Philosophy

Ask Ethan: Do polonium radiohalos support a young Earth?

Ask Ethan: Do polonium radiohalos support a young Earth?


One of the most beautiful things about science is that if even one single piece of robust evidence comes along that contradicts even our most deeply held ideas about reality, it means that our current way of thinking about things must be revised. The observations of Mercury’s orbit in the late 1800s led to the overthrow of Newtonian gravity; the observation that energy was quantized into discrete entities led to the birth of quantum physics; the observation of ultra-faint, variable stars in Andromeda led to the discovery of extragalactic objects and, soon after, to the expanding Universe. Wherever a seemingly contradictory observation occurs, there’s a chance for advancing our best scientific picture of how the Universe works.

We have to take immense care to make sure we don’t fool ourselves, but that applies in both directions. We have to make sure we don’t fool ourselves when it comes to accepting the established picture, but we must also make sure we don’t fool ourselves by believing flawed evidence that claims to undermine it. How is one to know what’s going on when different people who claim to be experts make inconsistent, contradictory assertions? That’s what Bob Brown wants to know, writing in to ask:

“I received this article — Polonium Radiohalos: Strong Evidence Against Millions of Years — from a friend… I’m at a loss as to how anyone should explain to him how this scenario just isn’t possible. Any insights you can provide will be greatly appreciated.”

One of the hallmarks of the scientific enterprise is to be able to consider an idea, even an “out there” alternative idea, and subject it to rigorous scrutiny. If it holds up, it cannot be discarded, no matter how absurd it sounds. However, if it crumbles beneath the weight of evidence, it cannot be viable. Let’s take a good look at what’s going on with this new claim.

The Cretaceous-Paleogene boundary layer is very distinct in sedimentary rock, but it’s the thin layer of ash, and its elemental composition (especially its severe iridium enhancement), that teaches us about the extraterrestrial origin of the impactor that caused the mass extinction event, enabling us to conclude that it was a carbonaceous asteroid of likely either the CM or CR type. Earth has hundreds of meters worth of sedimentary rock covering its surface practically everywhere, with limestone making up about 10% of the sedimentary rock in total.
Credit: James van Gundy

The conventional view of planet Earth is that it is, indeed, approximately 4.5 billion years old. The Sun and the Solar System itself is slightly older, while the Earth-Moon system was formed by a collision between two large protoplanets: a proto-Earth and a Mars-sized body named Theia. While many lines of evidence support an old Earth, including:

  • various layers of sedimentary rock with older metamorphic rock beneath them,
  • a fossil record dating back more than 3 billion years,
  • and our knowledge of solar physics, indicating the lifetime of the Sun,

the strongest evidence comes from radiometric dating: the measurements of elements and isotopes that arise from the radioactive decay of precursor elements that were present initially on our world.

By their very nature, minerals contain a wide variety of elements and isotopes: some of which are stable and others of which aren’t stable, with the unstable ones instead undergoing radioactive decay. Those decays often proceed in a chain: continuing until a final, stable product is reached. If you can know the initial concentration of the (parent) decaying element, the half-life of every element in the decay chain, and can measure the concentration of the (daughter) end product, you can calculate the age of the rock. Those are a lot of “ifs,” of course, but we’ve done that for Earth and for many other bodies in the Solar System, obtaining ages for Earth rocks in the billions of years and for several meteorites of around 4.55-4.56 billion years.

That’s the conventional view.

Scatter plot comparing 206Pb/204Pb and 207Pb/204Pb ratios for meteorites (squares) and pelagic sediment (circles) in a study of polonium radiohalos.

This animated version shows the lead isotope isochron that Clair Patterson first used to determine the age of the Solar System and of Earth back in 1956. The animation further shows progressive growth over 4550 million years of the lead isotope ratios within meteorites; the relationship between the lead 207-204 vs. lead 206-204 is key.
Credit: Jmpalin/Wikimedia Commons

However, there’s a new assertion out by Jake Hebert, claiming that the conventional age of billions of years for the Earth is wrong, and that even millions of years is too long. Instead, he claims that radioisotope dating supports an age that’s just thousands of years old for the Earth: an age that’s consistent with the claims of biblical creationism. This specific claim is that one should look at rocks known as Phanerozoic granites, and at features — or inclusions — within them known as polonium radiohalos.

While Hebert notes that the conventional picture claims that these radiohaloes are typically under 541 million years old and that nuclear decay rates (like the laws of physics) are a constant over time, he instead puts forth the idea that the decay rates were accelerated a few thousand years ago, and that the radiohalos from decaying polonium survive as the evidence of that.

To understand what he’s claiming, let’s go through what he states, but let’s do it in a way that compares what he’s asserting against the conventional story told by geologists, geophysicists, and nuclear physicists to see where there’s agreement and when there’s something he’s suggesting that’s outside of the realm of what’s generally accepted.

New Zealand’s Split Apple Rock is composed of granite, and dates back to the Cretaceous period more than 65 million years ago. The cause of the split down the rock’s center was a naturally occurring joint, and was likely broken apart by a combination of rains and ocean waves. Granite is generally a product of magma or lava that has cooled, and often naturally contains fractures where minerals, veins, or inclusions frequently appear.

Credit: Rosino/flickr

First, Hebert talks about granites in general (and Phanerozoic granites in particular) as having formed like any igneous rock: when hot magma cools and solidifies. He notes that zirconium silicate crystals often form within these granites, and that sometimes there’s a chemical substitution of (radioactive) uranium for zircon in these crystals.

This part is generally true. Granite is a common igneous rock, and it’s generally formed when magma comes to Earth’s surface and erupts (becoming lava, but that’s not an important detail), flows over the land, and cools, becoming solid rock. During the time that the rock is in the liquid state — as magma or lava — any radioactive decays that occur will produce daughter particles that don’t remain; alpha particles (or helium nuclei) become gas and escape, while only the ultimately stable daughter particle persists. It’s for this reason that measuring things like the uranium-to-lead ratio (or the potassium-to-argon ratio, among other radioactive tracers) allows you to date how long it’s been since a rock has formed: since it solidified.

The part about this being a Phanerozoic granite just means that it comes from the geological Phanerozoic period: approximately dating from the beginning of the Cambrian period and extending to the present time. Therefore, by definition, it covers the time period of the past 539 million years or so, and Phanerozoic granites represent rocks formed during this time period. So far, this is in full agreement with what’s presently understood.

Flowchart of the uranium-238 decay series, showing isotopes transforming into lead-206; these processes are central to the study of polonium radiohalos in young earth research.

This diagram shows an illustration of the decay chain of a uranium-238 nucleus: resulting in the ultimate production of the stable element lead-206. In total, 6 beta decays and 8 alpha decays occur, but several of the alpha decays are at very similar energies such that, when examined under microscopy, only five separate “rings” can be seen within any uranium halo.
Credit: Tosaka/Wikimedia Commons

Hebert then goes on to describe how — once a solid rock containing uranium is formed — a decay chain process occurs. This is indeed true. Overall, uranium’s most common isotope starts with 146 neutrons (U-238), and:

  • after a half-life of 4.5 billion years, decays to thorium-234,
  • which very quickly (after 24 days) decays to protactinium-234,
  • which again very quickly (after 1.2 minutes) decays to uranium-234,
  • which then (after 245,000 years) decays to thorium-230,
  • which afterwards (after 75,000 years) decays to radium-226,
  • which in the next step (after 1600 years) decays to radon-222,
  • which swiftly (after 3.8 days) decays to polonium-218,
  • when very rapidly (after 3.1 minutes) either decays to astatine-218 (1.5 seconds) and then to bismuth-214, or to lead-214 (27 minutes) and then to bismuth-214,
  • which after another 20 minutes, decays either to polonium-214 (0.16 milliseconds) and then to lead-210, or first to thallium-210 (1.3 minutes) and then to lead-210,
  • and then, after 22 years, undergoes a decay either to bismuth-210 (5 days), polonium-210 (138 days), and then to lead-206, or a decay to mercury-206 (8.3 minutes), thallium-206 (4.2 minutes), and then to lead-206.

At last, lead-206 is stable, and so when that product is reached, no further decays come about. Note how long the initial lifetime of uranium-238 is (4.5 billion years) compared to all of the intermediate products that come after. That’s why nearly 100% of the initial uranium-238 that begins in a sample will either still be uranium-238 or will have converted into lead-206. There will be tiny, trace amounts of the other elements/isotopes present at any given moment, where a total of eight alpha particles (helium-4 nuclei) and six beta particles (electrons) are emitted during the full decay chain process.

Microscopic view of a thin section of rock showing different crystal structures and polonium radiohalos under plane-polarized and cross-polarized light.

This view of an Allanite mineral with a pleochroic halo consists of a thin, 30 micron section exhibiting defect-containing inclusions with dark halos around them: arising from alpha particles emitted from a radioactive decay chain occurring within the uranium (and uranium-descended) elements within them.
Credit: Petr Hykš/flickr

Hebert states that these eight alpha particles per parent uranium nucleus come in a spectrum of energies, and he’s right. He states that if you have enough uranium in one deposit, you’ll get a discolored halo from this radioactive material (a radiohalo) around it, where the higher-energy alpha particles produce longer-length tracks and the lower-energy particles produce shorter length tracks: again, correct. And then, the more uranium you start with and the more time that passes, the darker your radiohalo appears. All of this is in agreement with the consensus picture.

Now, here’s where we get into the meat of the assertion. I’ll break it up into three chunks, so we can analyze each one separately.

1.) Hebert notes that, in some locations, you don’t see a large discolored halo with eight rings, indicative of a uranium-238 parent nucleus, but rather a smaller, less-discolored halo: sometimes with just three, two, or even one ring: indicative of polonium-218, polonium-214, or polonium-210 alone.

2.) And then, since you need hundreds of millions of alpha particles to form a radiohalo, that conventionally means you must have had hundreds of millions of years pass in order to create these radiohalos. But since polonium isotopes live only for days (or less), there’s no way to produce a radiohalo without starting from uranium, and therefore the standard picture is wrong.

A diagram showing radial particle paths from a center point, with microscopic views of 238U and 210Po polonium radiohalos in biotite, illustrating the formation of these spherical features.

This diagram shows how a radioactive source (center) emits a spherical halo of alpha particles over time, and shows a series of pleochroic halos, or radiohalos, as viewed under microscopy. Some radiohalos are larger than others, with 5 rings for a typical uranium-based radiohalo, but with fewer rings (between 1 and 3) for polonium-based radiohalos, which are typically found embedded in or at the interface of a different mineral than the more common uranium radiohalos.
Credit: Andrew Snelling/Institute for Creation Research

3.) And, then, Hebert then argues that in order to produce what he calls an “orphan” polonium radiohalo, you need to have produced a very large number of polonium atoms all at once, and then swiftly transport them a short distance away to a single, isolated location that’s nearby the original uranium halos. Therefore, the standard picture is wrong, and an alternative pathway — and Hebert proposed one that involves rapid, accelerated decays in the past, hydrothermal fluid flow, and rapid transport, allegedly occurring during the Biblical flood — is required to explain what we see.

These are the three key statements that are at the core of what Hebert is asserting. But are they true?

The first assertion is close. It’s true that, in theory, since their are eight steps to a typical radioactive decay of U-238, you’d expect eight concentric rings to appear. However, the energies of several steps in the radioactive decay chain are very close together; you can only discern up to five concentric rings under a lighted petrographic microscope. But if you have a polonium-218 halo (or a radon-222 halo), you indeed do see only three rings: one from Po-218, one from Po-214, and one from (the indistinguishable overlap of) Rn-222 and Po-210. (The immediate daughter products of U-238, which are U-234, Th-230, and Ra-226, also overlap to make one indistinguishable ring.)

Microscopic view of mineral crystals showing intersecting cleavage planes and a central inclusion with a polonium radiohalo.

This image shows a magnified view of zircons enclosed in the mineral biotite: a common location where uranium pleochroic halos are found. Tiny crystals rich in radioactive material emit alpha particles, which causes discolorations in a halo-like configuration surrounding the inclusions themselves.
Credit: Strekeisen/Wikimedia Commons

For the second assertion, you do indeed need hundreds of millions of alpha particles to form a radiohalo in granite. If you start from U-238, you do indeed need hundreds of millions of years to pass for a radiohalo to form. And there’s plenty of uranium inside the Earth’s interior; it’s one of the heaviest elements abundantly produced in processes like supernovae that created the material that our pre-solar nebula formed from, and its radioactive decay generates a significant fraction of the Earth’s interior heat.

However, uranium constantly decays inside the Earth, including in magma chambers. When it does, several of its immediate downstream products — thorium, protactinium, and radium — can be solid or liquid, depending on temperature. However, the next step in the decay chain after radium is radon: a gas. When you create a gas within a liquid, even if that liquid is magma, it rises until it gets trapped against a solid-bodied chamber: a crack, vein, or crevice of solid rock, for instance. Radon diffuses as a neutral gas along or through fractures.

As was shown by Lorence and Barbara Collins many years ago, “daughter” atoms, including radon (which becomes polonium after its next decay) are continuously being produced within the Earth within magma chambers: a veritable “sea” of radon-producing (and hence, later on, polonium-producing) material.

A close-up of a rock sample featuring a prominent, pale crystalline vein running diagonally through a dark, speckled stone matrix, often studied for polonium radiohalos.

This image shows a fracture-rich section of coarse-grained igneous rock: syenite in this case. Fractures and other features are common in various forms of igneous rocks depending on the temperature that they cool and form at, and mineral-rich veins and inclusions can often be found where different types of igneous rocks form.
Credit: James St. John/c.c.-by-2.0

And finally, the third key assertion is that polonium radiohalos are found nearby the uranium ones, and that an alternative scenario to the standard picture must be invoked in order to explain such a localized density of rapidly-decaying polonium atoms. But there’s a problem: polonium halos are not found in the same kind of granite where uranium halos are found. Granite that contains polonium halos occurs in rocks that have formed at temperatures above 700 ºC: rocks that have already crystallized and become solid by the time temperatures cool to 450 ºC, whereas granite that crystallizes from molten rock (which contains the uranium radiohalos) won’t have the necessary fractures within it so that the radon and polonium can collect at a particular, localized site.

Only when the temperatures drop below about 150 ºC (300 ºF) do the alpha particles begin to leave trails in the (now-solid) rock, creating these radiohalos. Depending on how much time passes between when the radon gas collects in pockets and fractures and when enough cooling has occurred for the temperature to drop sufficiently for radiohalos to form is what determines whether:

  • three-layered radiohalos (common for quick-cooling environments, if it cools in less than a week or so),
  • two-layered radiohalos (very rare, if cooling takes about 1-2 weeks),
  • or a one-layered radiohalo (common for slow-cooling environments that take months-to-years to cool)

winds up forming. Instead of invoking an alternative scenario — one favored by creationists — to explain the presence of polonium radiohalos, you simply need to apply the actual geophysical conditions present in the Earth’s interior where these features ultimately originate. And again, this is in an environment that’s different, embedded in a different type of granite, from where the uranium radiohalos, with five observed layers, are typically found.

A finger points at a rough, crystalline rock surface containing mineral deposits often studied for polonium radiohalos.

This cross-section of pink granite showcases several dark, discolored inclusions: candidates for pleochroic halos, which are associated with the radioactive decay of either deposits of uranium-238 or the daughter decay particles arising from U-238 decays. Depending on where in the decay chain the radioactive atoms are concentrated and “frozen in,” a varying number of concentric rings can be found in this halos.
Credit: Radioactive_Rocks/Reddit

But there’s a more fundamental problem with this type of claim that’s very different from, “I’ve found something unusual that lead someone to challenge the scientific consensus on an issue.” The point of this was not to claim that someone had found evidence that supported a conclusion other than the one accepted by the scientific mainstream. The point was to go out and find a line of reasoning that could, whether scrupulously or disingenuously, be used to convince people that mainstream science had our origin story wrong, and that the conclusion reached by Young Earth Creationists was correct instead.

This is a hallmark tactic of pseudoscientists: to craft an argument that most legitimate scientists in the mainstream will be unfamiliar with, and that will require the general public to digest and process a large amount of information to understand it. Instead of a complex, nuanced story that involved synthesizing together a large suite of information to understand it properly, they tell a simple, disingenuous story that can be told quickly and simply, but that takes a mountain of evidence to debunk. From global warming deniers to those attempting to link vaccines and autism to the “alcohol is good for you, actually,” crowd to creationists and more, this technique of invoking Brandolini’s law — that he amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude bigger than that needed to produce it — is as true today as it’s ever been.

In this life, it’s important to be open and curious about ideas that are out of the mainstream, but if you care about getting things right, it’s even more important to be rigorous, honest, skeptical, and thoughtful. Without those traits, and without adhering to what the evidence actually states, we cannot have a constructive conversation.

Send in your Ask Ethan questions to startswithabang at gmail dot com!

This article Ask Ethan: Do polonium radiohalos support a young Earth? is featured on Big Think.



Source link

Filed under: Philosophy

Selected by

Avatar photo

Im a doctor in training and I believe in a secular world