It is difficult to tell twins apart, especially identical twins, because they look so similar and their behaviors are also very much alike. Learning to see the real differences between twins can be extremely difficult for new parents, who are not aware of the difficulty twins may have separating from each other. It is so very critical that gradually twins and their parents develop a singular relationship with each other as they develop individuality.
How Do Twins Develop Individual Relationships With Parents?
In other words, Twin A is more in need of comfort than Twin B, who thrives on adventure. Mother and father have to give each twin what they need. Twin A does not want to learn how to ride a roller coaster. Twin A wants to be pushed on the swing at the park by her gentle mom. Twin B gets bored on the swing and wants to try the longest slide in the park. Dad is very willing to go down the slide with her. Twin A is afraid of the slide. These differences create unique relationships between each twin and their parents. Differences in preferences for food, activities, and friendships begin to establish different parent-child relationships that are crucial to develop unique aspects of each child’s identity.
There is much curiosity concerning why parents favor one twin over the other. It is related to the labeling of twins as opposites, as the good twin and the bad twin. Most likely, parents see labeling as an easy way to differentiate twins superficially. Most twins who have been split between “good” and “bad” are understandably upset. Twins who are treated as opposites of one another and know of my research and writing on twin identity always ask me, “Why did this happen? Is it my fault? Was I constantly causing trouble?”
I can find no answer to labelling twins as opposites that makes any sense or that reflects serious thought that went into the decision. In reality, like many twins I have worked with, I was the bad twin and my sister was the good twin for no known reason or no good reason. It seems like it just happens in the parents’ attempt to relate to each child as their own person. Unfortunately, favoring one twin is an extremely detrimental way to develop identity differences between twins and creates long-term problems. Or said in a different way; “Why is it acceptable to call one twin the good one and the other twin the bad one?” Or various other opposite labels, such as the “smart” twin and the “slow” twin. The “outgoing” twin and the “withdrawn” twin are also common ways that are ultimately harmful to natural and normal identity development for both of the twin pair.
Why Are Opposite Labels Harmful to Twins’ Identity?
Parents have to find real differences between their children because opposite labels will undermine the child’s sense of self and self-esteem. Opposite labels are statements like “Twin A is a better reader” and “Twin B is more social and makes friends for the pair.” This splitting aspect of personal identity makes learning harder and competition between the twins much stronger, and can contribute to intense physical and verbal abuse later on, years and decades later, as the labels persist.
There are other aspects of labeling that are very dangerous to identity development. Often one twin takes over one skill like reading and the other twin takes over another skill like math or history. Twin sharing of learning creates very serious problems. A humorous example comes from a parent of twins in London who called to ask if one of her twins had neurological issues. This child was in school and her twin sister was home sick in bed. The twin at school could not read a word and the teachers thought that she was suffering from a neurological problem. The twin at home was doing all of her homework easily and well. After much deliberation with the parents it became clear to me that the non-reading twin was always copying her sister and had not learned to read. The parents began reading with the twin that lagged behind and she no longer appeared to have a neurological issue.
The Power of the Twin Bond
I often get questions from parents of twins who ask me about the best way to raise twins. In general, developing an understanding of each child and not comparing them is the most effective way to raise twins to get along and learn to talk to one another. I realize that knowing twins for who they really are and not comparing them is easier said than done. And when you add in the power of the twin bond to complicate objective differences you can be sure that developing individuality is a difficult and ongoing problem.
Twins easily imitate each other for comfort and for fun. Some twins think that it is funny to trick people or confuse them. I know that my sister and I did this to others when we thought that we could get away with it. My favorite example is when we pretended we were our twin (the other twin). I was Marjorie and she was Barbara and we took our language tests in disguise. I took the French test for her and she took the Hebrew test for me. And we both got A’s. It was the wrong way to handle identity confusion, but it was a very effective way to improve our academic grades. Today, a twin called to tell me she had pretended to be her sister without asking and a huge argument was restarted.
On some level it was and still is valuable to talk to non-twins about how Marjorie and I hated being compared. Actually I think that non-twins really do not understand how painful comparison was and is. But at least it helped my sister, and other twins I have consulted with, to learn about the pitfalls and danger of comparing twins. Being a twin was and still is very hard and not as much fun as people imagine.
Understanding Twins Essential Reads
How Can Twins Develop Their Own Individuality?
Knowing who you are in relationship to your sister or brother is essential. For example, “My twin sister Amy loves potato chips and I don’t like them at all. She likes to wear jeans to school and I would never wear jeans to school because I think it is sloppy looking. Amy hangs out with the popular girls and I hang out with the smart girls. Amy likes to date and I like to read. We are very different in our interests and friendships.”
Obviously there are different and maybe more serious ways that twins are different, which develop as they grow and mature. By avoiding sharing clothes, friends, homework and special interests, you will accentuate the development of differences with your twin. My twin sister and I found that we liked different school subjects and wanted to study different things. She was interested in writing and poetry and I was intrigued by history. These early differences blossomed into very different but substantial careers. She became a rhetorical writing professor at Stanford and I wrote books on twin development. I studied psychology and education and followed different aspects of having a career in those fields.
As twins age it is easier to hold on to your sense of self and still find time to be a twin with your twin. By this I mean you more easily can share objects, people, and life experiences together without feeling jealous or inadequate. While twin issues with competition and comparison may continue to haunt you, it is easier to deal with them with honesty and perspective. Your sister goes to Europe for a summer holiday and you go hiking in the mountains near where you live. Both of you accept that comparing your experiences is not important.
Suggestions to Avoid Copying Your Twin
- Do not share friends, clothes, or accomplishments.
- Appreciate your differences and compliment your twin.
- Make family events a special time.
- Avoid competition and comparison.
Ways to Become More Your True Self
- Learn and follow your interests.
- Make your own friends.
- Spend time alone every day without your twin.
