Debate

Did US join Russia in abstaining from vote on UN resolution to protect women and girls?

Did US join Russia in abstaining from vote on UN resolution to protect women and girls?


Claim:

The U.S. joined Russia in abstaining from voting to pass a United Nations resolution to protect women and girls.

Rating:

Context

The vote was to move the draft resolution out of the Third Committee of the U.N. on Social, Humanitarian and Cultural Issues. It passed, with 175 countries voting in favor of it. Six countries abstained: the U.S., saying the mentions of “sexual and reproductive health” and “safe abortion” were “disappointing”; Russia; Argentina; Belarus; Burkina Faso and Cameroon. One country, Somalia, voted against it. The draft resolution will now go to the U.N.’s General Assembly Plenary for adoption.

In November 2026, a rumor spread that the U.S. had joined Russia in not voting for a United Nations resolution meant to protect women and girls against violence.

The claim made the rounds on social media, including on Facebook and Reddit. On X, a post shared the supposed image of the voting board showing that the U.S. and Russia were among six countries abstaining and that Somalia was the sole country to vote against it (archived):

Meanwhile, several Snopes readers searched the website seeking information on the rumor. 

The claim was true. On Nov. 17, the U.S., Russia, Argentina, Belarus, Burkina Faso and Cameroon all abstained from voting to push a draft resolution that sought to protect women and girls against all types of gender-based violence out of the Third Committee of the U.N. on Social, Humanitarian and Cultural Issues. This was according to a summary of the session published on the U.S. website. Somalia was the sole country to vote against the resolution. 

It is worth noting that this text was not final as of this writing. Instead, the Third Committee passed the draft resolution to the General Assembly Plenary for adoption.

Why the U.S. and Russia abstained

The specific draft resolution, on the “Intensification of efforts to prevent and eliminate all forms of violence against women and girls: gender-related killings of women and girls” (also referred to as “L.16” in the 81st session of the Third Committee, or C. 3), was the topic of debate during the committee meeting that led to the vote. 

In its explanation, the U.S. cited the mentions of “sexual and reproductive health” and “safe abortion” as the reason for abstaining to vote, calling them “disappointing”:

It is disappointing to see the controversial terminology of “sexual and reproductive health” and the notion of “safe abortion” in operative paragraph 4 of this resolution.  The United States believes in legal protections for the unborn.  There is no international “right to abortion,” whether under that name or under other terms like “sexual and reproductive health.”  Nor is there any duty on the part of States to finance or facilitate abortion.

It is true that the revised draft resolution mentions sexual and reproductive health in the context of educating girls about it and in the context of enhancing access it to it for women and girls (pages 7 and 8 of the PDF). The text also seeks to guarantee access to “safe abortion where such services are permitted by national law” (Page 8 of the PDF). The two sections that include these mentions are in the fourth paragraph of the draft resolution.

During the debate, the representative for the U.S. said about a separate resolution that her country supports “the overall goal of the text,” but that “the meaning of sexual and reproductive health must be determined by reference to national laws.” 

“The United States reaffirms its position that gender can only be defined by biological sex as male and female,” she added.

In addition, the committee session summary said, the representative for the Russian Federation introduced a series of amendments to L.16 to “promote women and girls’ role in the family and delete language that would reduce protections for them, including ‘gender-based violence’ and ‘intimate partner violence.'”

The summary of the session also gave more details about what the resolution would do:

By the text, the Assembly would strongly condemn all forms of violence against women and girls, online and offline, particularly gender-related killings, including femicide, and urge States to take measures to eliminate such violence against women in all their diversity.

For further reading, Snopes confirmed the U.S. was the only nation to vote against the U.N. Commission on the Status of Women’s agreed conclusions during the commission’s 70th session in March 2026.



Source link

Filed under: Debate

Selected by

Avatar photo

I’m a freelance blogger, writing about health care, art and politics.