Education

AI Has a Place in Education, Just Not in My Classroom

AI Has a Place in Education, Just Not in My Classroom


Last spring, I was inspired by educator Sean Morrissy’s word mapping project and was curious about using word maps with students to help them deepen their vocabulary knowledge. So I decided to conduct an action research project on the topic for my graduate course. 

Unfortunately, the project ran into hurdle after hurdle as my professor rejected proposal after proposal. A skeptic of the science of reading, she pushed back on my ideas to use explicit vocabulary instruction that was rooted in research and instead urged me to look into the latest edtech. 

Finally, I caved, and added an artificial intelligence (AI) component to my word mapping research. The proposal involved students using AI to create word maps as a source of comparison to their own. It was a creative attempt to get students interacting with and critiquing AI in a way that wouldn’t replace active student thought and engagement.

While my professor was elated that I agreed to use AI, I was still hesitant to take the leap into AI implementation while so many questions about its impact remain. I don’t want to use something just because it is new and shiny. If I’m going to bring AI into my classroom, I want to make sure it’s a benefit and not a risk, especially when its use appears to conflict with methods and practices that I know work well. In the end, I created the proposal but did not implement the lesson. 

But we are rapidly racing toward an AI-driven reality, and I have to wonder whether my work as a literacy advocate, and my intentional efforts to structure a classroom around what cognitive science tells us about how the brain learns, are meeting my students’ needs. I am also coming to terms with the reality that my classroom alone may never be able to meet those needs; acknowledging this limitation is not an admission of failure.

At the moment, I find myself stuck, much as I did during my graduate research project. I am against AI use due to students not having the foundational literacy. And I am against teaching AI literacy due to time constraints of everything else we have to teach in English language arts (ELA). I am torn between staying steadfast in what science tells us about how the brain learns to read and taking a gamble on the newest, buzziest technology. Reconciling my responsibility to prepare students for a future undoubtedly shaped by AI with my responsibility to protect the cognitive processes that make learning possible in the first place is not an easy task.

Pulling Back the Tech

My concerns about AI in the classroom began long before my battle with my graduate school professor about word maps. To be honest, I began pulling back from technology in the years after the COVID-19 pandemic, when I found so many students unable to handle the endless distractibility of a school-issued Chromebook. 

To this day, my seventh graders stray to other tabs or websites with the same unconscious automaticity that leads adults to doomscroll on a lunch break. Even when I restrict their browsing to specific websites, they waste time changing fonts, trying new backgrounds and downloading extensions instead of engaging with the academic task.

As a longtime educator, literacy teacher and advocate for reading science — and someone who grew up with school computers available only in a lab separate from the classroom — it is frustrating to know that even my best-executed lesson could have a low impact if students are in the presence of a screen. 

So instead of fighting that battle, I often forgo Chromebooks entirely. I model annotation strategies under my doc cam, ask kids to write first drafts by hand and spend our time together cultivating our formal and informal oral language skills. Students use Chromebooks only for major assessments; day-to-day work mostly involves novels, pencils and notebooks. 

At first, it was a hard, slow transition that took place roughly two to three years ago. It was especially tough for students who were used to unrestricted access to the internet and AI for entire class periods. In the first few weeks, they were extra fidgety, awkward about talking to peers and complained their hands hurt because they weren’t used to handwriting all their notes and essays. 

To combat this, I explicitly modeled calm behavior, eye contact and shorthand note-taking. Students are expected to master all these skills by seventh grade and I re-embedded them into my teaching as a foundation for the work we do offline. 

By the end of the 2023-24 school year, my students were more confident readers, speakers and thinkers. Years later, after they graduate, my hope is they will come back and tell me they struggled less in eighth grade and high school English language arts than their peers, and that end-of-year standardized testing felt easier than before.

Although stepping back from technology initially caught my seventh graders off guard, their ultimate growth was not accidental; reading science supports this back-to-basics approach. One argument for ditching the keyboard comes from research suggesting that handwriting can support learning and memory while also stimulating broader patterns of brain connectivity. Just this year, a meta-analysis of 56 studies found that scrolling through digital text wreaks havoc on the brain’s ability to decode and comprehend it. 

Furthermore, while teachers can see attentional decline in their own classrooms, a recent study offers more reason to hesitate by confirming that unrestricted access to AI continues to reduce student attention and retention. 

These studies reveal the limitations of the human brain itself. Maryanne Wolf, author of “Reader, Come Home: The Reading Brain in a Digital World,” reminds us that reading isn’t natural for the human brain — that’s why it must be taught explicitly. The reality is that neither our brains nor our students’ brains have adapted to the very recent influx of technology. 

Learning how to think critically, write precisely and read analytically is no easy task, and since these three skills require so much cognitive attention, I believe that there is no room left for AI literacy in the ELA block. 

But could this AI revolution really create the decline of cognitive abilities that I fear, or could this be the next evolution of the human brain as we know it? 

The Historical Echo

Socrates once feared that the rise of writing would lead to the downfall of academia itself because it made people retain only ambiguous ideas and rely on the written language to remind them of their own intelligence. My reaction to AI echoes Socrates’ response to innovations in his own time. His critique of the new technology of written language shaped his fear that the very foundations of his lifelong dedication to art, pedagogy and critical thought could be threatened by the newest, shiniest shortcut. This idea resonates with me and many other educators as we navigate AI implementation in schools. 

Despite feeling like I’ve made progress with my students regarding AI use in my classroom, I’d be lying if I said the rapid integration of AI into education doesn’t have me worried that this quiet peace is about to come crashing down. After all, my university professor’s implicit message was clear: reading science is boring, and AI is the latest trend we all should be running toward. Maybe we are more in the eye of the storm, at least in my classroom. The debates are happening for sure, but at least in my district, no one is really making big decisions for or against. I think they will come.

Although I am passionate about the research and science behind effective literacy practices, I also know the world changes whether or not we want it to. AI will be a part of my students’ future careers, and mine as well. 

Students have a right to be prepared for the workforce that awaits them, which means I also have an obligation to be informed about the pedagogical approaches to AI. Although I have no plans to integrate AI literacy into my ELA block, I am slowly working through an AI literacy course through an ISTE Generation AI Scholarship. I have also been accepted as an AI Education Project Trailblazer fellow to investigate the use of an AI curriculum in humanities spaces. 

I think Evie Wusk, an assistant professor of education and English, articulates my approach best with a metaphor of the flamingo stance: having one foot submerged in the curiosity of edtech’s newest frontier, and one foot pulled out to protect the humanity and cognition we have developed. My exploration of AI use through my AI Education Project fellowship could very well contradict every AI belief I hold, and that is okay because what I can’t do is simply continue on as if AI doesn’t exist, or that the learners in front of us aren’t totally different from the ones even 10 years ago. 

Ready for the Future

Over these past few years, it felt like the more tech I took away, the faster students built knowledge and the deeper their thinking and writing became. 

On the odd days when we do break out the Chromebooks, I see students talking less about the content, going back to the text less often and getting off task more frequently because they are on a different website. They can still get off task for a few minutes when the laptops are stored. But I feel better because they are building social skills by talking to each other, finding moments of peace without high-stimulation screens and discovering creativity through simple notebook doodles. 

These organic, unscripted moments are further affirmation that, without AI’s influence, students are taking what I have taught them about oral language and critical thinking and applying it to their own interests. With the canyon-sized literacy gaps we face, and the ease with which technology can quickly and negatively impact comprehension, AI literacy lessons probably fit best in STEAM spaces or flexible learning times. 

Regardless of how I feel about AI, it is a joy to see my students actively preparing for the world they will face outside the school’s doors. But before they enter the real world where they can wield any tool effectively, be it a pen, a keyboard or an AI assistant, they must learn to think critically, which only comes from active cognitive engagement that is not artificial. 

For now, my low-tech classroom is a space where student thought and oral discussion have the chance to develop outside of the tempting influence of AI’s reach. But it is also my professional obligation to acknowledge there may come a day when keeping this technology out of my classroom is no longer an option. And that’s okay too. Most importantly, my students will be ready.



Source link