal treatment for the EU. On Thursday night both were deleted, leaving the bare words “on tuition fees”.

From London that looks like the EU backing down. From Brussels it looks like the UK walking away from wording it seemed to accept at the start of the month – which is why the member states, rather than the Commission, then reached for a side statement to restore what the joint text had dropped.

The Council’s document register then fills in the timing. A note headed “Statement of the Council and the Commission” went to delegations on Thursday 19 November, and a written procedure, CM 5131, started the same day. It was reissued as a revision on Friday and closed with an end-of-procedure notice, CM 5132. The statement was formally adopted, and all four documents are closed to the public.

Agence Europe’s version of the adopted text refers to the “satisfactory conclusion” of the fee talks. If that’s right, the Council decides whether the talks succeeded as well as when they finished.

Who wanted the lock

The Commission had been relaxed about deferral. It proposed parking fees for six months to save the summit, and in July it pitched a compromise in which EU students would pay more than the home rate. The Commons Library records summer reports of a fee set at the cost of delivery, and on 3 November an EU diplomat told Reuters that “equal treatment” meant a big cut but not necessarily the home rate.

The capitals were less flexible. At least six member states, some from central and eastern Europe, wanted a firm commitment before the summit, and Rapporteur identifies a group including Italy, Hungary, Slovenia, Spain, Romania, Slovakia and Bulgaria that wanted fees tied to food trade and energy.

An EU diplomat quoted by the FT explained why – without fees, “for some countries there’s nothing to gain from this deal”. A state that sells little cheese to Britain and has no stake in carbon market linkage sees cheaper degrees as its only prize. The European Parliament’s trade chair Bernd Lange, whose committee’s consent will matter later, was warning by Friday afternoon against letting young people in and then pricing them out.

The money barely divides the two sides. In the final talks the UK reportedly offered as little as £12,000, against an EU figure of around £13,000 in October. A thousand pounds isn’t what this row is about – the mechanism is.

The UK has been consistent about its own starting point. In a letter to the Lords European Affairs Committee in September, Hamish Falconer said fee status wasn’t agreed in May 2025, isn’t part of the Common Understanding and is “distinct from” the youth scheme talks. Brussels spent the year treating fees as the price of YES and, by Friday morning, as the price of the whole package.

Diplomats’ kids?

The weekend brought a different explanation. Picking up a line first run by the Sunday Times in May 2025 – that von der Leyen has a child at an English university – this weekend’s Mail coverage had Anand Menon and others suggesting the push was really about senior EU officials wanting cheaper Russell Group places for their own children.

The negotiating record doesn’t fit that story. If Brussels insiders were driving it, the Commission would have been the hawk – instead it was the institution offering deferral and a fee above the home rate. The pressure came from capitals, and the list Rapporteur identifies is weighted to central, eastern and southern Europe, with CER’s Charles Grant pointing to Poland and the Baltic states and Cypriot MEP Loucas Fourlas pressing the case in the European Parliament.

That matches where the collapse happened. In the first year of international fees, new students from Poland fell by 78 per cent and from Romania by 83 per cent, against 53 per cent across the EU, on British Council analysis of HESA data. For governments in Warsaw or Bucharest the question is whether their students can afford to come at all.

The fair criticism runs the other way. The EU’s own mandate excludes loans, so a home fee paid up front helps the families who can already afford it – and the Migration Observatory finds EU students concentrated in London and the Russell Group. If capitals want the deal to reach the students whose numbers fell furthest, they need to ask about loans or bursaries, not just the fee line.

What the lock does

Both sides can claim to be right, which makes this awkward but not fatal. Nothing in the joint text makes SPS, ETS or YES conditional on fees, so Downing Street can say the deal is done and lay its bill.

But under Article 218 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, the EU can’t sign an international agreement without a Council decision authorising it. The member states have now put on record that no such decision will come until the fee talks conclude.

UK legislation can go ahead, but the UK can’t make the EU sign, and that leverage sits inside the EU’s own procedures – which is why it never had to appear in anything the UK agreed to. A fee deal by May means signature “in parallel” and everyone claims they were right. No deal, and the gap between “the deal is done” and “will not precede” becomes the story, with SPS due to apply from March 2028.

The one thing the UK clearly lost in the drafting was scope. Its bracketed option was for undergraduates, and the joint statement now covers “all students”. That brings in postgraduate taught and research fees, where there is no cap and, as David Kernohan points out in his look at current EU recruitment, not even a published list of home fees to measure a discount against.

“Irrespective of the immigration pathway” matters for a related reason. DK has also argued that YES could replace the student visa for many EU degree applicants, given its work rights and cheaper health surcharge. Tie fees only to YES, or only to student visas, and applicants would switch routes to get the better deal – covering every route closes that off.

The surcharge isn’t settled on paper either. The YES explainer says EU participants pay 75 per cent of the full charge, while the government’s economic methodology note assumes £776 a year, the same as existing youth mobility schemes. They can’t both be right. An EU student on an ordinary student visa still pays the visa fee and full surcharge, and the EU’s negotiating mandate rules out access to loans.

Switch, dial and levy

What is really being negotiated is the choice we set out in our earlier piece between a switch – putting EU nationals back into the home-status categories of the Fees and Awards regulations – and a dial, a new ceiling set somewhere above the home rate. “Equal treatment with nationals” is a switch. “Significantly reduced” international fees is a dial.

That choice has a fiscal side nobody seems to have spotted. The international student levy applies, on DfE’s own definition, to students who don’t qualify for home fee status. Flip the switch and EU students drop out of the £925 levy. Turn the dial and they stay international, discounted but still levied – so the UK’s preferred model protects the income earmarked for maintenance grants, and the EU’s costs the Treasury twice.

Scotland also needs more attention than it is getting. Before Brexit, EU undergraduates there paid nothing because Scots pay nothing, and most coverage assumes the same again. But under the Scottish fees regulations, status turns on residence rather than nationality, and UK nationals from elsewhere in the UK pay.

Whether “equal treatment with nationals” compares an EU student with a Scot or a Mancunian is a drafting question with a funded-places answer, and Holyrood should want a say before May.

Who loses

The loudest voice on cost has been the Russell Group, whose briefing has produced a figure anywhere between £540m and £580m depending on who is quoting it. DK reckons it is probably too pessimistic, because it applies the premium for all international students rather than EU ones, ignores domicile and subject differences and assumes no government support.

It also describes where the money is now, not what the sector would lose. The Russell Group enrols most EU students, and the government’s own London Economics modelling of the 2021 change found only Oxford and Cambridge stood to gain from charging EU students international fees, with every other cluster losing. Run that in reverse and the losses fall on the top of the market.

The claim that universities lose money on every home student needs checking too. The KPMG figure of £12,317 is a full average cost, built on subject-level costing that hasn’t been collected since 2019–20. An average isn’t the cost of one more student – much of a university’s spending is fixed or shared, and extra volume helps, as students were told repeatedly during the pandemic.

That loss-per-student story is hard to square with Russell Group members taking a record share of last cycle’s acceptances, reaching further down the grades than ever while lower-tariff intakes fell. When Manchester’s vice chancellor told the BBC it was “not clear we’d be able to increase the number of places” for EU students, he was describing a capacity problem his own group created.

The headline EU figures are also skewed by Ireland, whose students already get home fees and loans under the Common Travel Area – which makes Ulster and Queen’s the UK’s biggest EU recruiters, and the CTA the obvious model for a deal that reaches poorer applicants.

Six months to watch

Whether the UK concedes the switch or holds out for the dial, and whether the Commission’s earlier openness to a cost-based fee survives the member states, will decide the shape of the deal.

The next few months will also show whether any compensation follows the income actually lost or the loudest briefing, and whether anyone in Edinburgh spots the comparator question before the text is settled.

Both sides got what they wanted from the joint statement because it says almost nothing – and then one of them wrote down what it really meant on a separate sheet of paper.



Source link