Where’s the Science in Campaign Buttons?
Presidential politics first grabbed my attention in the leadup to the ’92 election due to a high school teacher’s collection of memorabilia. Every day, Mr. Urech passed around a presidential campaign button so we could feel history. Many buttons rhymed, such as I LIKE IKE and ALL THE WAY WITH L.B.J. Other buttons foreshadowed future campaigns such as REAGAN~BUSH IN ’80: LET’S MAKE AMERICAN GREAT AGAIN and ELECT HILLARY’S HUSBAND. None of the buttons, however, emphasized SCIENCE. The last time science and politics intersected on the cover of Skeptical Inquirer, Jeanne Goldberg made the case that America’s earliest presidents—George Washington, John Adams, James Madison, and Thomas Jefferson—“were citizen scientists” who delighted “in pursuing scientific topics” (see September/October 2017, p. 36). These presidents, Goldberg argued, “transported the scientific method of testing hypotheses and ideas, peer review, and free speech without fear of retaliation into a governmental context.” The checks and balances of science, it turned out, provided a useful defining foundation for a country based on freedom. Unfortunately, the pro-science views of our earliest leaders gave …