What people find sexually arousing does not necessarily stay locked in place throughout adulthood. A new study published in Psychology & Sexuality indicates that adults generally view their sexual “turn-ons” as moderately changeable over time and across life experiences, with noticeable differences across age, race, gender, sexual orientation, education, and religion. Having shifting arousal triggers, however, showed no positive or negative connection with anxiety, depression, or sexual difficulties.
How shifting turn-ons differ from broader sexual fluidity
Sexual turn-ons are the specific qualities, situations, or sensations that spark sexual arousal, ranging from a partner’s physical features and personality traits to the emotional bond between partners. To describe changes in these triggers, researchers introduced the concept of “turn-on fluidity,” meaning the degree to which what sexually arouses someone shifts over time, through personal experiences, or across relationships. In a 2024 survey study by two of the same authors using data from the same broader research project, cisgender and gender-diverse adults reported an expansive mix of physical, personality, and relational turn-ons, raising the question of whether those preferences stay fixed or evolve.
Prior research on changing desires focused mostly on broad behavioral adaptability or on which genders someone finds attractive. In a 2000 theoretical review, the author argued that sexual desires and behaviors, especially among women, can be reshaped by culture and life circumstances, a capacity termed erotic plasticity.
Other research has examined whether people direct their attractions exclusively toward one gender or feel drawn to more than one. In an earlier study of men and women, men showed strong exclusivity toward their preferred gender in their attractions and erotic fantasies, whereas women reported higher attraction and more frequent fantasies involving their non-preferred gender.
Free daily newsletter
Don’t miss the next big psychology finding
Every morning, PsyPost sends a short briefing on the most interesting new peer-reviewed research in psychology and neuroscience.
Researchers have also studied sexual fluidity, meaning shifts over time in attraction to the same or different genders regardless of one’s stated orientation. Looking at how stable those attractions remain across adulthood, a 2016 study tracking adults across timescales found that bisexual individuals experienced more shifts in attraction over time than heterosexual individuals.
Life events such as marriage, divorce, medical treatments, or societal disruptions can also prompt changes in sexual behavior. For example, a survey of adults during the COVID-19 lockdowns found that 20 percent of participants tried new sexual activities such as new positions, and those who experimented were three times as likely to report an improved sex life. Researchers separately study “sexual flexibility,” a person’s willingness to step away from routine “sexual scripts,” or cultural expectations about how sex should unfold, when facing bedroom problems, a trait linked to higher sexual satisfaction.
Whether those broader shifts extend to specific arousal triggers remained untested, prompting lead author Melody Garas, a psychology graduate student at Queen’s University in Kingston, Ontario, Canada, to examine the topic under the supervision of senior author Caroline Pukall. Pukall is a professor of psychology and Canada Research Chair in Sexual Health at Queen’s University, where she directs the Sexual Health Research Lab, and is the editor of the textbook “Human Sexuality: A Contemporary Introduction.”
“Although researchers have studied sexual fluidity for many years, that work has largely focused on changes in attraction, identity, or sexual orientation,” Garas and Pukall told PsyPost. “Much less attention has been paid to a related but distinct question: whether the specific things that turn people on remain stable or change over time. We wanted to explore this gap and better understand whether turn-ons are experienced as fixed or fluid, whether this differs across social and demographic groups, and whether turn-on fluidity is related to psychological or sexual well-being.”
Measuring changes in arousal triggers and well-being
Because turn-on fluidity had not been directly studied before, the authors framed their work as an exploratory analysis; participants did not consent to public data sharing, so the dataset was not posted online. Between November 2022 and January 2023, the team recruited English-speaking adults through social media ads on Instagram, Facebook, Reddit, and Twitter (now X) for a survey on legal, consensual sexual preferences.
After screening out incomplete, automated, duplicate, or ineligible entries from 1,077 submissions, the sample included 343 adults with an average age of 31.6 years, mostly in Canada and the United States. Slightly over half were women, just over a third were men, and about one in ten identified as gender-diverse, while most respondents were white and had post-secondary education. Nearly half of the sample identified as heterosexual and roughly 30 percent as bisexual or pansexual, alongside 8.2 percent who identified as gay or lesbian and 14.3 percent who endorsed other sexual minority identities such as demisexual, heteroflexible, or questioning.
Participants rated five statements created for the study from 0 (does not apply at all) to 10 (applies extremely well), with no preset definition of “turn-on.” The items asked whether their turn-ons had always been the same (reverse-scored to reflect change), had changed over time, or had shifted with life experiences, relationship status, or relationship length. Keeping the first two items separate let respondents indicate if some triggers stayed steady while others shifted, and about three-quarters gave non-identical answers across them.
Respondents also completed five validated questionnaires measuring mental and sexual well-being. Two scales assessed generalized anxiety and depression symptoms over the prior two weeks, while the other three measured sexual distress over the prior month, sexual dysfunction over the prior week, and sexual flexibility around bedroom problems.
Because participants could skip any question, sample sizes ranged from 148 to 273 across individual scales. To compare single-category groups, the researchers omitted 24 multiracial and 32 multireligious participants from the racial and religious comparisons, and across all group comparisons and regression models, analyses statistically adjusted for age, gender, and sexual orientation.
Moderate turn-on fluidity and differences across social groups
Across the sample, average scores on the five fluidity items fell near the middle of the 0-to-10 scale, from 4.27 for shifts based on relationship length to 6.73 for shifts based on life experiences. These mid-range ratings suggest that adults tend to view their turn-ons as moderately changeable rather than entirely fixed.
Several demographic differences emerged, though typically on one or two items rather than across all five. In an analysis treating age as a continuous predictor, younger adults tended to score slightly higher than older adults on reporting that their turn-ons had not always been the same, while associations between age and the other four items were not statistically significant.
Separate group comparisons examined averages across sexual orientation and gender on the 0-to-10 scale. Bisexual and pansexual participants averaged 1.36 points higher than heterosexual participants in reporting that their turn-ons had not always been the same, whereas comparisons involving gay or lesbian respondents and other sexual minorities were not statistically significant, nor were orientation differences on the remaining four items. Across gender groups, men and women reported similar fluidity overall, while gender-diverse adults averaged more than two points lower than both men and women on shifts tied to relationship status; gender differences on the other four items were not statistically significant.
Across racial identities, overall group variation emerged on two items: whether turn-ons had changed over time and whether they had not always been the same. In follow-up pairwise comparisons adjusted for multiple testing, white participants averaged 2.86 points higher than East Asian participants on turn-ons changing over time, whereas none of the individual pairwise comparisons on whether turn-ons had always been the same were statistically significant. Overall racial differences on the remaining three items were not statistically significant.
Formal education showed a similar pattern, with overall group variation appearing on both experience-based shifts and relationship-length shifts, though follow-up comparisons for experience-based shifts were not statistically significant. Adults with post-secondary education averaged 2.16 points higher than high school graduates on changes tied to relationship length, whereas overall differences between single and partnered adults were not statistically significant on any of the five items.
Religious affiliation showed overall variation across all five fluidity questions, producing the largest group effects in the study. In follow-up comparisons, Christian participants averaged lower fluidity scores than atheists on whether their turn-ons had always stayed the same, and lower than both spiritual and non-religious adults on changes tied to life experiences.
Jewish participants also averaged 3.75 to 4.84 points higher than Christians on shifts over time, relationship status, and relationship length, and 4.89 points higher than atheists on relationship-length shifts. Still, the authors advised interpreting the religious findings with caution, since many of the individual pairwise comparisons across the religious groups in the survey were not statistically significant.
“The strongest and most consistent finding was that turn-on fluidity was present across the sample,” the researchers noted. “Differences between demographic groups existed, but they were generally small to moderate in size and should be interpreted cautiously. The practical significance may be less about predicting who will experience fluidity and more about recognizing that changes in turn-ons are a relatively common part of people’s sexual experiences.”
No link to anxiety, depression, or sexual difficulties
None of the five turn-on fluidity items had a statistically significant association with anxiety, depression, sexual distress, sexual dysfunction, or sexual flexibility. Even people who readily adjusted their sexual routines around bedroom problems were no more likely to report shifting turn-ons, and only age predicted well-being outcomes, with older adults reporting lower anxiety and depression alongside slightly higher sexual distress.
That lack of a connection stood out to the team. “Given that sexual well-being is often closely linked to broader psychological well-being, we expected there might be at least some association,” the authors explained. “Instead, the results suggest that changes in turn-ons themselves may be relatively neutral from a well-being perspective.”
How social norms and relationship scripts may shape desires
Several demographic patterns align with an earlier study of adolescents, in which a third of youth reported changes in attractions and about one in six reported shifts in sexual orientation identity. Although that study measured changes in orientation labels and the gender of one’s attractions rather than specific erotic turn-ons, it similarly observed greater fluidity among younger participants, bisexual and pansexual youth, and white compared to Asian respondents.
In interpreting the group differences, the authors suggest that turn-on fluidity may reflect how much sexual exploration a person’s social environment encourages. Reporting unchanging turn-ons could reflect genuinely stable triggers, they note, or limited experimentation among people shaped by religious purity norms or more conservative cultural attitudes toward sex. In the authors’ reading, casual dating norms may give younger adults more room to explore, while university settings coincide with both formative relationships and higher openness to new experiences.
The researchers also propose that traditional gendered relationship scripts may push cisgender men and women to adjust their preferences when partnering more than gender-diverse adults, who often build their own relationship norms. Regarding well-being, the authors suggest that sexual flexibility reflects practical coping tactics rather than shifting arousal, and that whether a turn-on carries stigma and shame may matter more for mental and sexual health than whether it changes.
“The main takeaway is that sexual turn-ons do not appear to be completely fixed for many people,” Garas and Pukall said. “Participants generally reported moderate levels of change in their turn-ons over time and across experiences, suggesting that it is common for what people find sexually appealing to evolve throughout life. At the same time, we found no evidence that having more fluid turn-ons was associated with poorer psychological or sexual well-being, which may be reassuring for people who notice changes in what they find arousing.”
Caveats and next steps for studying arousal over time
There are a few things to keep in mind when weighing these results. Although the study focused on how arousal triggers shift over time, its cross-sectional design meant participants answered the survey only once and relied on memory to judge past desires. One-time snapshots cannot separate aging from generational differences or imperfect recall, and the survey did not measure actual relationship duration despite asking about changes tied to relationship length.
“A key caveat is that this was an exploratory, cross-sectional study, so it cannot tell us why turn-ons change or establish cause-and-effect relationships,” the researchers cautioned. “Additionally, our findings do not suggest that everyone’s turn-ons change dramatically, only that many people report some degree of change over time.”
The survey also left “turn-on” undefined and relied on five single-item questions, meaning respondents who blend physical arousal, attraction, and sex drive may have interpreted the items differently. In addition, more than two-thirds of initial entries went unfinished, and some comparisons rested on small subgroups, including 18 East Asian and 13 Jewish respondents overall, making those specific differences tentative until tested in larger samples.
Future longitudinal studies that follow the same individuals over several years could help determine whether turn-ons evolve naturally or intentionally, while qualitative interviews could unpack how adults define their own arousal triggers and sexual satisfaction.
“One important next step is to develop and validate more comprehensive measures of turn-on fluidity,” the authors stated. “We are also interested in understanding how turn-ons evolve over time, what experiences contribute to those changes, and whether turn-on fluidity relates to other aspects of sexuality that were not examined here, such as sexual desire, arousal, or relationship experiences. Longitudinal and qualitative research will be especially valuable for answering these questions.”
“To our knowledge, this is among the first empirical studies to specifically examine turn-on fluidity as a concept distinct from sexual orientation fluidity,” Garas and Pukall added. “We hope the work encourages researchers and clinicians to think more carefully about how sexual interests develop across the lifespan and to recognize that variation and change in turn-ons may be a normal part of many people’s sexual experiences.”
The study, “Turn-on fluidity and its relationship with psychological and sexual wellbeing: an exploratory analysis,” was authored by Melody Garas, Rebecca Star, and Caroline F. Pukall.
