All posts tagged: special counsel

How Hur Misled the Country on Biden’s Memory

How Hur Misled the Country on Biden’s Memory

First impressions stick. After a big story hits, the initial conclusions can turn out to be wrong, or partly wrong, but the revisions are not what people remember. They remember the headlines in imposing font, the solemn tone from a presenter, the avalanche of ironic summaries on social media. Political operatives know this, and it’s that indelible impression they want, one that sticks like a greasy fingerprint and that no number of follow-ups or awkward corrections could possibly wipe away. Five years ago, a partisan political operative with the credibility of a long career in government service misled the public about official documents in order to get Donald Trump the positive spin he wanted in the press. The play worked so well that a special counsel appointed to examine President Joe Biden’s handling of classified documents, Robert Hur, ran it again. In 2019, then–Attorney General Bill Barr—who would later resign amid Trump’s attempts to suborn the Justice Department into backing his effort to seize power after losing reelection—announced that Special Counsel Robert Mueller had not …

How the Steele Dossier Broke the Media

How the Steele Dossier Broke the Media

The parallel was striking—but perhaps no one wanted to see it. Last week, corruption allegations that underpinned the House GOP’s push to impeach President Joe Biden collapsed after federal prosecutors charged Alexander Smirnov, the informant who’d brought them forward, with lying to the FBI. The Biden impeachment was never about the substance of the allegations against him; it was revenge for what former President Donald Trump’s allies view as witch hunts against him. After Trump was impeached twice, Republicans were always going to search for some cause to impeach Biden—preferably one that involved just the kind of untoward foreign dealings of which Trump was accused. Instead, the conservative media and House Republicans seem to have blundered into their own version of the Steele dossier, the infamous collection of allegations against Trump gathered before the 2016 election. Both stories involve dubious dealings in the hall of mirrors that is the former Soviet Union, an FBI informant with sketchy intelligence ties, and accusations that Russian intelligence planted false information. And in both cases, the underlying information has …

The Memory Hole | Fintan O’Toole

The Memory Hole | Fintan O’Toole

An empty bucket, a Zappos shoebox, potting soil, a collapsed dog crate, a dog bed, a broken lamp wrapped in duct tape, some synthetic firewood—the flotsam and jetsam of the half-forgotten years. These leftovers from past lives accumulate in suburban garages as the people who once wanted them get older and older. Useless and unnoticed, they yet cling on doggedly until time does its work, their owners depart for good, and new people move in and take them to the dump. But this particular jumble of detritus has been rescued from oblivion and given a new home in the eternal archives of US history. For it included another item: a damaged box containing classified documents relating to America’s failed war in Afghanistan. That box, like Pandora’s, contained a whole world of trouble. From it has emerged the reality that the Democrats have been trying to evade—the vulnerability created by Joe Biden’s senescence.   In the report of the special counsel Robert Hur into Biden’s retention of official documents at his homes, there is a photograph …

Biden Cleared In Special Counsel Classified Documents Probe

Biden Cleared In Special Counsel Classified Documents Probe

President Joe Biden and his aides will not face any charges as part of a special counsel investigation into his handling of classified documents, the Justice Department announced on Thursday. Special counsel Robert Hur said in his report that while Biden “wilfully retained and disclosed classified materials after his vice presidency when he was a private citizen,” no criminal charges were warranted. The president rejected those findings in a press briefing on Thursday, saying any claim he had wilfully retained the papers was “misleading and just plain wrong.” He moved to cast the episode as far different than the documents found at former President Donald Trump’s Mar-a-Lago resort. “It wasn’t out there like in Mar-a-Lago, in a public place,” Biden said. “I wish I had paid more attention to how the documents were being moved. I thought it was being moved into the archives, I thought all of it was being moved.” “They made a firm conclusion,” he added. “I did not break the law, period.” Thursday’s release concludes a yearlong saga after the president’s …

If Russia wins – The Atlantic

If Russia wins – The Atlantic

This is an edition of The Atlantic Daily, a newsletter that guides you through the biggest stories of the day, helps you discover new ideas, and recommends the best in culture. Sign up for it here. Ukrainian defenses are in danger of being destroyed and overrun because House Republicans refuse to provide ammunition and aid. If Russia wins this war, the consequences could be catastrophic. First, here are three new stories from The Atlantic: What Could Happen Ukraine is fighting for the lives of its people and its very existence, and it is running out of ammunition. If the United States does not step back in with aid, Russia could eventually win this war. Despite the twaddle from propagandists in Moscow (and a few academics in the United States), Russia’s war is not about NATO, or borders, or the balance of power. The Russian dictator Vladimir Putin intends to absorb Ukraine into a new Russian empire, and he will eradicate the Ukrainians if they refuse to accept his rule. Europe is in the midst of …

The Special Counsel’s Devastating Charge Against Biden

The Special Counsel’s Devastating Charge Against Biden

Special Counsel Robert Hur leveled a devastating charge against Biden—just not a criminal one. Saul Loeb / AFP / Getty February 8, 2024, 4:04 PM ET A special counsel’s report into Joe Biden’s handling of classified material released today has good news for the president, and very bad news. The good news is that Robert Hur did not recommend charges against Biden, likely spelling the end of any legal jeopardy for sloppy storage of documents, though the report says that “the practice of retaining classified material in unsecured locations poses serious risks to national security.” The very bad news is that Hur delivered a devastating portrayal of Biden’s mental acuity, saying any jury would view him as “a sympathetic, well-meaning, elderly man with a poor memory.” Speculation about the extent to which Biden, the oldest president in American history, has lost a step has already been rampant. The president’s critics, including former President Donald Trump and many Republicans, have depicted Biden as senile. The president’s allies insist that he remains sharp, pointing to his record …

The Supreme Court Shouldn’t Punt on This One

The Supreme Court Shouldn’t Punt on This One

The Court needs to give the country a clear, final answer on Donald Trump’s eligibility for office. Illustration by The Atlantic. Source: Getty. January 28, 2024, 6:30 AM ET For the most part, America’s governing institutions have thus far responded to the problem of Donald Trump’s authoritarian aspirations by punting—passing the ball to some other actor in our political system. The criminal prosecutor Robert Mueller decided that Congress, not the Department of Justice, where he was special counsel, should assess whether Trump had committed any crimes in the 2016 election. Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell publicly blamed Trump for January 6 but voted to acquit him in his Senate impeachment trial anyway, on the grounds that holding Trump accountable for his actions was the responsibility of the courts. Similarly, the overwhelming majority of state election officials who have considered whether Trump should be deemed ineligible to appear on ballots have concluded that such decisions are really best left “up to the courts.” If anything is clear from the voluminous briefs filed recently with the Supreme …

The Achilles’ Heel of Democracy

The Achilles’ Heel of Democracy

Donald Trump’s trial on charges that he tried to overthrow the election will almost certainly not happen in March 2024, as many had hoped. If it doesn’t, Trump will have once again demonstrated that a commitment to due process is the Achilles’ heel of democracy. While democracy’s defenders play by the rules and the rule of law, Trump bends the law to his own purposes. That is the only conclusion one can reasonably draw from the latest Special Counsel filing, which asks the Supreme Court to hear immediately Trump’s claim of absolute immunity from prosecution. The claim is nonsensical, and the Special Counsel’s request for Supreme Court review is understandable (indeed, even commendable), but once again, Trump has succeeded in weaponizing the judicial process to his own advantage, using the delay that comes with Supreme Court review to postpone his trial to a more politically advantageous time for him. Trump was indicted this past summer on charges that he conspired to defraud the United States and obstruct an official proceeding in order to overturn the …

How Trump Gets Away With It

How Trump Gets Away With It

If Donald Trump regains the presidency, he will once again become the chief law-enforcement officer of the United States. There may be no American leader less suited to “take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed,” as the Constitution directs the president. But that authority comes with the office, including command of the Justice Department and the FBI. We know what Trump would like to do with that power, because he’s said so out loud. He is driven by self-interest and revenge, in that order. He wants to squelch the criminal charges now pending against him, and he wants to redeploy federal prosecutors against his enemies, beginning with President Joe Biden. The important question is how much of that agenda he could actually carry out in a second term. Explore the January/February 2024 Issue Check out more from this issue and find your next story to read. View More Trump tried and failed to cross many lines during his time in the White House. He proposed, for example, that the IRS conduct punitive audits of …

Donald Trump Is Any Defense Attorney’s Nightmare

Donald Trump Is Any Defense Attorney’s Nightmare

They say that a man who represents himself has a fool for a client. So, perhaps, does a person who represents Donald Trump. To most people, attacking someone with influence over one’s freedom and fortunes is self-evidently unwise, but that is precisely what Trump has been up to. This week, the former president attended a civil trial in Manhattan to determine what damages he might have to pay in a case about his company committing a massive, yearslong fraud. Justice Arthur Engoron, the judge in the case, has already ruled that fraud did occur, and Trump is furious about it. “This is a judge that should be disbarred,” he said outside of the court on Monday. “This is a judge that should be out of office. This is a judge that some people say could be charged criminally for what he’s doing. He’s interfering with an election.” David A. Graham: A guide to the cases against Trump The next day, Trump’s campaign issued a lengthy statement portraying Engoron as a Democratic operative, and Trump attacked …