The following recommendations are focussed on supporting universities’ place role in the short and longer-term. They are limited to the higher education and research policy arenas and are directed at tackling who has responsibility for the civic role, system changes required to elevate the positive impact on place, and the three main barriers and blockages to universities being civic (the way they are funded, regulated and measured).
The recommendations are grouped by what they do:
- Ownership of civic – who is responsible for the relationship between a university and its place
- Interim incentives – fixes to funding and measurement while ownership beds in
- System change – place as one of the terms of any future settlement
In isolation the recommendations provide incremental change and help – in a limited way – to incentivise the civic role. Collectively, they offer a strategic and systemic approach to helping universities have a bigger positive economic and social impact on the places they are part of.
Further reports will be published looking at how universities’ place role can be enhanced through policy outside of HE and Research.
A. Ownership of civic
These recommendations focus on the gap in responsibility for the civic place agenda, and detail ways to enable regulatory and institutional ownership of the agenda. Taken together, they amount to a constitution-in-embryo for place: an owner, a binding agreement, a counterparty with a seat at the table, and a collective regional voice.
1. OfS to become responsible body for civic/place
The OfS would become the responsible body for civic/place, and would give the university-place relationship an owner for the first time.
To do this, the government should introduce legislation so that the OfS is given a new statutory duty to have regard to place. This would formally promote collaboration between higher education providers and Further Education to ensure the right skills provision within each region, promote collaboration with other key public and private sectors in the university’s region, promote student choice and opportunity in each region, promote the efficient use of resources and value for money through collaborative working and services. As part of this, the OfS would become the responsible body ensuring each university has an effective partnership with its place. This must not become prescriptive, as each place is different, but would ensure each university adheres to an appropriate process in formalising effective relationships with stakeholders in their region.
2. Mandatory Civic University Agreements
Many universities have co-produced Civic University Agreements over the last seven years. These Agreements – locally developed – have made a tangible difference by putting the strategic needs of the place at the heart of a university’s approach. These agreements also recognise that each place has its own challenges and opportunities and any national programme which prescribed what should be in each Agreement would fail. However, as this is an entirely voluntary approach by universities there is little incentive to measure progress, and the quality and delivery of the Agreements are patchy across the country. In that regard, the Office for Students and UKRI should make this a mandatory exercise and require universities to submit a civic strategy and plan (this could be a reformed Civic University Agreement) for their civic area (this could be as a single university, or an Agreement which covers multiple universities in a place). The reformed agreements would include a plan for the skills and innovation provision for their region, alongside other priorities co-produced and co-signed with local and regional government. Each reformed Agreement would include long-term goals and annual milestones. There would be an expectation that the signatories of the Agreement would report annually on progress. For universities that wish to have access to government funding for civic activity (see recommendations on incentives), a Civic Agreement / Strategy would be required.
3. Local and/or regional government on the board of Civic University Agreements
Alongside local and/or regional government shaping Civic University Agreements, there would be a requirement for them to be represented on any Civic Agreement Board which would not only produce the civic plan for the region, but also report annually on progress. This would ensure local and/or regional government has a stake in the civic priorities and how any funding for place is spent.
4. Catalyst support for regional networks
With increasing devolution and the need for universities to work together in their regions to speak as a collective voice to mayors, business and national government; the Office for Students and Research England should work with the sector to help to catalyse and foster regional networks of universities, like Midlands Innovation, London Higher, Yorkshire Universities, the newly formed West of England Universities and Universities North East. While universities should fund these networks, there could be a small amount of catalyst support (up to £5m) to develop new regional networks where required, to support the skills provision within these networks, and to form a national voice so that these emerging networks can themselves speak as one to national government. There should also be an expectation from the OfS and Research England that when collaborative bidding opportunities arise, they are directed via the regional networks.
B. Interim incentives
While the policy will to support the civic agenda should follow once the agenda has an owner, there is an urgent need in the meantime to fix the incentives that shape universities’ civic role.
5. Strategic Priorities Grant and Strategic Priorities Funding
Access to certain funding opportunities would be open to universities that have a Civic Agreement. This would include a larger Strategic Priorities Grant from the OfS and any future Strategic Priorities Funding from UKRI, ensuring that universities, government and agencies incentivise and prioritise the impact a university has on its place.
6. HEIF and KEF
There is currently a significant debate about who has control of HEIF funding, whether it should be controlled centrally or devolved. As per recommendation 3, the reformed Civic Agreements could provide a way for regional government to shape the priorities for how the funding is spent, even if the funding pot remains within Research England.
Beyond the current debate, the Government could look to review its longer-term approach to HEIF. In particular, the Office for Students and Research England could be directed to evaluate whether HEIF should be linked formally with the Knowledge Exchange Framework. The purpose would be to provide credibility to the KEF and simultaneously have an additional mechanism to measure the impact of HEIF funding. They should also evaluate the feasibility of reforming the KEF so that it becomes a CKEF (Civic and Knowledge Exchange Framework), ensuring there is an evaluation on the economic and social impact on a university’s town, city and region that goes beyond KE activity so it is providing a holistic picture. Following the formal link between CKEF and HEIF the Government should look to increase the allocation of HEIF from £284m in 2026–27 to at least £500m annually.
7. Reweighting existing measurement criteria
As part of or following on from the wider Tertiary/HE Review (see below), the Treasury alongside Research England and the OfS should review the feasibility of redirecting and/or reweighting existing funding mechanisms – QR, REF, HEIF, and R&D tax credits. The emphasis would be on changing criteria, weightings, and conditions to incentivise place impact, including a cost/benefit analysis for any proposed change.
C. Civic at the centre of system change
Alongside the issue of ownership and interim incentives, it is vital that the civic/place agenda is front and centre of any wider change to the higher education system: place should be one of the terms of any future settlement, not an afterthought.
8. Place and the tertiary review
If and when the Government launches a major review (a new Dearing, for example) of the higher education or broader tertiary system, it must include ‘place’ as a key part of its terms of reference for that review, so that the system’s impact on place is a major feature of whatever settlement the review reaches. In other words, that review would need to consider the full impact of the reforms and system on local places, including skills and discipline provision, innovation and business as well as cultural engagement.
9. Single department for HE, skills and research
Building on the recommendation set out in The Post-18 Project’s report A Ministry for Manchesterism10 and the ambitions set out in the Government’s Rewiring the State statement, the Government should remove higher education from the Department for Education and create a single department for HE, Skills, Innovation, Science, Research and Business. This department would, among several priorities, be tasked to ensure the broad HE and Research system contributes to economic and social wellbeing in ‘every postcode’.
