Richard L. Kravitz and Dominique Ritley
This blog post is based on the Evidence & Policy article, ‘An academic–legislative partnership for evidence-based policy: the California State Policy Evidence Consortium (CalSPEC)’.
Researchers and policymakers need each other, but each group is constrained by its own conventions, vocabularies, and norms. Researchers value evidence that is reproducible, valid, and generalizable; policymakers prioritise research that is timely, actionable, and specific. The California State Policy Evidence Consortium (CalSPEC) was created to bridge this divide by connecting university research with real-world policymaking in the California state legislature.
There is no shortage of academic units and think tanks producing research monographs and policy briefs. CalSPEC was distinctive in two respects: it aimed to muster resources across an entire university system (specifically, the University of California’s 10-campuses and 70,000 faculty and academic researchers) to address critical problems in state policy, and it was a genuinely collaborative effort, with legislative committee staff involved in topic selection and question development from the start.
Over two research cycles (May 2022 – January 2023; February 2023 – January 2024), CalSPEC assembled university experts from six UC campuses to produce evidence reviews on two topics co-developed with legislative committees: microplastics and near-roadway indoor air pollution. In each case, teams conducted literature searches, built evidence tables, drafted narrative summaries, obtained peer review, and delivered monograph-length reports respectful of the legislative calendar.
The results were mixed. The microplastics report landed at a moment when media attention was surging and legislators were crafting related bills. It was cited in bill analyses and referenced in a U.S. Senator’s letter to the Government Accountability Office. The near-roadway air pollution report, while praised for its quality, found less traction as it bumped against a closed policy window.
Lessons learned
Our programme evaluation – combining quantitative impact measures with qualitative interviews of legislators, committee staff, faculty, and university administrators – yielded five key lessons.
Relationships matter as much as research. Evidence alone rarely influences policy; policymakers use research when they trust the people behind it. But trust takes time, and CalSPEC’s two-and-a-half-year pilot was arguably too short to build durable relationships. Legislative staff, who often remain long after termed-out legislators leave, are especially important to cultivate as long-term partners.
Be an honest broker, not only a science arbiter. CalSPEC deliberately chose to summarise evidence without making policy recommendations to preserve neutrality. In retrospect, greater impact could have come from presenting policy options or assessing recommendations from other credible sources.
Timing and accessibility are everything. The microplastics report succeeded partly because media attention and legislative interest peaked simultaneously. But even well-timed reports must be digestible. With over 4,000 bills per session, legislators need the headline. CalSPEC’s voluminous reports were too long. Concise formats – policy briefs, infographics, oral briefings – deserved greater emphasis.
Dissemination requires its own investment. Producing a high-quality report is necessary but insufficient. CalSPEC could have committed more resources to media outreach, podcast appearances, op-eds, personal briefings for key legislators, and engagement with advocacy groups and state agencies to amplify its impact.
Organisational sustainability requires coalition-building. CalSPEC is currently on hiatus as a casualty of the state’s budget crisis, underscoring that academic–legislative partnerships need durable funding models and broad coalitions of support to keep the flywheel turning.
Conclusion
CalSPEC demonstrated that a major public university system can produce rigorous, policy-relevant evidence synthesis on a legislative timetable. The project built new working relationships between university scholars and legislative staff, and it advanced the service mission of the university. But its measurably modest short-term impact is a reminder that even high-quality evidence often fails to move the policy needle without sustained relationship-building, strategic communication, and attention to the political currents that determine when – and whether – research gets a hearing. The stakes are high, both for policymakers who want decisions tethered to evidence and for scholars who want to remain relevant.
IImage credit: Author’s own. Photo by Dominique Ritley.
Richard L. Kravitz, founding director of CalSPEC, is a professor of internal medicine at the UC Davis School of Medicine.
Dominique Ritley, co-director of CalSPEC, is senior health policy researcher with the UC Davis Center for Healthcare Policy and Research.
Read the original research in Evidence & Policy:
Kravitz, R. L., Walters, H., Padilla, K., Lingbloom, L., Corbett, G., & Ritley, D. (2026). An academic–legislative partnership for evidence-based policy: the California State Policy Evidence Consortium (CalSPEC). Evidence & Policy, DOI: 10.1332/17442648Y2026D000000084.
If you enjoyed this blog post, you may also be interested in reading:
Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed on this blog site are solely those of the original blog post authors and other contributors. These views and opinions do not necessarily represent those of the Policy Press and/or any/all contributors to this site.
