Situated on the neighborhood’s extreme western and southern boundaries (Lafayette Street and Broome Street), Toby’s Estate is a solid place for grabbing a coffee to-go before strolling Little Italy’s streets. Originally founded in Sydney, Australia by Toby Smith in 1997, the brand quickly expanded internationally and continues to rank amongst top global coffee shops, thanks to its single-origin pours and original house blends. The spot equally excels at espresso-based drinks, including lattés, cappuccinos, and unsurprisingly, flat whites. While the pastries at Toby’s are certainly good, we’d recommend saving your stomach space for Italian cookies and cannoli and nearby pasticcerie, including Caffé Palermo and Ferrara Bakery—more on those below.
Address: 409 Broome St, New York, NY 10013
Technically located on the cusp of Little Italy’s historic boundaries (Kenmare and Broome Streets), La Esquina offers a flavor-packed reprieve from the classic red-sauce joints synonymous with the neighborhood. Situated in a former counter deli, this multi-level Mexican hotspot is best known for its casual taqueria (located in ‘The Corner Deli’ space) serving tacos, tortas, and ceviche. However, for those looking for something a bit stronger, head through the secret door and down the stairs to find the restaurant’s underground speakeasy. Lit by candle and adorned with Lucha Libre posters, the bar’s high-energy ambiance is prime for enjoying queso fundido and smoky Mexican street corn (elotes callejeros) washed down with expertly crafted agave-based cocktails.
Address: 114 Kenmare St, New York, NY 10012
