Secular & Atheism

Why do I vote in a church? 

Why do I vote in a church? 


I used to love Election Day.

There was something about doing my civic duty that gave me a feeling of togetherness and community that I didn’t often feel. I’d usually take the day off. A friend and I would arrange to go together, get our “I voted!” stickers, and grab a coffee. 

I haven’t done that in a long time. 

Now, this Separation of Church and State week, I can’t stop thinking about where I vote.

Why? Because every year I have to vote in a Catholic church. So does everyone else in my city, because that’s our only voting location. 

I don’t think anyone should be made to feel like an outsider because of what we believe or don’t. Please make a donation today to help us keep defending the separation of church and state.

For years it didn’t bother me. I never gave it much thought. I was used to walking by the giant crosses and pictures of Jesus as I went to find my ward (because I can never remember it). I used to joke about voting with the lord.

But in 2026, with a Christian Nationalist administration in charge, it’s hard to laugh about it. Having to walk into a church to cast my vote feels different now, especially when it seems like the only option. 

And that’s a big part of it: Why is a church the place we gather? We’ve lost things like community centers and recreational centers. We’ve lost the commons. And it’s a really tough pill to swallow walking into a church to vote against the Christian Nationalists when it feels like having us gather in that church is already a part of their plan. 

My polling place is what the erosion of state-church separation can look like. 

In 2022, Christianity Today reported that 1 in 5 polling places in the United States are in a place of worship. In Massachusetts, where I live, a third of our polling places are Catholic. Arkansas and Oklahoma are the highest, at 62% and 58% respectively.

I get that churches are free, and they usually offer a lot of parking for our car-centric society. But studies have shown that where people vote influences how they vote, even after researchers controlled for political beliefs.

 A 2010 study found that people who voted in churches were more likely to back conservative candidates. And a 2012 study further found that simply being in a church can prime more conservative thought, including negative attitudes toward the LGBTQ+ community.

And yet, legal challenges to this practice have been called “frivolous,” and courts have said “it’s fine” so long as there are alternatives available. 

But with widespread efforts to curtail absentee and early voting, it’s worth wondering for how long we will have alternatives. 

We shouldn’t have to make decisions about our democracy with a crucifix looming over our shoulders. 

When we talk about state-church separation, we often think about it in courtrooms and statehouses. But it’s all around us — in a well-meaning but presumptive “bless you” and in the places we cast our ballot. 

That’s why American Atheists’ work matters. Because protecting state-church separation means normalizing nonreligion and speaking out whenever and wherever religion starts to feel like a requirement. 

I want to love Election Day again. I want to walk into a community center, a library, or even a school gym and cast my ballot, put on my sticker, and go grab that coffee with a friend. And I want everyone to feel welcome where they vote — no matter what they believe or don’t. 

If you feel the same, I hope you’ll chip in $25, $50, or more today in honor of Separation of Church and State Week. Your contribution will help our team keep fighting for secular democracy, holding Christian Nationalists accountable, and building inclusive communities beyond a church.



Source link