Philosophy

NASA’s next flagship to answer the biggest question: “Are we alone?”

NASA’s next flagship to answer the biggest question: “Are we alone?”


There are a few questions that humanity has always pondered, yet scarcely could satisfactorily answer until the proper scientific advances came along. Questions like:

  • What is the Universe?
  • Where did it come from?
  • How did it get to be this way?
  • And what is its ultimate fate?

are questions that have been with us since time immemorial, yet remained unanswerable for nearly all of human history. Beginning in the 20th century and now into the 21st century, many of these questions are finally getting comprehensive answers thanks to incredible advances in physics and astronomy. However, perhaps the biggest question of all — the question of “Are we alone in the Universe?” — remains as perhaps the greatest existential unanswered question of all.

While the current generation of ground-based and space-based telescopes can take us far into the Universe, this is a question that’s currently the reach of any observatory that presently exists. To get there, we’ll need to acquire direct images of Earth-like exoplanets: planets with sizes and temperatures similar to Earth, but that orbit Sun-like stars, not the more common red dwarf stars like Proxima Centauri or TRAPPIST-1.

Those capabilities are precisely what NASA is aiming for with its next flagship mission: the Habitable Worlds Observatory. It’s an ambitious project, sure, but one that’s well worth it. After all, finding out we’re not alone in the Universe would quite possibly be the biggest revolution in all of science history.

This animation shows the four super-Jupiter planets directly imaged in orbit around the star HR 8799, whose light is blocked by a coronagraph. The four exoplanets shown here are among the easiest to directly image owing to their large size and brightness, as well as their huge separation from their parent star. Our ability to directly image exoplanets is constrained to giant exoplanets at great distances from bright stars, but improvements in coronagraph technology will dramatically change that story.
Credit: Jason Wang (Northwestern)/William Thompson (UVic)/Christian Marois (NRC Herzberg)/Quinn Konopacky (UCSD)

At the present time, there are three main ways we’re actively searching for alien life.

  1. We’re exploring worlds in our Solar System, including Mars, Venus, Titan, Europa, and Pluto, remotely and in situ, with fly-by missions, orbiters, landers, and even rovers, searching for evidence of past life or even, potentially simple life that persists at the present time.
  2. We’re examining exoplanets, searching for evidence that there’s life on them, from the surface to the atmosphere and beyond, based on observable signatures of color, seasonal change, and atmospheric contents.
  3. And by looking for any signals that would reveal the presence of intelligent aliens: through efforts such as SETI and Breakthrough Listen.

All three approaches have their advantages and disadvantages, and so it makes sense to invest in all three. As long as we don’t find anyone else, we’ll have no choice but to wonder whether we’re alone or not. However, once we have a successful example of life that originated outside of Earth, we’ll know for certain that we have company here in the cosmos.

Given the sheer number of chances that are out there, most scientists believe that it’s the second option that’s most likely to deliver our first success. If life requires conditions similar to those found on Earth, we might well be the only world in the Solar System where life ever developed, survived, thrived, became technologically advanced, and still exists at the present time. Unless there are other intelligent, actively broadcasting civilizations nearby right now, endeavors like SETI won’t be able deliver any positive results.

However, “life of any type” is a much lower bar than actively-transmitting intelligent, technologically advanced civilizations. If even a small fraction of worlds that exist with Earth-like properties have life of any type on them, exoplanet studies can deliver a success where the other two options won’t. And we’ve come a very long way in our studies of exoplanets: we have more than 6000 known, confirmed exoplanets within the Milky Way, where we know the mass, radius, and orbital period of nearly all of those confirmed worlds.

largest planet

Although more than 6,000 confirmed exoplanets are now known, with more than half of them uncovered by Kepler, there are no true analogues of the planets found in our Solar System. Jupiter-analogues, Earth-analogues, and Mercury-analogues all remain elusive with current technology. The overwhelming majority of planets found via the transit method are close to their parent star, are ~10% the radius (or, equivalently, ~1% the surface area) of their parent star or more, and are orbiting low-mass, small-sized stars.
Credit: NASA/Ames/Jessie Dotson and Wendy Stenzel; annotated by E. Siegel

Unfortunately, this isn’t enough to inform us about whether any of these worlds are inhabited. To make that determination, we need more than that. We’d need to be able to make the necessary measurements that could answer such questions as:

  • Does the exoplanet have an atmosphere?
  • Does it have clouds, precipitation, and weather cycles?
  • Do its continents green-and-brown with the seasons, like they do on Earth?
  • Does it have gases or gas combinations in its atmosphere that hint at biological activity, and do they show seasonal variations like Earth’s CO2 levels do?

On the cutting edge of performing these measurements, today, are the space-based JWST and ground-based 10-meter class telescopes, performing direct exoplanet imaging and transit spectroscopy.

But even those great observatories are not enough to reach the goal we’re truly after.

JWST and 10-meter ground-based telescopes cannot measure the properties of Earth-sized planets in Earth-like orbits around Sun-like stars. For direct imaging studies, we can take pictures of planets that are the size of Jupiter and that are more than about Saturn’s distance from the Sun: good for gas giant worlds, but not so great for looking for life on rocky planets. For transit spectroscopy, we can see the light that filters through the atmospheres of super-Earth-sized worlds around red dwarf stars, but Earth-sized planets around Sun-like stars are well beyond the reach of current technology.

transit spectroscopy PLATO

When starlight passes through a transiting exoplanet’s atmosphere, signatures are imprinted. Depending on the wavelength and intensity of both emission and absorption features, the presence or absence of various atomic and molecular species within an exoplanet’s atmosphere can be revealed through the technique of transit spectroscopy. JWST cannot get spectra for Earth-sized planets around Sun-like stars, but Habitable Worlds Observatory finally will.
Credit: ESA/David Sing/PLAnetary Transits and Oscillations of stars (PLATO) mission

We have, however, come far enough to know that if we can scale up our technology, acquiring that data for the exoplanets we truly desire is possible. What we need to do is build on our current technology and enhance it further if we hope to find and characterize an actually inhabited planet. Currently, we’re building the next generation of ground-based telescopes, ushering in the era of 30-meter class telescopes with the GMTO, the ELT, and potentially Exo-Life Finder as well, and looking forward to the exquisite performance of the coronagraph aboard NASA’s next astrophysics flagship mission: the Nancy Roman Telescope.

The Roman telescope will have the same capabilities as Hubble but with superior instrumentation, a field-of-view that’s 50-100 times as great as Hubble’s, and a coronagraph that allows us to image planets within the glare of their parent star’s light that are about 1000 times fainter than JWST can see. A critical test will arrive very soon, when Roman attempts to image a faint stellar companion that can sufficiently test its coronagraphic capabilities; if it succeeds, it means we’re on track to directly image Earth-like worlds around Sun-like stars with the planned Habitable Worlds Observatory.

Our technology does not remain stagnant, nor do our visions for discovery and exploration. Each decade, the National Academy of Sciences gets together to outline the highest priorities for astronomy and astrophysics, making recommendations as part of a decadal survey. Four flagship missions were proposed at the most recent (Astro2020) decadal:

  1. Lynx, a next-generation X-ray observatory, especially important given the reduced scope of the ESA’s upcoming Athena mission,
  2. Origins, a next-generation far-infrared observatory, filling a colossal gap in our wavelength coverage of the Universe,
  3. HabEx, a single-mirror telescope designed to directly image the very nearest Earth-like planets,
  4. and LUVOIR, an ambitious, giant segmented telescope that would be an astronomical all-purpose “dream” observatory.
LUVOIR concept space telescope

Ideally, the new space telescope Habitable Worlds Observatory, with capabilities between those of the previously-proposed HabEx and LUVOIR (shown here), will be large enough to image a large number of Earth-like exoplanets directly, while still having the desired properties to keep it on-budget and not require the development of wholly new, untested technologies. This observatory, known as Habitable Worlds Observatory, will be NASA’s next flagship mission after the Nancy Roman space telescope.
Credit: NASA/GSFC, LUVOIR concept

While the recommendation was that three of these four eventually be constructed, Lynx and Origins took a back seat to what was selected as the highest-priority mission: a scaled-up version of HabEx (or a scaled-down version of LUVOIR), taking features of both HabEx and LUVOIR into account to form the Habitable Worlds Observatory. In many ways, the proposed specification hit precisely in the “sweet spot” between feasibility given current technology, discovery potential given what we do and don’t know, and cost effectiveness, incorporating lessons learned from the problems and successes experienced along the way in the construction, design, and launch of JWST.

The specifications proposed for Habitable Worlds Observatory are very encouraging. So far, the design includes:

  • a segmented optical mirror design, similar to what’s already in use by JWST,
  • an improved version of the coronagraph technology that’s presently equipped aboard the Roman Telescope,
  • up-to-date sensors that can control the various mirror segments to achieve ~picometer-level stability (orders of magnitude better than JWST or current ground-based optical telescopes),
  • planned compatibility with next-generation rockets that will be flying in the late 2030s/early 2040s,
  • planned robotic servicing of components at the L2 Lagrange point, located ~1.5 million km from Earth,
  • but, other than that, no wholly new technologies that haven’t been fully matured prior to the development/construction phase.

The most expensive components of JWST were the all-new ones; with Habitable Worlds Observatory, there is nothing that’s all-new. This is extremely encouraging, as it presents an achievable plan that isn’t particularly susceptible to the delays and overruns that plagued JWST. Without the need to develop wholly new technologies, the path to getting a Habitable Worlds Observatory to the specifications we require is one of incremental improvement, rather than of wholesale invention.

spectroscopy exoplanet life

The prospect of detecting and characterizing the atmosphere of a true Earth-like planet, i.e., an Earth-sized planet in the habitable zone of its star, including both red dwarf and more Sun-like stars, is within our reach. With a next-generation coronagraph, a large ultraviolet-optical-infrared mission could find dozens, or even hundreds, of Earth-sized worlds to measure.
Credit: National Academies/Astro2020 decadal survey

With these capabilities, the Habitable Worlds Observatory will have an excellent chance to reach what’s perhaps the holy grail of astronomy: to reveal an actually inhabited planet to humanity for the very first time. With between a 6.0 and 6.5 meter primary mirror design, comparable to JWST in size and light-gathering power, it should be able to directly image Earth-sized planets around all of the stars within about ~14 light-years of Earth. Scientists on the design team will fight for every little bit of extra diameter they can get, because that’s what counts the most in this game; if you can double the radius you can see planets out to, you increase the search volume and the expected number of objects by a factor of eight. In the vicinity of the Sun, there are:

With its currently-planned design, somewhere between 20 and 30 Earth-like planets could be directly imaged by the Habitable Worlds Observatory. With a slightly scaled-up diameter, that number could easily be increased to around 100. If there’s even a ~few percent chance (or ~1%, in the upscaled scenario) of life taking hold on an Earth-like world, then this mission will likely bear the ultimate fruit: discovering our first inhabited planet beyond the Solar System. Perhaps, if nature is kind, we might even discover more than one.

closest stars to our Sun

This graphic shows the location of the closest star systems beyond the Solar System, centered on the Sun. If you can double the radius out to what you can see and measure, you encompass eight times the volume, which is why the ability to see farther even by a little bit vastly increases your chances to find something remarkable, even if it’s a rare type of system you’re seeking. Roughly every few hundred thousand years, a star will pass within 120,000 AU (a little less than 2 light-years) of Earth: coming within the estimated size of the Oort cloud.
Credit: Andrew Z. Colvin/Wikimedia Commons

Because we’ve already gone through the pain of developing many of the precursor technologies, including:

  • the 5-layer sunshield used with JWST,
  • the folded/segmented mirror design used with JWST,
  • and the deformable mirror used within the Roman coronagraph,

there shouldn’t be anything wholly new or novel to trip up the Habitable Worlds Observatory like there was with JWST.

However, all new developments come with risks. The idea of robotic servicing is encouraging, because we’ve done robotic servicing before, but only as far away as in low-Earth orbit. At the distance to L2, 1.5 million kilometers, even instructions sent at the speed-of-light have a 10 second round-trip delay. Upgrading the telescope and its instruments in orbit, i.e., the “servicing” component of the mission, will require both rocket technology and automated robotic technology that will need to be developed and matured.

To achieve ~picometer level mirror alignments is a technical challenge that requires advances far beyond the ~nanometer-level alignments achievable today. Although this requires only an incremental improvement over existing technology, a substantial set of resources will need to be devoted to it, and are currently being devoted as part of the “technology maturation” process inherent in the design and pre-design phases.

One big worry that hasn’t necessarily hit the right people’s radar is the suitability of the currently-designed Roman coronagraph for the Habitable Worlds Observatory. The JWST coronagraph is performing exactly as anticipated, enabling us to find and image planets that are just 1-part-in-100,000 as bright as their parent stars are. The Nancy Roman Telescope expects a factor of 1000 improvement over JWST, as their deformable coronagraph mirror is being optimized to deal with the interference patterns and stray light that emerges from a perfectly circular coronagraph shape.

However, there’s a catch: one of the reasons that the Nancy Roman Telescope’s coronagraph can perform so much better than JWST’s is because JWST has a tiled mirror with a segmented design, while the Nancy Roman telescope will have a single, circular, monolithic mirror. The shape of the JWST mirror is why it has that “snowflake-like” diffraction pattern around all of its stars and bright point-sources of light: that’s just a mathematical consequence of the geometry of its optics.

Since the architecture of the Habitable Worlds Observatory is slated to include a tiled primary mirror, this may pose a new set of compatibility difficulties.

nightmare snowflake

The point spread function for the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST), as predicted back in a 2007 document. The four factors of a hexagonal (not circular) primary mirror, composed out of a set of 18 tiled hexagons, each with ~4 mm gaps between them, and with three support struts to hold the secondary mirror in place, all work to create the inevitable series of spikes that appear around bright point sources imaged with JWST. This pattern has been affectionately called the “nightmare snowflake” by many of JWST’s instrument scientists.
Credit: R. B. Makidon, S. Casertano, C. Cox & R. van der Marel, STScI/NASA/AURA

After all, coronagraphs are circular in nature, and cannot easily “undo” the stray light that gets introduced from any sharp edges, including:

  • the hexagonal tiles,
  • the “corners” on the outer edges of the mirror,
  • and the ~millimeter-sized “gaps” between the various segments.

With a similar design to JWST, this seems like a very big problem for Habitable Worlds Observatory to reckon with, particularly since it needs coronagraphy that’s successful at the 1-part-in-10,000,000,000 (1-part-in-ten-billion) level to image Earth-like worlds around Sun-like stars: another factor of ~100 better than the Roman coronagraph will achieve.

However, there’s still the possibility that a larger-bodied rocket, capable of launching a monolithic mirror of diameters of 6.0 meters or more (and perhaps even up 8.4 meters: the largest monolithic mirrors we can reliably produce), will be available by the time the Habitable Worlds Observatory moves to its final design stage. If that occurs, this problem evaporates, and the mission becomes much less dependent on overcoming a difficult, never-before-faced problem.

starshade Astro2020

This artist’s concept shows the geometry of a space telescope aligned with a starshade, a technology used to block starlight in order to reveal the presence of planets orbiting that star. From tens of thousands of kilometers away, the starshade and the telescope must achieve and maintain perfect alignment to enable direct exoplanet imaging. Compared to a coronagraph, a starshade’s optics are superior, but far fewer stellar systems can be probed in any given amount of time.
Credit: NASA / JPL-Caltech

A different potential solution is to launch a starshade either with the Habitable Worlds Observatory or even after-the-fact, to block the target star’s light before it ever reaches the Habitable Worlds Observatory’s primary mirror. Although this is technologically feasible, it’s both expensive and limited in its effectiveness; it has to travel some ~80,000 kilometers relative to the observatory every time it wants to switch targets. (However, there is evidence that such a starshade could be multi-purpose, and leveraged with ground-based observatories as well.) All told, the addition of a starshade can help the Habitable Worlds Observatory potentially help image about one or two systems per year, meaning that it could allow for dozens or even scores of sufficiently imaged systems.

An intermediate solution that perhaps should be considered is neither building a traditional segmented mirror nor a single monolithic mirror, but a series of circular mirrors, akin to the optical setup of the presently under-construction Giant Magellan Telescope. With seven perfect circles instead of 18+ tiled hexagons, it has the light-gathering power of the area of all seven circles combined, but the resolution of the diameter across which the primary mirrors are mounted. With this design:

  • all of the stray light problems from a JWST-like design are eliminated,
  • the already-developed foldable primary mirror technology could still be utilized,
  • the picometer-level stability technology being developed across mirror segments would still apply,
  • and instead of a single secondary mirror and/or a single coronagraph, each of the seven segments could get their own.

As a bonus, there would be no wires required to cross the primary mirror optics, as the secondary mirror(s) could be held in place with wires that went in-between the gaps in the circular segments: precisely why the Giant Magellan Telescope will be the first world-class observatory without diffraction spikes on its stars.

Giant Magellan Telescope observatory illustration

The 25-meter Giant Magellan Telescope is currently under construction, and will be the greatest new ground-based observatory on Earth. The spider arms, seen holding the secondary mirror in place, are specially designed so that their line-of-sight falls directly between the narrow gaps in the GMT mirrors, creating a view of the Universe without sharp corners to its mirrors or diffraction spikes around its stars. As one of the two US Extremely Large Telescopes proposed by astronomers and currently in development, it is an essential part of bringing about a new generation in cutting-edge ground-based astronomy facilities.
Credit: Giant Magellan Telescope/GMTO Corporation

With the right design and implementation, and the technology maturation pathway laid out by NASA’s astrophysics division, we could be looking at a Habitable Worlds Observatory:

  • that launches as early as the late 2030s/early 2040s,
  • that’s on-budget and on-time,
  • that possesses the necessary architecture to achieve its observational goals without needing a starshade,
  • that’s fully refuellable and whose instruments are fully serviceable and replaceable,
  • that could have a starshade upgrade added to it at any point in the future,
  • and that quite possibly images enough “Earth-like” planets to discover at least one (and maybe even more than one) exoplanet that’s actually inhabited.

The big question that needs to go into the design of this telescope is the trade-off between how many Earth-like candidates it can directly image versus how large and costly the telescope is going to be. While the 6-to-7 meter range seems like the sweet spot, the nightmare scenario is that we build this observatory just a little too small and cost-conservatively to find what we’re ultimately seeking: an inhabited alien planet. We’d hardly regret it if we built one that was large enough that we sampled enough of the Universe to find more than one inhabited planet!

We must remember that in the search for life beyond Earth, we are playing a lottery with unknown odds. Each Earth-like planet that we image and characterize represents a ticket: a ticket in a lottery where the odds of all of the prizes are unknown. Our chances of success depend entirely on which tickets are winners and whether we buy enough of them. The hard part is we won’t know if we have meaningful constraints on what those odds actually are until after the findings from Habitable Worlds Observatory come in, and so it’s up to us to build it in such a way that our odds of at least one success are as great as possible. If we do, we might finally have the answer to “Are we alone in the Universe?” Just maybe, we’ll know for certain that the answer is, “No, there are others.”

This article was first published in February of 2023. It was updated in November of 2026.

This article NASA’s next flagship to answer the biggest question: “Are we alone?” is featured on Big Think.



Source link

Filed under: Philosophy

Selected by

Avatar photo

Im a doctor in training and I believe in a secular world