Lifestyle

The Freddy Krueger Technique of Purging Intrusive Thoughts

The Freddy Krueger Technique of Purging Intrusive Thoughts


In psychotherapy, bibliotherapy can be useful. But can a theme from a horror film be good therapy? A central idea from the Nightmare on Elm Street flicks can ground a technique in psychotherapy that I have found useful in working with clients with intrusive thoughts.

In one case, a client was referred to me with “pure O,” a type of obsessive-compulsive disorder that is not manifested in compulsive behavior but rather purely obsessive thoughts. This client worked as a limo driver and had the intrusive thought of his right foot becoming paralyzed when driving a passenger to their destination. The thought of the thought led the client to take time off from his job; he contemplated a different line of work to avoid the thought. However, the thought began to emerge while driving and not on the job.

My approach uses logic-based therapy (LBT), a form of rational-emotive behavior therapy I created that utilizes philosophy and logic to help clients overcome self-destructive emotions. One technique I use with clients suffering intrusive thoughts is philosophical imagery, in which the client first imagines themselves being back in a previous situation in which a thought intruded into their mind space. The client then assesses how bad the thought feels by using a negativity scale of 0 to 10, where 10 is the worst and 0 is neutral. Next, the client examines the thought while imagining it, contemplating a resonant philosophical mantra, combined with mindful breathing and supportive imagery. The client then rates the thought on the same scale while in this state of mindful breathing and contemplation.

In LBT, every flawed or irrational way we speak has a specific positive character trait or virtue that can fix it. Catastrophizing is matched to courage. This means identifying a philosophy that builds courage from the client’s perspective and overcomes the tendency to catastrophize. This is because courage is itself a philosophical construct that takes on different meanings for different clients depending on their worldview. In LBT, the client’s worldview is assessed, and the client chooses a mantra that builds the virtue in question from a worldview orientation. Worldviews can be existential, humanistic, theistic, ethical, pragmatic, mindfulness-based, and or stoic. This client tended to be existential. That is, the client felt empowered by contemplating freedom and autonomy over their own thoughts, feelings, and actions.

LBT provides a Toolbox of potentially client-resonant “philosophical antidotes” categorized by the specific virtue and worldview. For example, a client can search the courage category from each of the aforementioned worldview perspectives and receive a list of antidotes that can build courage from the selected worldview. Accordingly, I instructed my client to find a philosophical antidote or mantra for courage from the existential category that resonated with him—a mantra that felt compelling and empowering. The client selected the following antidote:

  • Antidote: “The only way to deal with fear is to face it directly.”—Source: Søren Kierkegaard, The Concept of Anxiety
  • Category: Existential Antidote
  • Appeal:
    • Resilience and Growth Appeal: Frames fear as a challenge to overcome rather than avoid.
    • Heroic and Aspirational Appeal: Encourages individuals to rise above fear by confronting it courageously.
  • Analysis: Courage is built through direct engagement with fear, leading to personal growth and empowerment.
  • Language Sensitivity: Replace “I can’t face this” with “I grow stronger by confronting my fears.”
  • Actionable Component: Identify one fear you’ve been avoiding. Take one small, direct action to address it today.

During the next session, I asked the client to imagine that they were driving a passenger and the thought of their right foot becoming paralyzed intruded into their mind space. When the client confirmed that the thought was in mind, I asked them to rate how it felt. They gave the thought a 10 on the 10-point negativity scale.

I then asked the client to think, “The only way to deal with fear is to face it directly. This will make me stronger.” I instructed him to breathe in the strength of facing fear directly (through the nose) and breathe out (through the mouth) the intruding thought, using imagery such as the exhaled thought dropping into a box with a lid closing on it. This client used imagery of the thought evaporating into the clouds when exhaled.

The client proceeded with the exercise while I observed him for about a minute until his breathing appeared more relaxed. I then asked him to rate the idea again, while he continued to contemplate the mantra. The client now gave the thought a 0 on the same negativity scale.

Like the Nightmare on Elm Street character, Freddy Krueger, the thought only had power over the client when he feared it. When the client confronted the thought directly in his imagination and drew strength from it, the thought no longer had power over the client. It was nothing, a goose egg on the negativity scale.

On the other hand, this client had previously tried distraction as a way of dealing with the thought, for example, trying to engage in talking to his customers while driving, but the thought kept re-emerging when the client stopped distracting himself. This is because distraction dignified the thought as something substantial or real, something to try to escape.

What if these thoughts have no existential merit? Why try to escape a thought with no referent? Why run from literally nothing?

There is a logical error known as the reification fallacy: supposing that because we can imagine or speak about something that it must exist. It’s like saying that because we can imagine Freddy (or a unicorn), then such a thing exists. However, statements about non-existent objects are false, not true. They make existential claims (something corresponds to a given description) that are simply false.

By facing the thought directly, the client no longer had to hide from it, and the thought ceased to exercise power over him. Like Freddy, the thought had no ontological status of its own. It was just an empty vessel, an image of a false description in the client’s fearful imagination, just like Freddy in the dreams of those who feared him. When the client looked the fear in the face, there was literally nothing to fear.



Source link