Philosophy

Did men evolve to fight each other? Scientists can’t agree.

Did men evolve to fight each other? Scientists can’t agree.


Anthropologist David Puts was a graduate student trying to decide on a dissertation topic when inspiration struck him at a mall food court. While eating a cheeseburger, he overheard two men behind him speaking in unusually deep voices. “I turned around to see what was happening, and there was a young, good-looking female nearby,” Puts said. 

His initial thought was that human males evolved deep voices to attract women, but he soon began to wonder whether they might also help establish dominance over other men: “A deep voice is intimidating — think about Darth Vader.” So, for his dissertation, Puts tested both possibilities. What he found surprised him.

Women tended to prefer a deeper, more masculine voice, but the effect of voice pitch on their ratings of male attractiveness wasn’t very big. Meanwhile, the effect of voice pitch on men’s judgment of another man’s dominance and fighting ability was 15 times bigger. 

The unexpected result led Puts to revisit earlier studies. He noticed that “the literature was really biased towards female mate choice” as a reason for deep voices, while findings related to male-male competition seemed to get “pushed under the rug.” This realization became the foundation for Puts’ theory that competition between males for mates, also known as “male-male contest competition,” may have played a larger role in the evolution of the human male than scientists had previously recognized. 

Puts, now a professor of anthropology and psychology at Pennsylvania State University, has continued to think about and develop this theory ever since the seed for it was planted in his brain in that mall food court in the early 2000s. Although he said he is mostly driven by a fascination with human nature, there’s more to his theory than pure academic interest. He believes that evolutionary understanding might help explain aspects of male psychology and inform positive social change.

Competition between males for mates may have played a larger role in the evolution of the human male than scientists had previously recognized. 

In November 2026, Puts and graduate student Saeed Koohgard published a review titled “The deadliest primate: Contest competition and the evolution of human males” in the Journal of Human Evolution. The review links modern-day male characteristics, including physical aggression, to male-male contest competition among our ancestors — a controversial theory. 

“This [idea] is supported primarily by evolutionary psychologists,” said Agustín Fuentes, an anthropologist at Princeton University. “Most anthropologists do not support this at all.” He said that those interested in understanding male violence should read the paper “but recognize this is a very teeny slice and a very biased view” in the midst of the wider anthropological, psychological, and sociological literature.

The ancestral mating system

For at least the past 150,000 years, the effective number of reproducing women at any given time has been roughly three times that of men, according to a 2015 study looking at Y-chromosome and mitochondrial DNA. This may reflect male invaders displacing local men, but Puts and Koohgard think it points to a polygynous mating system, where some men fathered children with several partners, while many other men had no children at all. They believe that our ancestors lived in single-male family units embedded within larger bands, as hamadryas and gelada baboons do.

This setup meant that “our male ancestors intensely fought, threatened, and killed each other to monopolize mates,” Puts said. 

In their review, Puts and Koohgard cite several findings that are consistent with their theory. For example, in a study of Eurasian Neanderthal and early modern human remains from 80,000 to 20,000 years ago, men were about six times more likely than women to show signs of head injuries. Furthermore, a study of homicide data spanning two decades and four locations (Canada, England/Wales, Chicago, and Detroit) found that unrelated men kill each other 27 times more often than unrelated women kill each other.

“A lot of male mating success may have had to do with just the plausible threat of aggression.”

David Puts

Puts and Koohgard also point to several features of the male anatomy as complementary evidence of male-male contest competition. Men are larger than women on average, with 61% more muscle mass overall and 75% more upper-body muscle mass. Size and muscularity are traits that help win fights. Men also have what biologists call “badges of status,” such as facial hair and deep voices. These traits signal dominance and help to win resources, such as mates, without engaging in costly fights.

Puts and Koohgard argue that, together, these lines of evidence suggest that male-male contest competition has played an important role in shaping men’s behaviors, including physical aggression. People might hear this theory and misread it as a justification of male violence, Puts said, but he stresses that understanding evolutionary influences is not the same as condoning violence — the idea that something being natural or evolved makes it justified is what’s known as the “naturalistic fallacy.” 

Although Puts and Koohgard’s theory centers on the idea that aggression helped our male ancestors to win mates, Puts doubts that the most violent males were ever the most successful. “There are huge costs to violence,” he said, “and if you’re living in a group and you’re a belligerent loose cannon, you’re likely to be killed or at least ostracized.” Instead, Puts thinks that “a lot of male mating success may have had to do with just the plausible threat of aggression.”

Clashing views

Fuentes is not convinced by Puts and Koohgard’s theory. The claim of a polygynous ancestral mating system is “highly disputed,” he said, and the “vast majority of geneticists who work in this area” conclude that our ancestors were most likely monogamous, with some mild polygyny. 

He accused Puts and Koohgard of selectively citing works that support their theory while leaving out research that complicates or challenges it — their paper doesn’t mention Nam Kim and Marc Kissel’s book Emergent Warfare in Our Evolutionary Past, for example. That book frames violence as complex and dependent on multiple conditions — not simply an evolved male strategy. Citing it would make it “more complicated to make the argument that [they’re] making,” Fuentes said. 

However, Raymond Hames, an emeritus professor of anthropology at the University of Nebraska–Lincoln, praised Puts and Koohgard’s review as “very comprehensive.” He said the paper’s strength is that it tests several alternative hypotheses that might explain male traits, such as sexual division of labor, and finds them a poor fit. His only objection is to the paper’s title: “The deadliest primate.” “Although we are violent, we are not the deadliest of all primates,” Hames said. Red-tailed monkeys, blue monkeys, and red-fronted lemurs are all far more likely than humans to kill their own kind, according to a 2016 study. 

“Humans didn’t evolve to punch each other — our hands are horrible at it. Our bodies actually aren’t that great for violence, but our minds are.”

Agustín Fuentes

With regard to Fuentes’ point, Hames thinks that warfare, or coalitionary violence, and one-on-one male violence aren’t interchangeable. One involves political competition over scarce resources, he said, while “the other one has to do with males striving for reproduction.”

In their review, Puts and Koohgard call out an erroneous figure on height differences by sex from Fuentes’ book Sex Is a Spectrum: The Biological Limits of the Binary. Fuentes concedes the error, which has since been fixed in the paperback edition, but said that Puts and Koohgard “ignore all the other data in my book that rejects their assertion.” He argues that men and women are not two fundamentally separate kinds of human, pointing to the fact that most bodily features — including organs such as the brain, heart, and kidneys — are not distinctly male or female.

Fuentes agrees with the point that Puts and Koohgard make about humans having evolved a capacity for incredible violence, but he believes “there is no genetic propensity for violence in males relative to females.” And while some researchers, most notably the evolutionary biologist David Carrier, argue that human hands evolved for punching, Fuentes believes that the human capacity for violence isn’t rooted in the body. “Humans didn’t evolve to punch each other — our hands are horrible at it,” he said. “Our bodies actually aren’t that great for violence, but our minds are.”

The questions worth asking

Hames agrees with Puts’ view that studying the roots of male violence can help reduce it. He said that understanding what motivates violence could help identify ways to “change the environment to reduce that motivation” and, hopefully, lower violence.

But Fuentes thinks they are asking the wrong question. In modern society, “most of the individuals who kill or rape are men, but the vast majority of men neither kill nor rape,” he said. Instead of asking “What’s the root of male violence?” he thinks researchers should ask, “Why do certain males do that and not others? In what context or situations do males act violently?”

Holly Dunsworth, a biological anthropologist at the University of Rhode Island, sees Puts and Koohgard’s paper as part of a wider trend of debating unknowable evolutionary causes. She questions the value of that work, while stopping short of saying it has none. 

Dunsworth said evolution is true but argued that the specific evolutionary causes of ancestral behaviors and traits can’t be known. “We have no systematic way of testing [Puts and Koohgard’s] idea against alternatives and for choosing the one that is closest to the truth,” she said. After years of study, Dunsworth is “very confident about what we don’t know and what we can’t know” — she has laid out her view in a book due out in June.

Instead of asking “What’s the root of male violence?” Fuentes thinks researchers should ask, “Why do certain males do that and not others? In what context or situations do males act violently?”

While anthropologists including Hames believe in uniformitarianism — a principle centered on the idea that the present is the key to the past — Dunsworth argues that knowing how evolution works does not mean we can identify the specific causes of evolutionary changes in the past. In her view, debating the details of Puts and Koohgard’s theory risks distracting from that fundamental uncertainty. She declined to offer alternative explanations, saying that would mean entering a debate “that will always be a debate.” 

“It’s always about who will win, whose argument is most preferred by most people, and sounds the most like common sense,” Dunsworth said. “That’s not what I’m interested in participating in.” 

Puts, on the other hand, is eager to debate. He thinks that male-male contest competition, underemphasized in the literature, may have been at least as important as — and perhaps more important than — female mate choice in human male evolution. However, he acknowledges that he may be wrong and sees scientific discussion as a way to improve understanding: “If I’m misunderstanding things, or there’s important evidence that I haven’t considered or my interpretation doesn’t make sense, I really want to know that.”

This article Did men evolve to fight each other? Scientists can’t agree. is featured on Big Think.



Source link

Filed under: Philosophy

Selected by

Avatar photo

Im a doctor in training and I believe in a secular world