A video has been making the rounds on social media. In it, a well-known speaker warmly and confidently says, “How you feel about yourself is the most important choice you will ever make. These negative thoughts about yourself only persist because you keep choosing to believe them. If you repeat a different thought, you will become a different person.” I watched the clip and understood its intention, but I also felt a tightness in my chest.
I believe this message gets something fundamentally wrong.
We do not simply choose how we feel about ourselves. That process begins long before we can choose.
Our relationship with ourselves is shaped through thousands of developmental and relational experiences that become part of how we see ourselves and the world.
The problem is, I’ve worked with many people who tried exactly what was suggested. They chose, affirmed, journaled, and repeated these steps. They did everything they were told, but years later, they came to see me feeling even more ashamed than before. They were told the solution was simple, but when it didn’t work, they believed something must be wrong with them.
Life is complex. Our relationship to ourselves is complex. It is not all or nothing. It is everything, all at once.
How do we come to feel what we feel about ourselves?
Our relationship with ourselves doesn’t start in adulthood or with a thought we choose to believe. It begins in our earliest months, shaped by the kind of attention we receive, whether our needs are met or ignored, and whether being close to our caregivers feels safe or uncertain.
The brain develops from the bottom up. Early experiences with caregivers help shape the systems responsible for safety, stress regulation, and connection. When a child’s stress response is activated too often, development is disrupted, leaving later emotional and relational capacities built on a less stable foundation (Gertel Kraybill, 2018).
We don’t remember these early experiences as clear memories. Instead, they are stored in our bodies, shaping our automatic expectations and our sense of what it means to connect with others. These early patterns become the framework for how we see everything that comes after.
This isn’t simply important for people with a trauma diagnosis. It matters to all of us. Everyone experiences moments of misattunement. Even the most attentive caregiver cannot meet every need. According to Schore and Schore (2008), these breaks are a normal part of development. What matters is repair. When caregivers reconnect, children learn that relationships can survive disconnection and return to safety.
But if misattunement keeps happening and there’s no repair, a different lesson is learned. The nervous system starts to believe that relationships are unpredictable and unsafe. Needs feel risky, and being on guard seems safer than trusting. Underlying the struggles that follow is usually a strong effort to connect in whatever way the person knows how (Gertel Kraybill, 2018).
This pattern isn’t limited to severe neglect or abuse. Most of us fall somewhere along a spectrum of relational experiences. The intensity differs, but the underlying process is the same.
Children who do not frequently experience attunement are unable to form secure attachments. And this applies not only to relationships with others, but also to their relationship with themselves, to their own needs, their own sense of being worthy of care (Gertel Kraybill, 2018).
Where self-help culture misses the mark
The wellness industry doesn’t mean harm. Most people giving self-improvement advice genuinely want to help. But the message behind most of these suggestions, no matter how kindly they’re shared, is that you can change how you feel about yourself right now if you want it enough. So if you haven’t changed, it feels like you just didn’t want it badly enough.
For someone who already believes deep down that they aren’t enough, this isn’t encouragement. It feels like proof.
Oversimplifying this process can cause real harm. When people don’t get the promised results, they rarely blame the method. They blame themselves. I see this every week in people who have followed every piece of advice they could find, only to conclude that they are the problem.
What can help
I’m not saying change is impossible. I’ve seen significant change take place, and I’ve experienced it myself. But the way change really happens isn’t what most self-help advice describes. We don’t change just by picking better thoughts or deciding to love ourselves. Changing negative thoughts to positive ones isn’t enough.
Real change happens when we feel safe. More specifically, it’s about feeling safe in relationships. This sense of safety, predictability, and connection to ourselves develops through our relationships with others (Gertel Kraybill, 2018). If our nervous system learned to expect threat in relationships, it can only learn safety through new, safe relationships.
This isn’t only an idea. It’s how our nervous system actually works. The aim of trauma integration is to help people deeply feel that they are safe, worthy, and lovable. This isn’t a mental exercise. It develops slowly through relationships where those experiences are real.
One of the most powerful moments in therapy is when someone realizes: This isn’t who I am. It’s something that happened to me. And now I’m doing something about it (Gertel Kraybill, 2018). That understanding doesn’t come from thinking differently. It comes from experiencing a relationship that feels safe enough to support it.
It is not realistic, and that matters
It’s not realistic to think someone can simply decide to feel differently about themselves. Insight, willpower, or repetition alone can’t change nervous system patterns that were formed before we had language, memory, or the ability to choose.
It’s also unrealistic to expect this work to be quick. Developmental trauma needs a complex response and affects every part of our well-being: emotional, mental, physical, spiritual, and social (Gertel Kraybill, 2018). Even for people without a trauma diagnosis, changing how we feel about ourselves through relationships is slow, unpredictable, and deeply human.
When we pretend this work is easy and it isn’t, the people who get hurt most are those who are already vulnerable. They chase the promised results, don’t reach them, and add that disappointment to the burdens they already carry.
There are no shortcuts and no simple happy endings. Life and our relationship with ourselves are complex. It’s not all or nothing. It’s everything at once. This work invites patience, honesty, and the safety of a therapeutic relationship rather than chasing a version of healing that doesn’t reflect reality.
Healing is the slow, relational work of learning to live with what is, to its fullest. Not only joy, but grief. Not only confidence, but uncertainty. Not only the parts of ourselves we like, but all of who we are.
