Lifestyle

Dealing With a Bully? What the Science Says to Do

Dealing With a Bully? What the Science Says to Do

With a new school year starting, and some not-so-good role models for our children in the news, it may be time to recall what research tells us about how to deal with a bully. In a recent well-cited review of the effectiveness of anti-bullying programs and recommendations for solutions, Christina Salmivalli and her colleagues at the University of Turku in Finland found that we may be overselling efforts to address bullying through formal interventions. First, though, a little about bullies and bullying.

Narcissism and Attention-Seeking

Bullies need to feed their narcissism. They cannot stand it when someone tells them they are wrong. Or weak. Or flawed. They must always perceive themselves as smarter and more important than everyone else. They have, however, one flaw: Their need for attention means they need victims.

That said, not all victims are equally vulnerable. According to Salmivalli, the age of the bullied child matters, with younger children more likely to be influenced positively by programs that influence the culture of a school or community and make bullying socially unacceptable. Unfortunately, older children, especially those between the ages of 13 and 15, respond far less well to such programs.

Helping a Child Cope With a Bully

Likewise, it can be difficult to say with certainty the best way to help a child cope with a bully. Strategies that hold the most hope include letting parents know what’s happening and encouraging them to support their child. Encouraging informal discussions among kids themselves is also a good idea. These informal approaches tend to report better outcomes in comparison to targeted interventions that teach children not to bully, or efforts to get bystanders to step in and help. Instead, less formal strategies may be easier for children to accept. When those who are bullied and those watching the bullying name the behavior for what it is (a narcissist trying to elevate their status), and lots of people condemn what the bully is doing, then it is more likely the bully becomes the one who is weakened rather than their victims.

Once there is agreement that the bully is acting badly, the bully is effectively undermined, labelled for what they are: a social misfit doing harm to others. Meanwhile, those who are bullied are provided with the empathy they need to maintain a sense of well-being. It seems that a little support from many different people goes a long way to giving back to those who are bullied their self-respect.

Status also plays a role in these patterns of interaction between bullies and those they bully. Bullies tend to be people who are perceived as popular but not necessarily liked. Their attacks on those with lesser status are an easy win for them, but increasingly, research is suggesting that bullies also attack higher-status peers because it brings the bully even more power.

So, what else works besides informal networks of people who create a culture that labels the act of bullying as distasteful and a sign of weakness? Capitulation does not work. Giving in to endless erratic and senseless demands by a bully only makes bullies feel and act with impunity. Negotiating with a bully is senseless, too, as they don’t want to share power: They want the status that comes from power over others. No wonder that paying a bully to be left alone (e.g., giving in to extortion) is not a great strategy that works long-term either. The bully will just keep pushing, and pushing, and pushing for more power (and the child’s lunch money) because power is what protects a bully’s fragile sense of self-esteem.

Likewise, having others defend the victim may work, but the best strategy is to simply secure allies. Not formal defenders, but those who become friends and stand with the child who is bullied. Think of this as not so much a direct attack on the actions of the bully but an affirmation that those who are bullied are better than the bully. To exist in a community of people who empathize with what a bullied child is experiencing increases the bullied child’s status. It is an inoculation against feelings of self-loathing. It encourages the victim of bullying to ignore the darn bully, turn their back on them, and seek out places where a bullied child can feel whole and appreciated, preventing those who are bullied from feeling isolated and weak.

Even better, laugh at the bully, behind their back if one must. Bullies, after all, hate to be seen as small or ignored. It reminds them how silly they look and how little power they actually have in the eyes of their peers.

It’s not easy to use these strategies when the bullying is incessant. If the science is solid, however, then what we know is that those who are bullied may experience the resilience to live through the bullying and grow to be much stronger, happier, and better connected by relying on their informal networks of like-minded peers and adults. And those are the last things the bully wants their victims to experience, if only because those are the very things the bully craves but fails to achieve.



Source link