Philosophy

Astronomers weigh the Milky Way’s mass at long last

Astronomers weigh the Milky Way’s mass at long last


Astronomers have long since mapped out the Milky Way’s starlight.

Behind the dome of a series of European Southern Observatory telescopes, the Milky Way towers in the southern skies, flanked by the Large and Small Magellanic Clouds, at right. Although there are several thousand stars and the plane of the Milky Way all visible to human eyes, there are only four galaxies beyond our own that the typical unaided human eye can detect. Although observing the normal matter and starlight within our galaxy allows us to map out the stellar and gaseous distribution, mapping out the mass distribution is a more challenging endeavor.

Credit: ESO/Z. Bardon (www.bardon.cz)/ProjectSoft (www.projectsoft.cz)

But mapping our mass — or weighing the Milky Way — has proven far more difficult.

milky way Gaia

Gaia’s all-sky view of our Milky Way Galaxy and neighboring galaxies. The maps show the total brightness and color of stars (top), the total density of stars (middle), and the interstellar dust that fills the galaxy (bottom). Although this traces out the baryonic matter remarkably well in a variety of wavelengths of light, this method reveals only about 15% of the total mass of our Milky Way Galaxy. The remainder, dark matter, must be revealed dynamically.

Credit: ESA/Gaia/DPAC

Recent estimates range from 500 billion to nearly 2 trillion solar masses.

Scatter plot showing Milky Way mass measurements (M200) from 2013 to 2023, with data points labeled 1 through 20 and a horizontal shaded region representing the mean value.

This graph, with error bars, shows a variety of estimates of the overall mass of the Milky Way from a variety of studies from 2013 through 2023. Overall masses range from approximately 500 billion to 2 trillion: a factor of 4 in uncertainty. Weighing the Milky Way, here in the 21st century, has proven remarkably difficult from our location within it.
Credit: V. V. Bobylev & A. T. Baykova, Astronomy Reports, 2023

Using a combination of DESI and Gaia data, the DESI collaboration just weighed the Milky Way.

Comparison of QSO fiber assignment completeness in DESI DR1 and DR2, showing two plots with varying colors indicating different levels of completeness across right ascension and declination axes.

The new (DR2) DESI data set contains more than 14 million galaxies and quasars, which is more than double the number released in DR1 in 2024, over the region of the sky highlighted on the map on the right. Although its primary goal was to measure the Universe well beyond the Milky Way, it also was able to capture spectroscopic data on an enormous number of stars within the Milky Way, even though it avoided the galactic plane: the location where most Milky Way stars can be found.

Credit: DESI DR1 and DR2; Cristhian Garcia-Quintero

They identified more than 10,000 individual stars away from the galaxy’s disk: within the halo.

dark matter halo milky way

The dark matter halo around our galaxy should exhibit slightly different interaction probabilities as the Earth orbits the Sun, varying our motion through the dark matter in our galaxy. The stellar extent of each galaxy that we observe is embedded within a much larger dark matter halo, which can extend for millions of light-years for a typical Milky Way-like galaxy.
Credit: ESO/L. Calçada

They focused on blue and RR Lyrae horizontal branch stars.

Graph illustrating the evolutionary journey of a 1 solar mass star, akin to our sun, from main sequence through red giant and asymptotic branches to its final planetary nebula phase, depicted by luminosity and temperature changes as the star eventually dies.

After evolving off of the main sequence (not shown), stars with similar masses and metallicities to the Sun evolve into subgiants, then true red giants, then evolve back and forth along the horizontal branch. There is typically a “gap” in the horizontal branch between the red and blue ends in an individual population of stars, like within a globular cluster, where those stars pulse and vary in their properties: RR Lyrae stars. The latest study traced both blue horizontal branch stars and RR Lyrae stars in the galactic halo.

Credit: Lithopsian/Wikimedia Commons

Stellar distances ranged from 33,000 up to 312,000 light-years.

Histogram comparing the distribution of RRL (red) and BHB (blue) star counts over distance in kiloparsecs, used for Milky Way mass measurements.

This graph shows the number of RR Lyrae (red) and blue horizontal branch (blue) stars selected for this latest study as a function of distance. No stars closer to the galactic center than 32,000 light-years or farther than 312,000 light-years were chosen, but more stars at greater distances could lead to an even superior future study.
Credit: DESI Collaboration, Astrophysical Journal submitted/arXiv:2611.05518, 2026

The DESI data’s best-ever spectroscopic measurements provide exquisite line-of-sight motion data.

A spectrometer, like JWST’s NIRSpec instrument (shown here) or DESI’s ground-based spectrometer, can break the light from many different targets in the same field-of-view up into their component wavelengths. The shifting of the light toward either the red or the blue end of the spectrum, relative to the laboratory rest-frame of Earth, reveals the star’s motion relative to our instrument-at-rest along the line-of-sight.

Credit: NASA/ESA/CSA and the NIRSpec team

This is complemented by Gaia data, which yields superior proper (transverse) motions of these stars.

A small, curved trail of light moves rapidly across a star-filled field, providing data for Milky Way mass measurements against a black background.

As the Earth revolves around the Sun annually, even stationary stars appear to make small circles owing to the relative motion of the Earth around the Sun. However, superimposed on that circular motion is proper motion: the drift of the star over long periods of time, causing it to move on the sky. All of the stars are in motion, and ESA’s Gaia is our best tool for measuring and quantifying these stellar proper motions for stars within our galaxy.
Credit: ESA/Gaia collaboration

They then compared the 3D positions and motions of the observed stars with 24 simulated galaxies of known masses.

Three panels simulating Milky Way mass in the dark matter halo: one showing the halo, one with star-forming dwarf galaxies, and one with dwarf galaxies where star formation has ceased.

According to computer simulations, swarms of dark matter clumps exist all throughout the smooth halo of the Milky Way and all galaxies. Some of them can even trigger star-formation within them. Even beyond the luminous extent of the galactic disk, the positions and motions of halo stars can be used to trace the gravitational mass of the galaxy, and simulations can be used to understand how different tracer and analysis methods can be biased.
Credit: NASA, ESA, and T. Brown and J. Tumlinson (STScI)

Several different analysis methods were independently implemented.

A grid of scatter plots comparing Milky Way mass measurements across five methods (emPDF, GME, NIMBLE-A, NIMBLE-B, and Joint) for various Auriga halos, showing errors for M < 30 kpc, 80 kpc, and 200c.

Leveraging different methods for estimating a halo mass, when applied to mock catalogues from simulated galaxies of known underlying masses, can help quantify the bias inherent in each method. For different radii from the galactic center, different methods overestimate or underestimate the actual mass. However, a joint analysis, in the rightmost panel, can be leveraged to create the least biased result possible. Once calibrated in this fashion, this method can be applied to actual, real-world data.
Credit: DESI Collaboration, Astrophysical Journal submitted/arXiv:2611.05518, 2026

The greatest uncertainties — at the galactic center and within the disk — were irrelevant for this data.

Two graphs showing Milky Way mass measurements, comparing estimates from different methods for RRL (left) and BHB (right) tracers.

Four different methods and algorithms were each applied to a selected sample of around 5000 RR Lyrae stars (left) and blue horizontal branch stars (right), where they analyzed the mass profile of the Milky Way between 10 and 80 kpc (33,000-260,000 light-years). When a joint analysis was conducted for each one, and the data was combined together, a total mass of around 640 billion solar masses was found enclosed within that radius, with an uncertainty of only 6-7%.
Credit: DESI Collaboration, Astrophysical Journal submitted/arXiv:2611.05518, 2026

Within 80 kpc (260,000 light-years), 636 billion solar masses were robustly enclosed: within just 6-7%.

Two scatter plots showing enclosed mass versus radius for various Milky Way mass measurements, each with a trend line and a shaded confidence interval.

The red and blue data points, above, show the RR Lyrae and blue horizontal branch stars under the various analyses performed with joint DESI and Gaia data. Previous studies, shown in yellow, give far less precise results. When extrapolated out to over a million light-years in diameter, on the right side of the graph, the halo of the Milky Way sums up to 1.19 trillion solar masses, cumulatively.
Credit: DESI Collaboration, Astrophysical Journal submitted/arXiv:2611.05518, 2026

A mass estimate of 1.19 trillion solar masses was obtained over the entire galactic halo: with mere 10-12% uncertainties.

A scatter plot displaying Milky Way mass measurements from various studies, grouped by method, with a vertical shaded band indicating the consensus range for the total mass.

Compared with many previous studies estimating the mass of the Milky Way (colored points, below, labeled by method), the combination of DESI and Gaia data for halo horizontal branch stars yields the smallest uncertainties and the most precise mass estimate ever for the full, entire halo: at 1.19 trillion solar masses.
Credit: DESI Collaboration, Astrophysical Journal submitted/arXiv:2611.05518, 2026

A light Milky Way, as previously suggested, is now thoroughly disfavored.

Among its many discoveries, the ESA’s Gaia mission has found that the Milky Way Galaxy not only has a warp to its galactic disk, but that the warp in the disk precesses and wobbles, completing a full rotation for roughly every three revolutions of the Sun (in yellow) around the galactic center. Although studies of stars in the disk and near the galactic center suggested a light Milky Way with little dark matter, studies of distant halo stars now rule that interpretation out.

Credit: Stefan Payne-Wardenaar

Mostly Mute Monday tells an astronomical story in images, visuals, and no more than 200 words.

This article Astronomers weigh the Milky Way’s mass at long last is featured on Big Think.



Source link

Filed under: Philosophy

Selected by

Avatar photo

Im a doctor in training and I believe in a secular world