Lifestyle

Are You a Collector or Hoarder, or Are You an In-between?

Are You a Collector or Hoarder, or Are You an In-between?

In 2009, an art installation called Waste Not traveled from Beijing to New York, London, Vancouver, and Sydney. It consisted of ordinary household objects, bottle caps, toothpaste tubes, shoes, and kitchen utensils, all saved over decades by Zhao Xiangyuan, the mother of artist Song Dong. Her son had worried for years that her overstuffed Beijing house was harming her health. Rather than purging her possessions, he sat with her and sorted every item, laying them out in rows grouped by size, color, and use. Not one thing was thrown away. In doing this, something remarkable happened. What had looked like a hoard became a collection, at least in the eyes of museum visitors.

That transformation sits at the heart of a thought-provoking article by anthropologist Katie Kilroy-Marac of the University of Toronto, published in the Journal of Material Culture. Her central question is one I have been curious about throughout my professional life as a collector of Chinese export porcelain. What, exactly, is the difference between a collection and a hoard? And, is there an in-between?

Kilroy-Marac suggests it is not quantity that separates a collector from a hoarder

Most people assume the difference is volume. The hoarder has too much. The DSM-5, the diagnostic manual psychiatrists use, says otherwise. In its Diagnostic Features section for Hoarding Disorder, the manual acknowledges that, in some cases of collecting, the number of possessions may be similar to that accumulated by a person with hoarding disorder. In other words, the sheer number of objects does not, by itself, separate health from pathology.

Then, what does? Kilroy-Marac answers this. She did not rely on impressions. She drew on multiple, independent lines of evidence. For her research, she spent two years as a participant observer with the Toronto Hoarding Coalition, a working group of social workers, public health nurses, fire officials, and cleaning specialists. She conducted 21 semi-structured ethnographic interviews with professional home organizers in the Greater Toronto Area between 2014 and 2015. Also, she analyzed the clinical research that shaped the DSM-5 diagnosis itself, most notably the work of Nordsletten and colleagues, who compared 20 self-identified collectors with 29 people meeting criteria for Hoarding Disorder.

That comparative study found that both groups acquired objects, attached to them, and hesitated to discard them. The collectors, however, were more focused, confining themselves to a narrow range of items, were more selective, planning purchases in advance, and were more likely to organize their possessions, and less likely to accumulate excessively. Roughly 30 percent of the general population collects something, and collecting is generally psychologically beneficial. Hoarding, by contrast, produces disorganized clutter, distress, and impairment in relationships, work, and daily life.

Attentiveness and attachment

Kilroy-Marac distills the distinction into two concepts, thing attentiveness and thing attachment.

Attentiveness is active curation. The collector holds the entire collection in mind at once, knows every item, where it sits, what it means, and what is still missing. The collection is displayed, and most often separate from everyday things. A hoard, on the other hand, is a mass of stuff, which might include newspapers, dust, and debris. It shows no visible sign of intention.

Attachment concerns emotional distance. Collectors are passionate, but they temper that passion. They talk about their objects, share them, trade them, and even brag about them. Hoarders, in the popular and clinical imagination, care too much and not enough at the same time. They are so absorbed in their possessions that the boundary between person and object blurs. Yet, they are unable to maintain or protect what they own. Tellingly, about half the hoarding participants in the Nordsletten study called themselves collectors and could name at least one collection within their hoard. Their diagnosis, however, effectively overruled them because they were unlikely to plan, organize, or share their collections as collectors typically do.

A necessary note of caution

What makes this article worthy of an academic journal, rather than a lifestyle magazine, is that Kilroy-Marac does not stop at the checklist. She asks who gets to draw the line. In the clinical comparison, the collectors were more often men, partnered, educated, and living in larger homes, though this stereotype is changing as more women enter the workplace and have their own resources. Also, Kilroy-Marac’s concept that hoarders are more often women is no longer valid, as a more recent meta-analysis has shown this is not true. Yet, when everyone can accumulate everything, it is no longer the ownership of things that confers collector status. It is how we order them.

Why this matters

Kilroy-Marac’s framework also maps neatly onto what brain science has begun to reveal. The cognitive-behavioral model of hoarding proposed by Frost and Hartl identifies deficits in categorization and decision-making as core features, precisely the sorting failures described. Further, neuroimaging by Tolin and colleagues shows that when people with a hoarding disorder must decide whether to discard a possession, the anterior cingulate cortex and insula, regions that weigh significance and emotional salience, respond abnormally. Every object feels consequential, so nothing can be released. The collector’s brain, by contrast, appears to run on Panksepp’s SEEKING circuit, the dopaminergic engine of anticipation and pursuit, channeled through focus, selectivity, and the deep pleasure of completing a set. Attentiveness and attachment, it turns out, are not just cultural judgments. They reflect measurably different patterns of neural activity.

And lastly, I believe there is a very small group that are neither collectors nor hoarders but lie somewhere in the middle of the two. This is an area I hope to explore in the future: the in-betweens.



Source link