Since moving in at Number 10 and Number 10 North, Andy Burnham has sought to accelerate the shift of power, resources, and decision-making from Whitehall and Westminster to devolved institutions across England and the rest of the UK to empower communities and people in every postcode.
Burnham’s championing of a place-based devolution agenda offers an opportunity to reflect on an aspect of the growing profile of civic and policy engagement that universities and the higher education sector more widely have been somewhat reluctant to confront directly: public policy is inherently political. As universities increasingly embrace civic engagement, local partnerships, and place-based policy work, there is a need to recognise that the success of these activities is shaped not only by institutional capacity, evidence, and collaboration, but also by the realities of diversity in political leadership and political culture across multi-level governance frameworks in the UK.
Recent discussion of Burnham’s approach has rightly emphasised his ambition to deepen devolution and strengthen local leadership. What makes his approach distinctive, however, is that he appears to be advancing a vision of devolution that extends beyond England to develop an interdependent UK-wide approach to governance and public service reform. This represents a notable departure from the dominant logic that has shaped devolution since the late 1990s. Successive governments at Westminster have largely treated devolution as a series of national settlements, devolving powers independently to Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland while pursuing separate reforms within England. The result has been an asymmetrical and fragmented constitutional landscape. Burnham’s emphasis on policy diffusion between and across devolved territories, mayoral leadership, and public service reform suggests an alternative vision in which devolution is understood as a collective UK-wide endeavour.
The devolution era
As Kevin Morgan and John Tomaney have recently argued, Burnham appears to be driving “a new phase of devolution” which derives its political leadership from the North of England rather than from London, Scotland, or Wales. This shift is important because it repositions English city-regions as generators of constitutional innovation rather than simply recipients of powers delegated from Whitehall and Westminster. The current push towards the comprehensive roll-out of strategic authorities and the acceleration of local government reorganisation in England can similarly be understood as an effort to create more universal, if not uniform, forms of multi-level governance across the UK.
Yet Burnham’s vision is significant for another reason. Unlike many previous constitutional reform agendas, it explicitly connects devolution to public service reform. This reflects the experience of Greater Manchester, where devolution has been presented not merely as a constitutional settlement but as a vehicle for integrating services, improving outcomes, and strengthening collaboration across sectors. As mayor, Burnham’s political practice was grounded in a partnership-based ethos that brought together different levels of government, public services, businesses, civil society organisations, universities, and communities. The signing of the Greater Manchester Civic University Agreement in September 2021 highlighted the key role of universities in developing a landmark “quadruple helix” model of partnership working, policy innovation, and collaborative governance.
It is noteworthy, however, that since becoming Prime Minister, Burnham has stated that he will embed a “triple helix approach” to growth and innovation, rather than the “quadruple helix” model. There has been little detail added to the vague ambitions within the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act 2026 to enhance community engagement and empowerment through neighbourhood governance.
This shift raises important questions about power and democratic legitimacy in place-based governance. The inclusion of communities within a “quadruple helix” model can broaden participation and enhance the legitimacy and responsiveness of collaborative place-focused strategies. It may also complicate decision-making where community priorities conflict with the policy agendas of elected leaders. In such circumstances, tensions can emerge between authority derived from electoral mandates and the claims to legitimacy arising from different forms of community engagement participation. How any competing political and community priorities should be balanced within collaborative place-based working models is often overlooked but merits further consideration.
The politics of place
For universities, devolution has increased demand for research evidence, analytical capacity, and specialist expertise at the local and regional level. As the recent Universities Policy Engagement Network report on place-based academic-policy engagement observes, universities are increasingly being called upon to support place-based policymaking through new networks, institutes, and forms of engagement. Across the UK, numerous civic university and policy engagement institutions, initiatives, and networks have sought to strengthen the relationship between research, teaching, community, and public engagement and decision-making.
However, the expansion of place-based engagement also exposes a significant blind spot within higher education. Questions of political leadership, political ideology, and political competition often remain in the background of place-based approaches to civic and policy engagement. Yet they are becoming increasingly important.
For universities pursuing place-based engagement, navigating the UK’s system of multi-level governance presents significant challenges. Systems underpinning political leadership vary between tiers of government and across the UK. In England, local authorities most commonly operate a leader and cabinet-based model, strategic authorities are increasingly led by directly elected mayors, and the UK government draws on a hybrid form of political leadership that combines elements of cabinet government with increasingly presidential styles of prime ministerial leadership. These complexities are further compounded by uneven patterns of devolution across England, where some areas continue to operate within more traditional local government structures, or without a strategic authority.
Across Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland, devolved political institutions and policy environments create additional layers of variation in political leadership and party politics. As a result, universities must navigate diverse political leadership models and cultures, governance and civil service arrangements, and policy priorities. This means they face place-specific challenges in building relationships and partnerships across multiple political arenas. Universities must as such be sensitive to both shared and place-based policy agendas across multiple scales of government.
The UK’s devolved governance landscape is not only characterised by institutional diversity but by growing political leadership diversity. Different political parties now exercise power at multiple levels of government across the UK. Some possess extensive experience of governing; others have little or none. Some embrace collaborative approaches to policymaking; others are more sceptical of partnership working. Some actively seek evidence-informed policymaking; others prioritise political responsiveness, local identity, or ideological commitments. These differences matter in shaping the local conditions for place-based working.
Realising a UK-wide approach
One of the key challenges facing Burnham’s vision of a UK-wide approach to devolution is how this interacts with the politics of the devolved nations. He has described his established approach to devolution as one that prioritises place over party and problem-solving over point-scoring. His style of political leadership has consistently emphasised partnership working across public services, sectors, and institutions.
However, the success of this approach has been facilitated by the fact that much of his tenure as mayor took place within a relatively favourable political environment, with the combined authority’s constituent local authorities overwhelmingly under Labour control. As his devolution agenda expands into areas characterised by greater partisan diversity, the assumption that collaborative, place-based governance can transcend political differences may face more significant tests.
Politics will likely shape divergence in UK-wide intergovernmental relations. While England’s devolution agenda has largely been framed around demands for greater local autonomy, constitutional politics in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland are shaped by questions of national identity and constitutional sovereignty. Parties committed to independence from the UK currently hold significant political leadership within devolved institutions outside of England. This will inevitably affect the tone, priorities, and nature of place-based working across the UK.
The challenge is further complicated by institutional fragmentation across government. Bodies such as the Council of Nations and Regions and the Mayoral Council of England have yet to provide any clear oversight or coordination of devolution. Similarly, the role and remit of Number 10 North remains unclear. Meanwhile, the organisation and capacities of the civil service vary considerably across levels of government, as do the structures of the wider public sector. Creating genuinely integrated approaches to policymaking across these systems that are also place-sensitive presents a substantial challenge for the UK government.
Universities must be prepared for these realities. Place-based working cannot assume a politically neutral environment or coherent governmental landscape. In some places universities may be viewed as trusted civic partners. In others they may be perceived as representatives of metropolitan elites, particular social values or specific policy agendas. Some political leaders may actively seek university involvement in policymaking, while others may question the legitimacy or relevance of academic expertise. The sector cannot simply assume that research, evidence, and expertise will speak for themselves.
This raises a further challenge. Universities have what might be described as a “geography problem”. Higher education institutions are unevenly distributed across the UK and concentrated heavily within metropolitan areas. Yet devolution increasingly seeks to empower places that extend beyond major cities and towns. If universities are to support place-based development effectively, they must consider how civic leadership, knowledge exchange, and policy engagement can reach communities with limited direct access to higher education institutions.
Building political intelligence
The answer lies partly in recognising that place-based working requires political intelligence to complement the ongoing development of civic intelligence. Universities have become increasingly skilled at engaging with stakeholders, producing accessible evidence, and establishing local partnerships. What is now required is a deeper understanding of the political environments within which those partnerships operate.
This does not mean universities should become partisan. Quite the opposite. It means accepting that successful engagement requires understanding the incentives, pressures, and governing styles of different political actors and institutions. It means recognising that multi-level governance is shaped as much by political relationships as by institutional structures.
Encouragingly, there are signs that the sector is beginning to develop this capability. Political scientists and public policy scholars and practitioners are playing increasingly important roles in civic and policy engagement initiatives across the UK. Yet there remains considerable untapped potential. Universities possess substantial expertise on political institutions, electoral politics, democratic governance, public administration, and intergovernmental relations. Networks such as the Political Studies Association offer access to expertise too. Greater use of this knowledge could help the sector navigate the complexities of an increasingly devolved and politically diverse UK.
If Burnham’s vision represents the next phase of devolution, then universities must adapt accordingly. The future of place-based working will depend not simply upon stronger partnerships or better evidence, but upon a more sophisticated understanding of politics itself. Devolution is creating new centres of power across the UK. For universities seeking to contribute to local and regional place-based working, recognising that all public policy is inherently political may be the most important lesson of all.