Philosophy

Do you have a selkie or a seal in the family?

Do you have a selkie or a seal in the family?


In October 1948, in Country Kerry, Ireland, Seán Ó Muircheartaigh met with Seosamh Ó Dálaigh to tell him about the woman who came from the sea. She had appeared, said Ó Muircheartaigh, one night on the magharees, those bright spits of sand that occasionally pop up amid the rain-lashed rocks of the Dingle peninsula. Alone on the beach, she settled herself on a rock and began combing her hair.

Also on the beach was a farmer, who – much to the surprise of the woman herself – would by daybreak become her husband. He’d come to gather seaweed, seeing her before she saw him. Beautiful as she was, the woman was also strange: the creature he saw stagger onto that Dingle beach was not a woman at all. It was a seal.

By the time Ó Muircheartaigh told Ó Dálaigh about the seal woman, he was already 80. He had been born in the apocalyptic aftermath of the Great Hunger that divested as much as a third of Ireland’s population to death or migration, and he had survived two great wars. Most of the disappeared were – like Ó Muircheartaigh himself – small farmers and native Irish, or Gaeilge, speakers. The famine had been not just a physical genocide: it had been a linguistic and cultural one, too.

Both Ó Muircheartaigh and Ó Dálaigh were veteran contributors to the Irish Folklore Commission: the former as a renowned storyteller; the latter, an equally renowned collector. The IFC is now the National Folklore Collection at University College Dublin ­– a behemoth of 3 million pages of texts and recordings. But in 1948, following eight centuries of colonialism, the loss of 99 per cent of the island’s forests, a staggering emigration, and the decline of the Irish language, the IFC was in a race against time and the fragility of memory. As it turned out, an awful lot of people had heard stories about seals that came to land as humans.

Nowadays, these shapeshifters are known as ‘selkies’. Selkie is a Scots term that came into widespread use via a Joan Baez cover, ‘Silkie’ (1961), of a traditional Scottish folk song. Yet the phenomenon it describes – of creatures who shapeshift between human and seal forms by shedding a skin – appears consistently in folklore spanning the Celtic world and beyond, even as far as Sweden. Before Baez insinuated the term into international parlance, selkies were identified in Irish and English by a constellation of descriptors. In Irish, the most common is mhaighdean mhara, or ‘sea maiden’, referring to selkies and mermaids. Even in English, many storytellers use ‘mermaid’ for both the phocine and the piscine. Sometimes the two are differentiated with context (fish tails, seal skins), but what matters more than phenotyping is that the mermaid or selkie is neither quite human nor animal. What defines the selkie is transformation.

Much of the folklore retains the quality of the best gossip, hyper-local and yet vague. Storytellers name names, offer precise locations for key scenes in the story. And several admit something startling: that they themselves are the descendants of human-seal pairings.

After the farmer spotted the woman on the beach, Ó Muircheartaigh said, he saw something else. A sealskin cloak lay beside her: her ticket to transformation and a return to the sea. Then he made a choice that would ricochet throughout the generations, and leave the selkie with no option but to follow him home. He stole the selkie’s cloak and secreted it away, thus securing her for a bride. These rough beginnings aside, the couple produced a brood of children and went about the gruelling lives of any impoverished Irish fishing family. The only thing disrupting the fantasy of a normal human wife, acquired in normal human ways, was the webbing between the children’s toes. That, and the fact that the woman never smiled, but kept looking out towards the sea.

What does it mean if your grandmother was a seal? The folklore attests that marriages between humans and selkies were common enough to generate a host of human-selkie lineages – Conneely, Gallagher, Dowd, O’Kane, O’Shea, MacDuffie, McPhee, Flaherty, Glavin – whose members were predisposed towards webbed digits and an ineffable longing for the sea. (‘My mother was one of them O’Sheas,’ the railway worker Séamas MacMathghamhna confided to a folklore collector in 1949, after explaining the selkie lineage of the O’Sheas.) The Celtic studies scholar Gregory Darwin has identified nearly 50 family groups whose members carry selkie blood.

Now is a good time to have a seal in the family tree. As our planet hurtles through climate catastrophe, everyone from environmental activists and TikTok influencers to academics and New Age pilgrims is turning towards animals-as-family rhetoric. Such gusto stems from a cultural exhaustion with extractionism and with narratives of domination and human exceptionalism that have dogged the culture and geopolitics of the Global North since the 19th century. Yet the naivety with which the zeitgeist tends to approach an expanded view of interspecies kinship presents its own problems. For one, it doesn’t quite ring true – and it is hard to fight for a worldview that you can’t see clearly. For another, if we reframe our relationship with the more-than-human around intimate familial connection, then we need ways of understanding what happens when that connection becomes fraught.

The selkie story is one of family dysfunction par excellence. After all, the gutting truth at the centre of selkie families is that one’s origins lie in theft, violence, rape and unimaginable loss. The children of human-selkie pairings face a mottled inheritance, at best. Writing for The New York Times in 2008, Bryan Patrick Miller recounted how his great-great-great-grandfather’s kidnapping of a mhaighdean mhara cursed the family, causing the couple’s half-human children to flee across the Atlantic. Some coastal communities saw seals as fallen angels or the souls of drowned fishermen: mating with them was dubious to say the least.

Mottled or not, a selkie genealogy had to be reckoned with. Having a selkie in the family forced an acknowledgement of a mixed inheritance that was dark and disturbing, and in which successive generations continued to be implicated. Only by considering these uncomfortable reverberations of what it means to be family do we move closer to reimagining our relationships with the more-than-human world.

A woman who is sexually unsatisfied in her marriage may cry into the sea and receive a selkie who is an absolute dynamo in bed

Among folklorists, the trope of the selkie is generally known as the Seal Wife – a designation that speaks more to the gendered hold that the selkie story has on our imagination than to the actual folklore topos. The selkie’s allure is such that men will risk curses and commit theft and kidnapping to possess her, regardless of the certain tragedy that forced marriage augurs. Yet the selkies of folklore are not necessarily wives, women or even seals (note the mermaids, above). Male selkies occasionally make cameos as the kidnapped selkie wife’s jilted husband, father of her aquatic children, keening for her release from outside the human husband’s house. At other times, they appear as her brother, or as characters in the quotidian interactions between humans and their environment: they are accidentally killed, kidnapped as pets, steal fish, issue prophesies, plead and bargain, proffer advice and opinions.

Male selkies also arrive as lovers. Sometimes their affair with a human woman is star-crossed – the paramours may meet only once every seven years, say – but generally sex with a male selkie is an occasion for straightforward joy. A woman who is sexually unsatisfied in her marriage or a maiden hoping for a youthful adventure may cry into the sea and receive a selkie who is, apparently, an absolute dynamo in bed.

What is fascinating about these stories is that they centre female pleasure in a way that the selkie wife stories never do (or male pleasure, for that matter). Instead, the selkie wife – despite the sensual appeal that incited her husband to theft – is noted for her competence in housekeeping and childrearing. But even the male selkie stories occasionally take dark turns. Sometimes, the human woman steals her lover’s skin to compel him into marriage; other times, the human woman is raped by the male selkie.

The hybrid relationships described in the folklore are multilayered and fraught, but they are also interwoven with the rhythms of rural Irish life. The Irish tendency to link themselves to the more-than-human world – including through creatures such as the merrow, or mermaid, the shapeshifting púca, and, of course, the aos sí, the supernatural, fairy analogue to humans – has been noted for hundreds of years. Even the Normans, frustrated with their new subjects’ disinterest in distinguishing themselves from animals, set about reforming the Irish Church and ‘civilising’ the population.

In their paper ‘Slipping Off the Sealskin’ (2015), the literary critic and research artist Clair Le Couteur points out that early selkie stories had far more gender parity than later ones: not only were male selkies better represented, but their female counterparts were more empowered. The change towards the comparably flat Seal Wife trope, they suggest, echoes mankind’s changing view of our ecological place. Male selkies have ‘been largely erased [and] replaced by a simplified Seal Wife story in which gender and species are cross-linked … the female, the animal (seals), and indeed the natural and supernatural realms are conflated into a simplified, exploitable identity formed in opposition to Man’s agency as protagonist.’

Yet if the Seal Wife stands for gendered and environmental exploitation, she does not submit without a fight. The would-be husbands who steal her skin are met with unhappiness, rebellion and sometimes violence. In one story, a mhaighdean mhara retrieves her skin by setting her kidnapper’s house on fire and following the smell of singed skin (in spite of the lore, as Le Couteur warns, that destroying a mhaighdean mhara’s skin may lead to her death).

One particularly difficult aspect of the selkie story is the repeated insistence that the marriage is a happy one. It’s a fair claim that this is patriarchal whitewashing: in one story, the teller describes the marriage as happy, only to admit two lines later that the woman laughed just three times during her spell on land – the last being at her departure. Yet the story raises a thorny truth: sometimes love is problematic. You can love someone who hurts you, and you can still leave.

The notion that humans and animals are kin falls into the broad bucket of relational ontologies known as animism, although the word occupies an uncertain place in Celtic studies. Edward Tylor, a British anthropologist and a towering figure in the nascent field, coined the term in his book Primitive Culture (1871). Here, he divided the world population into stages of evolution: ‘animism’ was reserved for savages so undeveloped they could grasp only the crudest expression of religion. It took more than a century for pioneering scholars like Nurit Bird-David to reclaim and refresh the term as ‘new animism’ and argue that animism did not describe a ‘failed epistemology’, but a relational one.

Initially, the Victorians were thrilled to equate so-called ‘backwards’ rural Europeans with those cultures abroad that they deemed uncivilised. Yet, as Natalia Schwien Scott, a herbalist, wildlife rehabilitation apprentice, and PhD candidate in religion at Harvard University told me, once colonialism became racialised, the language quickly changed: now animism as genealogical kinship between humans and animals was delegated to Black and brown cultures as a means of othering them. The Irish themselves, sick of British dehumanisation, wanted nothing to do with the term. Such leeriness is understandable – and, if history is anything to go by, completely warranted.

Beyond racial politics, the lived experience of animism – for all its zeitgeisty, Kumbaya reputation – is a complicated one. ‘Animism is easy to like when you’re not an animist,’ Guido Sprenger, an anthropologist at Heidelberg University in Germany, told me. In 2021, Sprenger published a paper cheekily titled ‘Can Animism Save the World?’ He’d written it after watching animism slip ‘from being an exciting analytical concept to a catch-all term for moral relations with the environment, without much regard for those who actually practise it and find themselves in all sorts of moral conundrums and dangers.’ He added: ‘Animism isn’t that pretty, peaceful, smoochy, nonhuman affair.’

If the bounds of human exceptionalism are dissolved, and every animal is a family member, then how do you eat?

Like many other anthropologists, Sprenger was initially put off by the term’s colonial origins and nebulous usage; yet, when animism started to gain traction in environmental anthropology, he reconsidered his stance. Now, he worries that the original sin of animism is returning to dilute the term, once again, past the point of usability, out of a desperation to find alternatives to late-stage capitalism and human exceptionalism. ‘Everything that’s not us, with our nature-culture divide, is somehow animist and therefore better,’ he says. ‘And this is a step back into that diffuse and theoretically thin use of animism.’ He worries that this sudden enthusiasm for animism means sidestepping some of its trickier realities.

The animists with whom Sprenger spends his time are the Rmeet people of the Laotian highlands. Some eco-philosophers argue for a closer connection with the nature spirits to address our ecological crisis but, for the Rmeet, ‘this would be the idea of a madman.’ Spirits are a fact of life for the Rmeet, but not a kind one. As Sprenger told me, from the Rmeets’ point of view: ‘Who wants to deal with spirits? Who wants to get close to them? The whole point is that you want to be on good terms with them because you want them not to interfere in your life. They are just entities that are there. They are not a normative category. They are just as normative as a tree – a tree can fall on your head, or it can give you shade. The spirits are just there.’

His words suggest that intimacy and safety are not the same. For example, one issue that besets animist cosmologies is cannibalism. If the bounds of human exceptionalism are dissolved, and every animal is a family member, then how do you eat? Some cultures resolve this dilemma by distinguishing between animals (leave the seal, take the salmon); others by using ritual acts – cooking, say – to metamorphose animals from person to meat. Still others fly straight into the conundrum. An animal family member might allow itself to be caught by hunters, an act of self-sacrifice that allows its kin to survive.

Love and violence are perpetually entangled in animist cosmologies, which makes me wonder: why does it matter to be descended from a seal? Why hold onto a family story so fundamentally sad and troubling? In ‘Violence, Mourning, Politics’ (2003), Judith Butler argues that it is our relations with others that put us at risk of violence – and yet to forfeit being in relation is to forfeit being human. ‘Loss and vulnerability,’ they write, ‘seem to follow from our being socially constituted bodies, attached to others, at risk of losing those attachments, exposed to others, at risk of violence by virtue of that exposure.’ In short, our attachments put us in jeopardy, while shedding them risks losing something fundamental to our place in the order of things.

Animism – or at least claiming a worldview in which we see ourselves as integrated into the more-than-human world rather than lording over it – does not offer safety. If anything, it does the opposite. To be in relationship with the more-than-human world, to take seriously our connections beyond the strictly human, is to become more exposed and also more attached. It puts us, as the selkie stories confirm, directly in the path of more violence. We kill a whale and kill our grandmother. We risk having our house set alight and our heart broken by an angry seal. But we do it because it is what makes us human – and if we lose that, we lose everything.

Whether we can learn from the fraught relationships of selkie kinship rests on an obvious question: did anyone believe they were part-seal? It’s difficult to say what rural seaside communities in Ireland thought about their world up until the 20th century, particularly when they had already undergone centuries of cultural and linguistic erasure. Yet, as Schwien Scott notes: ‘The material very clearly says: “Her mother was a selkie,” or “Her grandmother was a selkie.” Why would we assume that wasn’t actually believed?’

One Galwegian domestic worker, Máire Ní Shúilleabháin, told her daughter in 1938 that she knew islanders who were children of mhaighdean mhara. The mhaighdean mhara were a common-enough reality that her great-uncle had seen one; the year before, a sighting in Connemara led to a £4,000 bounty for the marine woman’s capture (she escaped). One school-age collector in Cork, Nora O’Sullivan, wrote in her notebook that her father told her a story of a man who married a mermaid whose daughter then married into the Sullivans – that is, her family. Her teacher wrote a small memo affirming the story. In 1882, one Ms Dolan claimed that she personally knew the three children of a Lough Owel man named Mahon and his lake-creature bride. ‘She was a very good housewife, as all those lake people are,’ Dolan noted approvingly. ‘She kept his house beautifully.’ In 1937, Micheál Mac Conagail recounted that he knew of a mhaighdean mhara whose son became a priest. Such testimonies abound.

What is more, many fishing communities had taboos on killing seals based on blood relations between humans and seals. The economic implications of this were significant. Not only were these fishermen unable to harvest seals, they also had to swallow the seals’ presence as fishing competition – a huge blow amid grinding rural poverty in Ireland. Given all this, it’s reasonable to adduce a widespread literal belief in selkies that has lasted through living memory. And this belief had real-world implications – none of which were easy.

Seán Ó Muircheartaigh recounted in his story that, when the oat harvest came, the farmer set about clearing out the loft of the house he lived in with his seal wife and their half-selkie children. In a moment of carelessness, he threw down his wife’s sealskin cloak. She grabbed it immediately and secreted it out of sight.

That night, she waited for her husband to step out for the evening, then she washed her children and brushed their hair, just as she had brushed her own the night she was kidnapped. And then she took her cloak and was gone.

One of the most devastating aspects of an already devastating story is that it is about a woman who abandons her children. Every so often, the selkie departs with a blessing, or a curse, but mostly she goes quickly and in silence. She almost never takes her children: and in the case of the O’Dowds, she turns her progeny into stone. She rarely says goodbye. In a small subset of selkie stories, the shapeshifting mother continues to visit her terrestrial family even after she has returned to the sea, in one, returning to comb her children’s hair. But most often she just disappears.

For the selkie herself, the loss is doubled. While her human husband appears incurious about his bride’s former life, storytellers offer occasional glimpses. Eibhlín Ní Chonchubhair tells of a selkie who pauses before her marine return to bid farewell to her human husband. Bewildered, he asks what the children will do without her. Her reply is acid: ‘I have children who are dearer to me than these.’ In this story, as in others, she is met in the water by her selkie husband, who embraces her with cries of joy. Behind the selkie’s flight back to sea is a terrible calculus, where a return to one family means the loss of the other. The situation is complicated by kidnapping and abuse, with children who are innocents and also byproducts of forced marriage.

The selkie story is a roadmap for navigating relationships that cannot be repaired

Family haunts us. In his paper ‘Of Mermaids and Marriages’ (1990), the folklorist Bo Almqvist notes that both he and the poet Seamus Heaney have considered the selkie story as a parallel for parental suicide – a choice that is often incomprehensible to those left behind: to wit, a woman brushes her children’s hair then walks into the sea and vanishes. The selkie story is in many ways a ghost story whose participants just happen to still be alive.

I’ve suggested, pace Judith Butler, that to be in relationship is to place ourselves at risk of loss. But the selkie story, in its peregrination through the undergrowth of complicated grief, takes things one step further: it explores what it is like to remain in relationship with a loved one who is gone and who has caused you immense pain. In some ways, the selkie story is a roadmap for navigating relationships that cannot be repaired, where there is no hope or desire for reconciliation. For one thing, selkie stories acknowledge that we don’t always get to choose who we’re in relationship with – and that, sometimes, the healthiest move within a relationship is to break it.

As we navigate the inevitable species loss attendant on the climate emergency, reckoning with those places on the globe where the greatest act of love may be to decide against human intrusion, the selkie story offers a model for processing meaningful relationships that are defined by absence. The losses and hauntings endure: many individuals and communities in Ireland continued to see themselves as entangled with seals even generations after an interspecies marriage. The selkie story acknowledges as real those relationships where one half of the duo has abruptly left the conversation, as well as the cruelty and love that led up to the loss. It affirms that you can love your children and leave them, or love your children and turn them into stone. These truths can rub shoulders with each other, clear their throats, look down uncomfortably at the floor. Love is messy and not always good.

The selkie narrative is powerful because it considers the aftermath of things going wrong and posits a world in which violence doesn’t mean an end to care. It deals in difficult truths. Yet it is also a story that allows people to look out to sea and see cousins and siblings, parents lost and family gained. It allows a human to look at a seal and feel kinship. To think: there she is. There goes my family.



Source link

Filed under: Philosophy

Selected by

Avatar photo

Im a doctor in training and I believe in a secular world