This article originally appeared in The Skeptic, Volume 7, Issue 6, from 1993.
I’ll say one thing for old Ron Hubbard of Scientology notoriety: at times, he was careful of his semantics. He pointed out, quite sensibly, that as you can’t be the same thing as something you own, then to talk about ‘my soul’ is a nonsense. The bit that is conscious, is you yourself. Anything else that survives death and even gets tortured in hell you are therefore not conscious of, so you can stop worrying.
I just thought I’d get that source of possible misunderstanding out of the way first. You are a consciousness. Which is obvious, really.
The next item on the menu is to take the bull by the horns and all four feet, and try to define consciousness. Some learned person tried this in a recent book, and came up with six different consciousnesses in each human being, which somehow get together to form ‘me’. I prefer to define my consciousness simply as awareness.
This is a very useful definition because, in plain language, if you’re not aware of anything ever, do ‘you’ exist? (Further: you can be aware of yourself as a consciousness any time you like. But awareness of anything else can be temporary, fickle or even illusory. ‘You’ are a certainty.)
We now come to people’s experience of the so-called paranormal, which features frequently in The Skeptic including issue 7.3 which I’m reading again this week. Let’s start off with near-death experiences, or NDE.
You’re on a hospital bed, and the doctors are looking worried. You float up to the ceiling, and observe your body on the bed. The doctors are doing something to it, yet your main feeling is only one of curiosity. At this point you observe that you are in a tunnel with a bright light at the end which pulls you towards it. You serenely follow the light to emerge in a lovely garden, where dear old Uncle Jack who died in 1976 is pruning some roses, and comes over to greet you. After a hug and a chat, you are suddenly aware that something is pulling you back, and you wake up on the hospital bed with a worried surgeon bending over you, and you feel a bit annoyed.
Oh, brother (or sister) – are you making a whole bagful of unsubstantiated assumptions! Let’s dissect your NDE, or any other paranormal experience. First, how do you know it’s your body you’re viewing from the ceiling? In fact, how do you know it’s a ‘body’ at all? Well, your memory tells you, doesn’t it? And your memory tells you what light is, and what tunnels are, and who Uncle Jack was, and about roses. It also tells you what it is that you’re feeling: serenity, friendship, annoyance, whatever. Mind you, the first time you ever felt these sensations, they were just feelings, which in any case are bodily functions – which is why drugs affect them, which is why we have drug-trafficking. Because they’re material things, causing feelings. For which you need a body. And a memory to remember them.
Yet isn’t your memory essentially corporeal, rather than ethereal? It’s decades since it was found that prodding certain parts of the brain produced certain memories. And Alzheimer’s disease isn’t ethereal or paranormal but physical, destroying memories or blocking them.
Near Death Experiences, exteriorisation, souls flitting back and forth, all involve another serious contradiction. For these ‘souls’ seem to be able to see perfectly well. Yet seeing is not just looking at something. It’s a highly complex physical operation in which you first need a lens and a retina to produce a picture, which is upside down. Behind the rods and cones of the retina, sensitive cells do a certain amount of preliminary data processing before passing the data on to the sight interpretation area at the back of the brain. This puts the picture right side up, and relates it to your memory of what you’ve seen before. Which, in the case of NDEs, is beds, nurses, ceilings, tunnels, light, Uncle Jack and all. Very physical indeed. And much the same goes for talking to Uncle Jack’s ghost.
Paranormalists in America have tried to get over the problem of an ethereal memory by calling it a ‘discarnate memory’ – a memory which doesn’t need a brain or even nervous system to exist. Even less probable than a computer that’s all ethereal software and no hardware at all?
I consider this matter of post-death memory to be central to any discussion of ‘soul’, survival, Last Judgements and all the rest of it. For let’s go back to the one thing we haven’t yet managed to comprehend: simple consciousness. Put differently, us. (And let’s keep animals out of this. Animals are aware. Humans are aware of being aware. That’s why we’re human. And the bigger our pre-frontal lobes, the more we’re capable of monitoring our own thoughts and actions. Well, it’s an interesting theory, anyway.)
In almost all the literature I’ve read on the subject (even by skeptics) there seems no understanding of the fact that consciousness alone is not enough for intellectual, emotional or locational survival. For consciousness is not personality. For that, you need memory. Simple awareness is total ignorance which means that, if we can’t take a well-functioning memory with us when we go to heaven, we might well find that the sum of everyone’s IQ in heaven adds up to zero. Unless you believe in miracles or other cop-outs.
There’s another interesting thing about memory which I will pass on as I don’t see why I should be the only person who can’t solve it rationally. When you go to sleep at night, mightn’t it be that what really happens is that your memory switches off totally while you remain completely conscious but unaware of anything except awareness itself? So that when you wake up in the morning, it’s simply your memory re-activating. And as that memory hasn’t recorded anything while you’ve been asleep, you say ‘Gosh, I slept well’ only you’ve been fully conscious all the time.
Dreams? Well, if your memory starts churning around in your sleep, your consciousness will make you aware of those memories. Hence, dreams. And as they’ll now be in your memory, you can remember some of them. An irritating theory I pass on, free.
A final word on memory. We are – as anyone who has had anything like aphasia knows – rather more fragile and more at the mercy of our physical being, memory bytes and all, than most people imagine. I had aphasia on several brief occasions about thirty years ago, and it is a most educational experience, despite scaring the hell out of one. I had been overworking, had eye-strain, and got a new pair of specs which turned out to overcorrect for parallax. A week later, I had the visual phenomena of migraine, but nothing else until a couple of minutes later when I tried to say something and gibberish came out. I kept trying. More gibberish. (I later realised that speech is practically automatic so that, when one normally speaks, one is only barely conscious of assembling the words in one’s mind. One gets the sense of what one wants to say and it comes out, without effort, in one’s own terms of phrases and inflections.)
Anyway, I had nightmarish thoughts of having to learn the English language again, from scratch. But a few minutes later, speech slowly returned, and after getting new specs, the problem vanished. But it had been like being in a car and forgetting what all the controls were for, even forgetting which end is ‘front’.
Now, spectacles and eye-strain are not ethereal things. Yet even that minor, strain-caused disturbance to my brain wiped out my ability to use language for a bit. Destroy the brain, as in death, and it seems as if you do indeed wipe out all memory and personality. For keeps.
Which leaves us with consciousness: a most puzzling phenomenon, for it is both fragile and tough. A simple blow to the head will temporarily demolish it completely. But, on the other hand, how many babies have you heard of who have actually been born unconscious? How many puppies or kittens are born in a coma? Not many, although babies and pups alike may be still-born, which is quite a different thing. Because it means, dead.
So you’re conscious and you know who you are. Do you? What if you had only been in your body since you woke up this morning – the previous owner having gone elsewhere. How can you prove that that isn’t the case? You’ll have all the memories of your brain, and all of them telling you that they’re your memories. Your reflexes, attitudes, tastes and so on will be, you think, unchanged and yours. Only they’re some-one else’s. There’s no way you can tell, because simple consciousness doesn’t have reflexes, attitudes or tastes. It’s simply awareness. Which is why many people, on coming round after a really nasty crack on the head, don’t know who they are, what they are, or where they are. But they’re certainly aware. And their memory-system is recording, so they can remember much of it later.
So far, I seem to have done a fair job of proving that there’s no life after death. But where there is even a tiny bit of rational doubt, the true Skeptic is skeptical even of his own conclusions. And the doubt here is in the fact that, on a planet which is around four billion years old, Homo Sap has only been around for some 100,000 years, and science and its scientific methodology, for probably less than 400. So we know rather less than we might think, as shown by our wide-eyed reaction to such things as the Big Bang and genetic engineering, etc. By no means is all the evidence in regarding consciousness. We can’t actually prove that it exists in the Here and Now – or in another dimension (to offer a smart escape hatch from the Grim Reaper?).
But, from what we know, we can make some shrewd guesses and even afford a chuckle at that skeptical epigram about the ‘survival of the soul’ which goes: ‘Most of those who yearn for eternal life don’t even know what to do with themselves on a wet Sunday afternoon.’ Surely a self-evident truth?
So why does humanity imagine there’s an individual, surviving soul for each, all and sundry? My personal opinion is that this is partly because it’s very hard to imagine ‘not being’. But as this problem is in a way self-answering (‘not being’ means not being anything), try this way around it: describe your feelings on 22 November, 1746. (Reincarnationists need not answer that one.) See? It is possible for you to imagine that you don’t exist; in the abstract, anyway.
Humanity as a whole, however, doesn’t engage in such deep thinking. It blithely assumes that if ‘I’ survive death, so do my memory, sight, hearing, emotions – in fact, the whole works. And yet if all this assemblage of sophisticated sensors, data, gigabytes (and, to get to Heaven, navigational equipment) does exist in the here-and-now universe as the orthodox religions assure us, then surely it must weigh something? Well…
In the latter half of 1993, some German scientists allegedly claimed that after many careful weighings of people at the very moment of death, they found that ten milligrams had gone missing per corpse. No, I don’t know the names of the scientists or of their lab (although I’d feel better about it all if Richard Dawkins had been present) because we now have a problem (or rather, the German scientists do.)
If souls have weight but no volume (because if they had volume, they’d be unable to escape from submarines, etc) then their density must be infinite and they should sink to the centre of the Earth. Too much volume, and they’d end up in the stratosphere. And what about momentum? If you have a fatal infarction in a 747 at full speed, do you just keep circling the Earth?
In other words, if ‘I’ have any existence in this universe, even as self-regenerating radiation (which can be measured, surely?) then a fair assumption is that ‘I’ must obey the universe’s laws. Otherwise, we’re back in the Miracles and Magic department – generally known as the paranormal. I just thought I’d clear that point up. I hope I have.
Still, the sneaking feeling exists when you look at the sheer size and improbability of the universe, that it just might be a ‘put-up job’. Otherwise, why the existence of Sod’s Law? Why, when nuclear physicists look for simple truths, do they find only more and more complications? Why are religions both so powerfully mind-warping, yet so stupid? And bearing in mind that we can’t know anything except through physical nerve-endings, is there really a universe out there? For when the chips are down, ‘I’ is the only certainty we have.
I hope I haven’t spoiled your dinner.
